A Different Take on Screen Time
In this episode of Good Inside with Dr. Becky, Dr. Kennedy and Ash Brandon tackle the topic of screen time management as families transition from summer to school schedules. They discuss practical approaches to setting screen time boundaries, suggesting that families should consider their unique needs and routines rather than following rigid rules. The hosts explain how screen time can serve useful functions beyond entertainment, particularly for parents with non-traditional schedules.
The conversation explores how video game mechanics mirror effective parenting strategies and challenges common assumptions about screen time. Brandon and Kennedy address parental guilt surrounding screen use, emphasizing a data-driven approach over decisions based on shame or fear. They also examine the role of leisure activities in child development, suggesting that downtime—including screen time—contributes to emotional regulation and resilience.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Aug 12, 2025 episode of the Good Inside with Dr. Becky
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
Transitioning Screen Time From Summer to School Year
As families prepare for the school year, Becky Kennedy and Ash Brandon discuss strategies for adjusting summer screen time habits to accommodate school schedules.
Guide Screen Time by Family Needs & Routines
Brandon advises setting clear, non-negotiable routines first, such as morning departure times, and then planning screen time around these fixed points. She emphasizes the importance of involving children in decisions about screen time, particularly for after-school periods, to foster better cooperation with new rules.
Considering Family Needs For Screen Time Rules
The hosts emphasize that screen time serves practical functions beyond entertainment, particularly for single parents or those working non-traditional hours. Brandon suggests that rather than focusing solely on restrictions, families should consider how screen use can benefit the entire family unit, such as through shared activities like family movie nights.
Overcoming Screen Time Shame and Guilt For Empowerment
Ash Brandon emphasizes viewing screen time as a neutral tool rather than inherently good or bad. Kennedy points out that parental guilt often stems from fear of judgment rather than actual impacts on children. Both hosts advocate for a data-driven approach to screen time, suggesting that families should evaluate what works practically rather than making decisions based on shame or fear.
Parallels Between Game Mechanics and Boundary-Setting With Children
Kennedy and Brandon draw comparisons between video game mechanics and effective parenting strategies. They note how games provide clear, consistent boundaries while offering choices within those limits - a model parents can follow. Kennedy emphasizes maintaining neutrality during boundary enforcement, similar to how video games consistently apply rules without emotional involvement.
Role of Rest, Leisure, and "Unproductive" Activities in Child Development
Kennedy and Brandon challenge the notion that children's time must always be productive. They emphasize the developmental importance of downtime and leisure activities, including screen time. Brandon compares screen time management to learning to swim, suggesting it's a skill requiring balance between leisure and responsibilities. The hosts stress that activities often dismissed as unproductive can play crucial roles in child development, fostering emotion regulation and resilience.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While setting non-negotiable routines is important, some families may find that too rigid a structure can create stress or conflict, especially if unexpected events disrupt those routines.
- Involving children in decisions about screen time is beneficial, but it may not always be practical, especially with younger children who may lack the foresight or self-control to make balanced choices.
- Screen time does serve practical functions, but relying on it too heavily, especially for single parents or those with non-traditional hours, can lead to excessive use and potential neglect of other enriching activities.
- Shared activities like family movie nights are valuable, but it's also important to ensure that screen time doesn't replace other forms of family interaction, such as conversation and physical play.
- While it's helpful to view screen time as a neutral tool, it's also important to acknowledge that not all screen time is created equal, and some types can have negative effects on attention span, sleep, and physical health.
- Parental guilt may sometimes be a valid internal cue that screen time is not being managed effectively within the family, and not solely a reaction to external judgment.
- A data-driven approach to screen time is useful, but it should be balanced with intuitive parenting and an understanding of each child's unique needs and responses to screen time.
- Comparing video game mechanics to parenting strategies can be insightful, but it may oversimplify the complexities of human relationships and the nuances of child development.
- Consistency in boundary enforcement is important, but so is flexibility and the ability to adapt to the individual needs of the child, which may sometimes require emotional involvement and empathy.
- While downtime and leisure are essential for child development, there should be a balance, and not all screen time is equally restorative or beneficial for emotional regulation and resilience.
- Learning to manage screen time is important, but equating it with a skill like swimming may minimize the potential risks associated with digital media overuse.
- Activities labeled as unproductive may contribute to development, but it's also crucial to encourage a variety of experiences, including those that challenge children and promote active engagement with the world around them.
Actionables
- You can create a family decision-making board to involve children in setting screen time rules, where each member can post their suggestions and vote on them weekly. This visual and interactive approach encourages participation and helps children understand the democratic process of rule-setting, making them more likely to adhere to the agreed-upon screen time schedules.
- Develop a "Family Tech Time" jar where each family member can contribute ideas for shared screen activities, such as educational games, documentaries, or creative apps that can be drawn at random for family nights. This ensures that screen time is used for bonding and learning, and it turns screen use into a positive, collective experience rather than an individual, isolating one.
- Introduce a "Screen Time Token" system where children earn tokens for completing responsibilities and can exchange them for screen time, mimicking the reward structure of video games. This teaches children about earning leisure time and helps them associate screen time with positive behavior, while also providing clear boundaries and a sense of achievement.
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Transitioning Screen Time From Summer to School Year
As the school year approaches, families face the challenge of adjusting screen time routines that were relaxed during the summer. Becky Kennedy and Ash Brandon offer guidance on how to navigate this transition effectively.
From Relaxed Summer Routines to School Year Demands
End-of-summer Sparks Thoughtful Screen Time Rule Adjustments
Becky Kennedy notes the concern that screen time habits from the summer may not fit into the more structured schedule required for the school year. In particular, she points out that screen time in the mornings, which may have been permissible during the summer, won't align with school routines that demand children get ready and leave early.
Ash encourages parents to reflect on what worked or didn't work before summer and any issues that arose during the more lenient summer period. By evaluating these points, families can better prepare for the upcoming school year, considering everyone's needs and fitting screen time into the new routine accordingly.
Guide Screen Time by Family Needs & Routines
Determine Non-negotiable Priorities Like Punctuality, and Plan Screen Time Around Them
Ash Brandon advocates setting clear non-negotiable routines, such as a departure time of 7:45 AM, around which screen time usage can be planned. For example, if leaving on time is a priority, it may be necessary to limit morning screen time. When setting new rules for screen time, Brandon advises parents to communicate their non-negotiable requirements clea ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Transitioning Screen Time From Summer to School Year
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While setting non-negotiable priorities is important, it may not account for the individual differences in children's needs and temperaments. Some children may require more flexibility in their routines.
- Involving children in decision-making is beneficial, but it should be balanced with parental guidance to ensure that screen time does not interfere with other essential activities like homework, physical activity, and sleep.
- The transition from summer to school year screen time might not be as challenging for some families, depending on their summer routines. Some families may maintain a consistent schedule year-round, reducing the need for significant adjustments.
- The effectiveness of screen time rules can vary widely depending on the child's age, maturity level, and individual circumstances. What works for one child or family may not work for another.
- There is an assumption that screen ti ...
Actionables
- Create a visual screen time transition chart to ease into the school year routine by mapping out a gradual reduction of screen time from summer levels to school year goals. Start by identifying the amount of screen time allowed during the summer and then decide on an acceptable amount for the school year. Each week, decrease the screen time by increments until you reach the desired school year limit. For example, if summer screen time was 3 hours a day and the school year goal is 1 hour, reduce by 30 minutes each week over a month.
- Develop a family screen time currency system where screen time is earned through fulfilling responsibilities and priorities. Assign a time value to tasks such as homework completion, chores, or practicing an instrument. For instance, 30 minutes of homework might earn 10 minutes of screen time. This system encourages punctuality and responsibility by directly linking privileges to priorities.
- Organize a family "Screen Time Summit" ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Considering Family Needs For Screen Time Rules
Brandon and Ash Brandon weigh in on how to approach the issue of screen time within families, pointing out that the discussion should include consideration of the functional roles that screens play in family life beyond just child entertainment.
Screens Serve Functional Purposes For Families, Not Just Child Entertainment
Screen time does more than keep children entertained; it can also serve practical functions that help manage the complexities of family life.
Screens Can Ease Family Life Burdens
The hosts discuss the role of screen time in easing burdens, particularly for single parents or caregivers working non-traditional hours. Screens can sometimes fill in gaps in caregiving, providing necessary relief to adults who are trying to juggle multiple responsibilities.
Consider Screen Time's Impact on the Entire Family, Not Just the Child
Brandon emphasizes that when setting screen time rules, it’s essential to consider what screen use allows to happen within the family unit.
Focus On Inclusive Solutions, Not Just Screen Use Restrictions
Rather than strictly limiting screen time, it’s beneficial to focus on inclusive solutions that address the needs and routines of the whole family. Ash sugge ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Considering Family Needs For Screen Time Rules
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While screens do serve functional purposes, over-reliance on them for family management could lead to a lack of engagement in other valuable family activities that promote bonding and development.
- Easing burdens with screen time might provide short-term relief but could also contribute to long-term issues such as reduced physical activity and social skills development in children.
- Considering the entire family's needs is important, but it should not overshadow the individual developmental needs of the child, which might be compromised with excessive screen time.
- Inclusive solutions are ideal, but they should also include non-screen-based activities to ensure a balanced lifestyle and to encourage diverse experiences.
- Shared activities like family movie nights are beneficial, but they should be balanced with other shared activities that do not involve screens to promote a variety of s ...
Actionables
- Create a family screen time charter that includes everyone's needs and preferences. Gather as a family and draft a document that outlines when, how, and why screens will be used in your household. For example, you might agree that screens are allowed during meal prep times to keep children engaged, or that certain hours will be screen-free to encourage family interaction. This charter should be revisited and revised regularly to adapt to your family's evolving dynamics.
- Develop a "screen time currency" system to teach children about balance and decision-making. Assign a certain number of tokens or points to each child that they can "spend" on screen time, with the opportunity to earn more through chores or good behavior. This system encourages children to think critically about how they use their screen time and allows parents to integrate screen use with positive reinforcement and life skills education.
- Organize a weekly "Tech Together" event that tur ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Overcoming Screen Time Shame and Guilt For Empowerment
Ash Brandon and Becky Kennedy discuss the challenges parents face with managing their children's screen time and suggest a shift in perspective to overcome shame and guilt for empowerment.
View Screen Time as a Purposeful Tool, Not "Good" or "Bad"
Ash Brandon emphasizes that fear and shame are not empowering and that healthy screen time does not necessarily mean minimal screen time. Brandon argues for viewing technology with neutrality to empower children to have a relationship with technology that works for them long-term. Brandon and Kennedy suggest rethinking screens as tools and maintaining a neutral perspective, which allows for flexibility and informed decision-making without condemning their use as detrimental.
Shame or Guilt About Screen Time Often Comes From Biases or Unrealistic Expectations, Not Actual Impact on the Child
The conversation includes discussing how screens are not inherently moral issues and that we should not automatically consider all possible activities screen time could replace as having more value. Becky Kennedy points out that often, the guilt or conflict parents feel regarding their child's screen time comes from their own associations and the fear of being judged as a bad parent, rather than the actual impact on the child.
Adopt a Neutral, Data-Driven View on Screen Time For Flexibility and Experimentation
Ash Brandon suggests avoiding negative spiraling or catastrophizing about screen time and seeking a balance with other activities without judgment. Both hosts emphasize the importance of focusing on skills rather than fear to parent effectively without guilt. Kennedy and Brandon encourage removing the emotional weight from screen time decisions to make them less daunting and maintaining boundaries eas ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Overcoming Screen Time Shame and Guilt For Empowerment
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- Viewing screen time as a neutral tool may overlook the potential for addictive design in some technologies that can impact children's behavior and development.
- While shame and guilt are not empowering, they can be natural indicators that personal values or expectations are not being met, which may warrant attention and reflection.
- The assertion that healthy screen time doesn't necessarily mean minimal screen time could be challenged by research suggesting that excessive screen time can have negative effects on children's physical and mental health.
- Rethinking screens solely as tools might ignore the content being consumed, which can vary widely in educational value and appropriateness for different ages.
- The idea that guilt about screen time often comes from biases may not account for legitimate concerns about the opportunity cost of screen time, such as reduced physical activity or face-to-face social interaction.
- A neutral, data-driven view on screen time might not fully consider the qualitative aspects of a child's experiences and the subtleties of their emotional and social development.
- Avoiding negative spiraling about screen time is sensible, but it's also important to recognize when screen time is becoming a problem and to address it proactively rather than just seeking balance.
- Focusing on skills rather than fear can be beneficial, but it's also important to acknowledge that some fears may be based on valid concerns about the impact of technology on children.
- Removing emotional weight from screen time decisions could potentially lead to disengagement from the emotional and relational aspects of parenting in the digital age.
- Viewing screen time challenges as information-gathering opp ...
Actionables
- Create a family screen time journal to observe patterns and behaviors without judgment, noting what activities occur before and after screen time, the content consumed, and the mood of each family member. This approach allows you to gather data over a period, helping you make informed decisions about screen time without guilt. For example, you might notice that watching educational shows in the morning leads to more creative play afterward, while certain games in the evening might make bedtime routines more challenging.
- Develop a "Screen Time Swap" system where for every hour spent on screens, an equivalent time is allocated to a family activity or individual hobby. This system encourages balance and helps to integrate screen time as a part of a diverse set of activities rather than the sole focus. For instance, if your child spends an hour playing a video game, they then spend an hour on a puzzle, reading, or playing outside, fostering a variety of interests and skills.
- Implement a weekly family "Tech Talk" where everyone discu ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Parallels Between Game Mechanics and Boundary-Setting With Children
Ash Brandon and Becky Kennedy present intriguing parallels between the structured nature of video games and the ways in which parents can set and enforce boundaries for their children effectively.
Video Games Exemplify Rule and Boundary Communication For Parenting
The clarity and consistency of rules in video games, as cited by Brandon and Kennedy, provide a useful framework for establishing boundaries in parenting.
Set Non-negotiable Limits and Offer Choices Within Boundaries
In video games, certain boundaries, such as the defined edges of a level or the fixed behaviors of objects, give players a clear understanding of what is not negotiable. Within these limits, however, they are free to make choices, fostering both structure and space for creativity. Similarly, Kennedy mentions the importance of setting non-negotiable boundaries in parenting, such as fixed screen time limits, while allowing children to make certain choices within those boundaries.
Children Test Limits; Consistent Enforcement Builds Understanding
Just as games consistently enforce rules without personal bias, Kennedy notes that parents should aim to maintain neutrality during the enforcement of boundaries.
Maintain Neutrality to Avoid Power Struggles, Like the Game Engine, Rather Than Taking Boundary-Testing Personally
The impersonal enforcement by a video game's r ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Parallels Between Game Mechanics and Boundary-Setting With Children
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- The parallels between video game mechanics and parenting boundaries lie in the structured nature of both, where clear rules and limits are set for guidance. Video games provide a framework with non-negotiable boundaries and choices within those limits, similar to how parents establish fixed boundaries while allowing children some freedom within those constraints. Consistent enforcement of rules in games and boundaries by parents helps build understanding and reduces conflicts, emphasizing the importance of maintaining neutrality and not taking boundary-testing personally. This approach helps children learn and adapt to boundaries, fostering a balance between structure and creativity in both gaming and parenting contexts.
- In the context of parenting, video game rules can be applied by setting clear and consistent boundaries for children, similar to how rules are established in games. These boundaries provide structure and guidance while allowing room for decision-making within those limits, fostering a balance between structure and creativity. By maintaining neutrality and enforcing boundaries consistently, parents can help children understand the importance of rules and consequences, similar to how video games enforce their rules without bias. This approach can help children learn and adapt to boundaries over time, reducing conflicts and promoting a better understanding of limits.
- In parenting, non-negotiable limits are rules that are firm and must be followed without exception. Choices within boundaries allow children some freedom to make decisions within the set limits, fostering independence and responsibility. This approach provides structure while also encouraging creativity and decision-making skills within a safe framework. It's about balancing clear rules that cannot be changed with opportunities for children to exercise autonomy within those established parameters.
- Consistent enforcement of boundaries in parenting involves setting clear rules and limits for children and ensuring these rules are consistently upheld. This approach helps children understand what is expected of them and the consequences of crossing established boundaries. By maintaining consistency in enforcing these boundaries, parents provide a stable and predictable environment for their children, promoting a sense of security and understanding. Consistent enforcement also helps children internalize these boundaries over time, leading to better compliance and fewer conflicts.
- Maintaining neutrality in enforcing bou ...
Counterarguments
- While video games provide clear rules, real-life situations are often more nuanced, and a one-size-fits-all approach to boundary-setting may not account for the complexities of individual child development and family dynamics.
- Non-negotiable boundaries might not always allow for the flexibility needed to accommodate exceptional circumstances or developmental changes in children.
- Consistent enforcement of boundaries is important, but it must be balanced with empathy and understanding of a child's emotional state and needs, which can sometimes require a more nuanced response than a video game's binary rule system.
- Maintaining neutrality is a sound principle, but it's important to recognize that parenting is inherently an emotional relationship, and complete ne ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Role of Rest, Leisure, and "Unproductive" Activities in Child Development
Recognize the Value In Downtime and Purposeless Activities
Kennedy's therapist's suggestion that even just lounging on the couch can be an essential component of rest, underscores the importance of downtime. Similarly, Brandon asserts that activities such as screen time are legitimate, pleasure-oriented activities which should not be depreciated as unproductive.
Avoid Judging Screen Time As Unproductive
Kennedy and Brandon discuss screen time, emphasizing that leisure for leisure's sake holds value that should not be dismissed for both children and adults. In a child's range of activities, things like coloring on an iPad are satisfying experiences and should not be automatically labeled as unproductive. Brandon compares navigating screen time to learning how to swim, suggesting it's a skill that requires a balance of leisure and responsibilities, therefore prioritizing the developmental importance of leisure activities.
Challenge the Assumption That Children's Time Must Always Be Maximized For Learning
Leisure, Exploration, and Motivation Are Key for Child Development
Kennedy highlights that children need opportunities for play and learning divorced from immediate rewards, stressing the role of emotion regulation and resilience fostered through seemingly 'unproductive' activities. The speakers challenge the notion that every activity in a child's life needs to be structured for productivity or education. Instead, they underscore the significance of leisure, exploration, and intri ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Role of Rest, Leisure, and "Unproductive" Activities in Child Development
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While lounging may be restful, it is also important to ensure that it does not lead to a sedentary lifestyle, which can have negative health implications.
- Screen time, though not inherently unproductive, needs to be moderated as excessive use can lead to issues with attention, sleep, and physical health.
- Leisure is valuable, but it should be balanced with activities that promote physical, cognitive, and social development.
- Coloring on an iPad can be satisfying, but it is also important to encourage traditional forms of creativity that do not rely on screen-based media.
- Navigating screen time as a skill is important, but it should not overshadow the development of other essential life skills that require face-to-face interaction and hands-on experiences.
- Opportunities for play and learning are crucial, but structured learning experiences are also important for providing children with a well-rounded education.
- Emotion regulation and resilience can be fostered through a variety of activities, not just 'unproductive' ones, and some structured activities can also promote these qualities.
- While not every activity needs to be structured for productivity, some level of structure and guidance is often necessary to help children develop discipline and a work ethic.
- Leisure and exploration are important, but so is t ...
Actionables
- You can create a "Do Nothing" day where you and your family intentionally plan a day with no structured activities, allowing everyone to engage in whatever form of leisure they prefer, such as lounging, doodling, or simply daydreaming. This can help normalize the idea that rest and unstructured time are valuable, and it can be a recurring event in your calendar to ensure regular practice.
- Develop a family leisure chart that includes a variety of non-productive activities, such as building a pillow fort, having a dance party, or cloud watching, and encourage each family member to mark when they engage in these activities. This visual representation can serve as a reminder of the importance of leisure and can help track the balance between work and relaxation.
- Introduce a "creative corner" in y ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
1-Page Summary- Transitioning Screen Time From Summer to School Year
- Considering Family Needs For Screen Time Rules
- Overcoming Screen Time Shame and Guilt For Empowerment
- Parallels Between Game Mechanics and Boundary-Setting With Children
- Role of Rest, Leisure, and "Unproductive" Activities in Child Development
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
