Love 2.0: How to Move On
In this episode of Hidden Brain, psychologist Antonio Pascual-Leone examines the complex process of moving on after a relationship ends. Through his own experience of trying to win back an ex-girlfriend, Pascual-Leone illustrates common post-breakup behaviors and explains why grand gestures often serve as avoidance mechanisms rather than genuine attempts at reconciliation.
The episode explores therapeutic strategies for processing breakups and gaining closure, including writing unsent letters and conducting empty chair conversations. Pascual-Leone's research reveals how the way people tell their breakup stories can impact their mental health outcomes, and he discusses the importance of grieving not just the relationship itself, but also the unrealized hopes and dreams it contained.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Oct 20, 2025 episode of the Hidden Brain
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
Common Problematic Behaviors and Reactions to Breakups
Antonio Pascual-Leone shares a personal story of making an elaborate public attempt to win back an ex-girlfriend, illustrating common post-breakup behaviors. He reflects on how such grand gestures often serve as avoidance behaviors, focusing more on personal needs than genuine reconciliation while potentially avoiding confronting the real issues that led to the breakup.
Emotional and Psychological Process Of Ending a Relationship
Shankar Vedantam and Antonio Pascual-Leone explain that ending a relationship involves a complex grieving process. Pascual-Leone emphasizes the importance of internal reflection and confronting difficult emotions rather than engaging in problematic behaviors like brooding or rushing into new relationships. He introduces the concept of "undeclared losses" or "surplus reality" - the unrealized hopes and dreams within the relationship that also need to be grieved.
Strategies For Gaining Closure and Moving Forward
Pascual-Leone discusses several therapeutic strategies for processing breakups. Writing unsent letters to ex-partners can help articulate feelings and create emotional clarity. He also explains the effectiveness of talking to empty chairs, a technique that allows individuals to work through unresolved issues and emotions without requiring the other person's presence. Through these methods, people can process their feelings and gain closure independently.
Storytelling's Role in Processing Relationship Endings
According to Pascual-Leone's research, the way people narrate their breakup experiences can predict their emotional and mental health outcomes. He notes that superficial or maladaptive narratives often correlate with higher levels of depression, anxiety, and trauma symptoms. The process of storytelling itself becomes a crucial tool for understanding, processing, and ultimately moving forward from relationship endings.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While grand gestures may often be avoidance behaviors, they can also be sincere attempts at reconciliation; not all such actions are inherently self-serving or avoidant.
- The grieving process is highly individual, and what may be seen as brooding or rushing into new relationships for some may actually be a part of their natural healing process.
- The concept of "undeclared losses" might not resonate with everyone, as some individuals may not feel a sense of lost future possibilities post-breakup.
- Writing unsent letters and talking to empty chairs, while therapeutic for some, may not be effective for everyone; different individuals may benefit from different strategies.
- The assumption that gaining closure independently is essential may not hold true for all individuals; some may find closure through new relationships or external support.
- The correlation between superficial or maladaptive narratives and mental health outcomes might not imply causation; other underlying factors could contribute to both the narratives and the mental health issues.
- Storytelling, while crucial for many, might not be the preferred or most effective tool for everyone in processing relationship endings; some may find solace in non-verbal expressions or other forms of processing.
Actionables
- Create a breakup narrative timeline to objectively assess the relationship's history and its end, which can help identify patterns and personal growth opportunities. Start by jotting down significant events and feelings from the beginning to the end of the relationship. This can include the good times, the challenges, and the moments leading to the breakup. By visualizing the relationship's trajectory, you can gain insights into what worked, what didn't, and how you've evolved, which can aid in developing a more balanced narrative and healthier closure.
- Develop a "future-self" journaling practice where you write letters from your future, healed self to your current self, offering perspective and encouragement. Imagine yourself a few months or years in the future, having fully processed the breakup and grown from the experience. Write down the advice your future self would give you about coping with the loss, learning from the relationship, and moving forward. This can help shift your focus from past regrets to future possibilities and reinforce the belief that healing and growth are achievable.
- Engage in creative expression activities, such as painting or songwriting, to channel and process the complex emotions of a breakup. Choose a form of creative expression that resonates with you and use it to convey the feelings and thoughts you're grappling with. For instance, you might paint an abstract piece that captures the tumult of your emotions or write a song that tells the story of your relationship's journey. This can serve as a therapeutic outlet and a tangible representation of your internal experience, fostering a deeper understanding and acceptance of the breakup.
Get access to the context and additional materials
Common Problematic Behaviors and Reactions to Breakups
Antonio Pascual-Leone recounts an episode following a breakup where he made an elaborate and public attempt to win back his ex-girlfriend.
Desperate Attempts to Quickly Replace Lost Relationships
Avoidance Behaviors After Loss: Anger or New Relationships
Pascual-Leone’s actions manifested as a form of avoidance behavior after the loss of his relationship. His choice to serenade his ex-girlfriend beneath her balcony with singing, poetry, and even fireworks was an intense effort to replace the lost connection. However, Pascual-Leone later realizes that this gesture was more of a performance focused on his own needs rather than a genuine attempt to reconcile the relationship.
Dwelling On Past Failures and Blaming Ex-partners
Reflecting on his extravagant act, Pascual-Leone understands that h ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Common Problematic Behaviors and Reactions to Breakups
Additional Materials
Actionables
- Reflect on your motivations before making grand romantic gestures by journaling your feelings and intentions. Write down what you hope to achieve and whether it's truly for the other person's benefit or to satisfy your own needs. This can help you understand if your actions are self-serving or genuinely aimed at reconciliation.
- Create a personal growth plan post-breakup instead of rushing into grand reconciliatory acts. Identify areas for self-improvement that may have contributed to the relationship's end and set goals to work on them. This could involve reading books on emotional intelligence, seeking therapy, or taking up new hobbies that foster self-awareness.
- Practice express ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Emotional and Psychological Process Of Ending a Relationship
Shankar Vedantam and Antonio Pascual-Leone delve into the complexities of breakups, giving insight into the emotional and psychological journey of ending a relationship.
Ending a Relationship Involves Grieving and Letting Go
Vedantam and Pascual-Leone compare the end of a relationship to the process of grieving. Pascual-Leone emphasizes the need for internal reflection and confronting feelings such as insecurity to begin the process of letting go.
Benefits Of Recognizing Loss and Rejecting Intolerance
These experts identify problematic behaviors that can arise at the end of a relationship, including brooding, and impulsive actions like seeking new relationships or expressing unwarranted anger. Vedantam points out that such behaviors can prevent proper healing and closure. Pascual-Leone speaks to the gravity of acknowledging the value of the former relationship, likening it to giving it the "funeral it deserved." This act of recognition allows individuals to learn, understand the care that was present, and accept the relationship's termination.
Grieve and Release Unresolved Hopes and Dreams In the Relationship
Undeclared Surplus Reality Losses
Pascual-Leone reflects on the deeper aspect of grieving after a breakup. It's not merely about the loss of a partner; it can profoundly impact one's self-perception and sense of worth. Moreover, Pascual-Leone discusses the 'undeclared losses' or 'surplus reality' of a rela ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Emotional and Psychological Process Of Ending a Relationship
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While grieving and letting go are common aspects of ending a relationship, some individuals may experience relief or a sense of freedom, suggesting that the grieving process is not universal.
- Internal reflection is important, but external support from friends, family, or professionals can also be crucial in the healing process.
- Rejecting intolerance is beneficial, but it's also important to recognize and set boundaries to protect oneself from further emotional harm.
- While problematic behaviors can hinder healing, they can also be part of the natural process of coping with loss, and with proper guidance, individuals can learn from these behaviors.
- Acknowledging the value of a former relationship is important, but it is also valid for some individuals to choose to move on without fully engaging in this process, depending on the circumstances of the breakup.
- The concept ...
Actionables
- Create a "Grief Map" to visually represent your emotional journey, using colors and symbols to denote different feelings and stages you're experiencing. This can help you track your progress over time and identify patterns in your grieving process. For example, use blue for sadness, red for anger, and green for growth; add symbols like storm clouds for turbulent emotions or sunshine for moments of clarity.
- Start a "Letting Go" journal where you write letters to your past self, the ex-partner, or the relationship itself. This exercise allows you to express all the things you wish you could say, helping you confront and release your feelings. For instance, write a letter forgiving your past self for mistakes made or expressing gratitude to the relationship for the growth it brought you.
- Develop a personal r ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Strategies For Gaining Closure and Moving Forward
Shankar Vedantam highlights the complexity of moving on from relationships and engages with expert Antonio Pascual-Leone on unconventional but effective strategies for gaining emotional closure.
Unsent Letters to an Ex Offer Emotional Expression
Speak Freely Without Pressure For Responses
Antonio Pascual-Leone discusses the therapeutic value of writing a letter or email to an ex-partner but intentionally not sending it. This private act provides a structured way to articulate feelings and the narrative around the relationship’s end. It can clarify emotions and aid in closure, offering a clear and coherent emotional expression that might not emerge through mere thought.
Talking To Empty Chairs: Gaining Clarity and Closure Through Imagined Dialogues
Explores Perspectives, Emotions, and Unresolved Issues Typically Impossible in Real Life
Pascual-Leone then expands on how closure can be attained without the other person's presence by using alternative strategies like talking to empty chairs. This allows individuals to work through emotions and finish conversations in a psychologically effective manner.
For example, in studies with suicidal adolescents who had unresolved issues with their parents, imagined dialogues were found to be more emotionally beneficial than actual conversations. Pascual-Leone explains that such a process is a personal journey where the other person cannot undertake the emotional processing on one's behalf.
Talking to an empty chair can evoke emotions and provide clarity. In this therapeutic exercise, individuals can express what is otherwise unsaid, explore different perspectives, and even simulate responses. A client, for instance, used this method to address a difficult relationship with his father by first articulating his own feelings and then imagining his father's possible responses. This exercise led to personal forgiveness and a decision to maintain a healthy distance, thereby protecting his own daughter from potential harm.
Pascual-Leone also emotionally engaged in a conversation with an empty chair, simulating his late aunt expressing pride in him which provided him with emotional continuity and a sense of closure.
Goal: Shift Narrative to Personal Growth and Honoring the Relationship
Acknowledging Positives and Negatives to Become Better
Pascual-Leone stresses the opportunity for personal transformati ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Strategies For Gaining Closure and Moving Forward
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While writing unsent letters can be therapeutic, it may not provide the same sense of resolution that a real conversation might, leaving some individuals feeling incomplete.
- Talking to empty chairs, although beneficial for some, might not be effective for everyone, as it requires a certain level of imagination and self-guidance that not all individuals possess.
- Imagined dialogues can sometimes reinforce one's own biases or misunderstandings without the reality check that an actual conversation with another person could provide.
- The strategy of shifting the narrative towards personal growth, while positive, might not be feasible for everyone, especially if the breakup was traumatic or if there are unresolved issues that need professional intervention.
- The emphasis on personal transformation may inadvertently pressure individuals to find a silver lining in a situation where they are not ready to see one, potentially invalidating their current feelings of pain or loss.
- Acknowledging the positives and negatives of a relationship is important, but it can be challenging for someone who has experienced abuse or toxicity to focus on the positives without feeling like they are minimizing their pain.
- The idea that one must find a partner who prioritizes their needs might lead to unrealistic expectations or pressure to enter into a new ...
Actionables
- Create a personal growth journal to document your journey after a breakup, focusing on the lessons learned and how you've evolved. By regularly writing in this journal, you can track your emotional state, recognize patterns in your thoughts and behaviors, and set goals for your personal development. For example, after a tough day, you might write about how you managed your emotions and what you learned about your needs and boundaries.
- Develop a "relationship timeline" art project that visually represents the highs and lows of your past relationship. Use colors, symbols, or images to depict different periods and events. This creative process can help you acknowledge the full spectrum of experiences within the relationship and see your growth over time. You might use green for growth periods, red for conflicts, and yellow for happy memories, creating a visual narrative of your journey.
- Organize a "future-self" meditation session where you ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Storytelling's Role in Processing Relationship Endings
Storytelling has a profound impact on how individuals cope with the end of relationships, potentially influencing emotional and mental health.
Storytelling of Relationship Endings Predicts Emotional and Mental Health Outcomes
Antonio Pascual-Leone shared his personal breakup story on the podcast, suggesting that reflecting on relationship endings is crucial for personal understanding and processing. Such reflections may significantly affect one's emotional and mental health outcomes.
Superficial or Maladaptive Narratives Link To Higher Depression, Anxiety, and Trauma Symptoms
Pascual-Leone discusses a study examining how people narrate their experiences with traumatic relationship endings. The study found that certain types of narratives, specifically superficial or shallow stories as well as "same old stories" reflecting maladaptive states, predict higher levels of depressive, anxious, and trauma symptoms. It's not just the content of the stories that matters; the method and choice of words used in storytelling can indicate the severity of these symptoms.
Focus On Narrative Framing For Relationship Awareness and Healing
Antonio Pascual-Leone underlines the importance of learning from past relationships and evolving as a person to sidestep similar issues in the future. This points to the role that storytelling and reflection may play in one's emotional and mental health recovery process after a relationship ends.
Telling a Balan ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Storytelling's Role in Processing Relationship Endings
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- Antonio Pascual-Leone shared his personal breakup story on a podcast, emphasizing the importance of reflecting on relationship endings for personal understanding and emotional healing. He highlighted how the way individuals narrate their experiences with relationship endings can impact their emotional and mental well-being. Pascual-Leone's breakup experience underscored the significance of viewing the end of a relationship as a moment of clarity and growth, showcasing how storytelling can aid in processing and moving on from such events. His insights suggest that crafting a balanced and evolving narrative of a relationship's end can facilitate healing and self-awareness.
- Narrative framing in relationship awareness and healing involves how individuals construct and interpret the stories they tell themselves about their past relationships. By framing their relationship endings in a balanced and evolving narrative, individuals can gain insight ...
Counterarguments
- While storytelling can be therapeutic, it may not be a universally effective tool for everyone; some individuals might find other coping mechanisms more helpful.
- Reflecting on relationship endings can sometimes lead to rumination, which could potentially worsen mental health if not done constructively.
- The link between narrative style and mental health symptoms could be correlational rather than causal; individuals with higher depression, anxiety, and trauma symptoms might be more prone to tell their stories in a certain way, rather than the storytelling style causing these symptoms.
- The emphasis on learning from past relationships could inadvertently lead to self-blame or an over-analysis of one's behavior, which might not always be constructive or necessary for healing.
- The idea that a balanced, evolving story aids in moving on might not account for complex situations where closure is not easily attainable or where the relationship dynamics are too traumatic to revisit.
- The concept of seeing the end of a relationship as a clarifying moment m ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
