Podcasts > Focus on the Family Broadcast > Never Perfect: Finding More Joy, and Less Guilt, As a Mom

Never Perfect: Finding More Joy, and Less Guilt, As a Mom

By Focus on the Family

Dive into the struggles and revelations of motherhood with Leslie Leyland Fields in the Focus on the Family Broadcast alongside hosts Jim Daly and John Fuller. In the latest episode, Fields candidly shares the often unspoken tribulations of chasing the elusive image of a perfect mother. She opens up about the guilt and self-criticism that ensues from unmet expectations—be it toddler tantrums or a son's silence—and admits to questioning her abilities as a mother and Christian when her children's behavior didn't align with her hopes.

Throughout the discussion, Fields brings theological insight to the challenges of parenting by comparing her experiences to the emotional depiction of God as a parent in the Old Testament. Shattering parenting myths derived from scripture, she highlights the misplaced emphasis on perfect parenting as the main calling and the overestimation of parental influence on a child's acceptance of faith. By sharing her journey towards embracing a more liberated approach to parenting, Fields imparts wisdom gleaned from scripture and personal epiphanies, encouraging fellow parents to see their role through the lens of faithfulness and privilege, leading towards a more joyful and less burdened experience.

Listen to the original

Never Perfect: Finding More Joy, and Less Guilt, As a Mom

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Mar 7, 2024 episode of the Focus on the Family Broadcast

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Never Perfect: Finding More Joy, and Less Guilt, As a Mom

1-Page Summary

Parenting Guilt from Unmet Expectations

Leslie Leyland Fields recounts her expectations of parenting bringing happiness and fulfillment, only to face the reality of unhappiness in situations like toddler tantrums and a son's silence. She admits to feeling guilty and self-critical for not living up to the ideal of a perfect mother, comparing herself unfavorably to others. As her children grew, the challenges magnified, and Fields felt like a failure because her children did not meet her expectations, making her question her abilities as a mother and a Christian.

God as Parent

Fields reflects on the Old Testament portrayal of God as a parent, acknowledging that God experiences emotions such as anger and judgment towards His children. She finds comfort in realizing that her frustrations and emotions mirror God's, as she, too, is made in His image. This realization helps her relate to the divine experience of parenting, imparting a sense of solace amidst her struggles.

Parenting Myths from Scripture

Fields discusses the misconceptions that arise from scripture regarding successful parenting. She calls out the idea that parenting is one's main calling, arguing instead that loving God takes precedence. Fields also addresses the false notion that a child's spiritual outcome is a measure of parenting success and the belief in a critical timeframe to impart faith. She emphasizes that success in parenting should not be tied to the children's acceptance of faith, relieving parents from the weight of impossibility.

True Freedom in Parenting

Fields shares how she found freedom in parenting by learning to love and accept her children as they are, letting go of the burden for their life outcomes. Inspired by the Biblical story of Ezekiel, she recognizes that her children's choices are their own, and her role is to guide, not control. This epiphany, combined with placing love for God first, alters her view of parenting from a performance to a privilege. Fields encourages parents to view the role as an act of faithfulness, and a privilege filled with joy and honor, rather than a burdensome duty, thus transforming her approach and experience of parenting.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • In the Old Testament, God is often depicted as a parent to His people, showing care, discipline, and guidance similar to a human parent. Emotions like anger and judgment attributed to God reflect His response to the actions of His children, emphasizing His expectations and standards. This portrayal helps believers understand the complex relationship between God and humanity, highlighting His role as a loving but just parent figure. Recognizing these emotions in God's character can provide insight into how divine love and discipline intersect in the context of faith and obedience.

Counterarguments

  • While Fields finds solace in comparing her frustrations to God's emotions, some may argue that human emotions and divine emotions should not be equated, as they may differ fundamentally in nature and purpose.
  • The idea that loving God should take precedence over parenting could be challenged by those who believe that parenting is a divine calling and a primary way to express love for God through stewardship and nurturing of children.
  • The notion that a child's spiritual outcome is not a measure of parenting success might be countered by those who believe that parents do have a significant influence on their children's spiritual development and that this responsibility should not be taken lightly.
  • Fields' emphasis on accepting children as they are and letting go of the burden for their life outcomes could be critiqued by those who believe that parents should have a more active role in shaping their children's futures and instilling values.
  • The idea that parenting should not be tied to children's acceptance of faith might be challenged by those who see imparting faith as an integral part of parenting and a key aspect of a child's upbringing and moral foundation.
  • Some may argue that the story of Ezekiel and the concept of children's choices being their own does not fully absolve parents from the consequences of their children's actions, as parents are often seen as responsible for guiding their children towards making good decisions.
  • The transformation of parenting from a performance to a privilege might be seen as an oversimplification by those who experience parenting as a complex mix of duty, responsibility, joy, and challenge, rather than a binary choice between burden and privilege.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Never Perfect: Finding More Joy, and Less Guilt, As a Mom

Parenting Guilt from Unmet Expectations

Leslie Leyland Fields shares her personal journey through the trials of parenting, reflecting on the unmet expectations that led to a profound sense of guilt and failure.

Leslie's expectation that children would bring happiness and fulfillment

Leslie Leyland Fields discusses the stark contrast between the idealized message that having children will bring complete happiness and fulfillment and the reality of her own experiences. Despite the hopeful verse from Scripture that suggests "happy is the man whose quiver is full," she encountered moments of deep unhappiness, such as handling a toddler's tantrum or enduring years without communication from her son.

Leslie's self-condemnation for not measuring up as a perfect mom

Fields candidly shares her struggles with self-condemnation and guilt as she reflects on her role as a mother. She often went to bed overwhelmed with guilt for not meeting her own expectations of a perfect mother, replaying her failures and the day’s negative interactions with her children. She finds herself unfavorably comparing her maternal efforts to those of other mothers, noticing the differences in the lunches she prepared and the experiences her children had.

Feeling like a failure because her kids did not turn ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Parenting Guilt from Unmet Expectations

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Leslie Leyland Fields faced challenges in parenting such as handling a toddler's tantrum, enduring years without communication from her son, struggling with self-condemnation for not meeting her own expectations, feeling like a failure as her children faced serious challenges in high school, and questioning her identity as a mother and a Christian when her parenting outcomes did not align with her aspirations.
  • Leslie Leyland Fields faced challenges with her children during their high school years, including issues like drug tests and secretive parties. These challenges added to her feelings of self-doubt and inadequacy as a parent. The mention of drug tests suggests potential substance abuse concerns within her family. The reference to secretive parties implies a lack of transparency and potential risky behavior among her children during this period.
  • Leslie's identity as a Christian plays a significant role in her feelings of failure as a mother because her faith ma ...

Counterarguments

  • Happiness and fulfillment from parenting can vary greatly and are not solely determined by children's behavior or outcomes.
  • The concept of a "perfect mom" is a social construct that may not account for the diverse realities and challenges of parenting.
  • Children's development and outcomes are influenced by a wide range of factors beyond parental control, and it is unrealistic to hold parents solely responsible for how their children turn out.
  • Self-condemnation may not be a productive response to parenting challenges and can overlook the positive aspects and efforts made in parenting.
  • Comparing oneself to other parents can be misleading, as each fam ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Never Perfect: Finding More Joy, and Less Guilt, As a Mom

God as Parent

Fields contemplates the portrayal of God in the Old Testament, considering the divine as a parental figure experiencing an array of emotions toward humanity.

God understands parent frustrations and struggles

He expresses emotions like anger, judgment

Fields draws parallels between stories from the Old Testament and the concept of God as a parent to His children. She recognizes not only the love and mercy God bestows upon His children but also His expressions of frustration, anger, and judgment.

Leslie realizes her emotions echo God's as a parent

Finding solace in her role as a mother, Fields relates to the ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

God as Parent

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The parallels drawn between God as a parent and stories from the Old Testament highlight how God's interactions with humanity mirror parental emotions and behaviors seen in the biblical narratives. These parallels emphasize the multifaceted nature of God's relationship with His people, showcasing not only love and mercy but also moments of frustration, anger, and judgment. By connecting these divine attributes to parental experiences, the text underscores the complexity and depth of the portrayal of God in the Old Testament. This comparison serves to humanize the divine figure, making His actions and emotions more relatable and understandable in the context of familial relationships.
  • Leslie's role as a mother relates to the concept of God as a parent in the sense that she sees parallels between her experiences as a parent and the emotions attributed to God in the Old Testament. By recognizing her own feelings of frustration and judgment as a mother, Leslie finds a connection to the complex range of emotions that God is depicted as having towards humanity. This connection helps Leslie understand and empathize with the portrayal of God as a parental figure, enriching her perspective on her own ...

Counterarguments

  • The portrayal of God as a parent with human-like emotions may be seen as anthropomorphic, projecting human traits onto the divine, which some theological perspectives might argue limits the nature of an omnipotent, omniscient being.
  • The interpretation of God's emotions in the Old Testament can vary widely among different religious traditions and scholars, with some arguing that divine anger and judgment are metaphorical or serve specific narrative purposes rather than reflecting literal emotions.
  • The idea that human emotions directly mirror God's might be challenged by those who believe that while humans are created in the image of God, our emotions are flawed reflections of the divine due to human imperfection and sin.
  • Some might argue that using personal experiences to understand the divine could lead to a subjective interpretation of religious texts that may not align with traditional or historical understandings.
  • There may be alternative interpretations of the O ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Never Perfect: Finding More Joy, and Less Guilt, As a Mom

Parenting Myths from Scripture

Leslie Leyland Fields examines common misconceptions surrounding Biblical parenting, clarifying the misconceptions derived from scripture about what constitutes successful parenting.

Responsibility to love God first before loving kids

Fields challenges the prevalent belief, particularly among mothers, that parenting is the most important calling. She highlights the primary charge given to believers in both the Old and New Testaments, which is to love God with all one's heart, soul, mind, and strength before anything else, including parenting.

Parenting brings purpose and fulfillment

Instead of the notion that parenting in itself is the ultimate source of purpose and fulfillment for believers, Fields argues that foremost is the responsibility and charge to place love and devotion to God above all other relationships, including those we have with our children.

Kid outcomes determine parenting success

Fields confesses the pressure she felt, being worried about her children's outcomes, particularly in ensuring they became believers. This pressure is commonly felt due to claims, sometimes propagated by Christian authors, that there is a limited timeframe to solidly impart faith to children. Fields deconstructs the myth that a parent's success is entirely def ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Parenting Myths from Scripture

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The text challenges the belief that parenting is the most important calling, emphasizing the priority of loving God above all else. It questions the idea that parenting alone brings ultimate purpose and fulfillment to believers. The pressure felt by parents to ensure their children's spiritual outcomes is discussed, debunking the myth that success is solely defined by their children's faith choices. The misconception of a limited timeframe for passing on faith to children is addressed, highlighting the undue burden it places on parents.
  • The concept of a limited timeframe to pass on faith to children suggests that there is a critical period in a child's life where parents must impart religious beliefs for them to take root effectively. This idea can create pressure on parents to ensure their children embrace faith within a specific timeframe, often leading to anxiety and feelings of failure if this window is perceived to have passed. It implies that the effectiveness of a parent's efforts in nurturing their child's faith is judged based on whether the child embraces the family's religious beliefs within this perceived timeframe. This belief can overshadow the broader, lifelong journey of faith development and may overlook the individuality of each child's spiritual growth process.
  • Parents often feel immense pressure to ensure their children follow a particular spiritual path, suc ...

Counterarguments

  • While loving God is central to many believers, some argue that parenting can be a divine calling in itself, and that loving one's children deeply does not necessarily detract from one's love for God.
  • Some individuals find deep purpose and fulfillment in parenting, and this does not inherently conflict with their spiritual life or devotion to God.
  • While it's true that a parent's success should not be solely judged by their children's spiritual outcomes, some argue that parents do play a critical role in shaping their ch ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Never Perfect: Finding More Joy, and Less Guilt, As a Mom

True Freedom in Parenting

Leslie Leyland Fields shares insights on how to find true freedom in the role of parenting, balancing love and acceptance with an understanding of the true nature of parental responsibility.

Loving and accepting kids as they are

Fields acknowledges the immense pressure she experienced in her desire to secure her children's success and to influence their life choices and faith. She learned to love and accept her children as they are, without imposing unrealistic expectations on them for specific outcomes.

Letting go of burden for kids' life outcomes

Fields reveals a moment of epiphany inspired by the Biblical story of Ezekiel, which taught her that she isn't responsible for her children's individual choices and responses. They are endowed with the free choice to listen and obey, or not. By doing so, she let go of the panic and misconception that parenting is a performance and released herself from the burden of responsibility for the ultimate outcomes of her children's lives. She speaks about the relief in recognizing her true role in her children's lives, which is to guide, not to control.

Recognizing parenting as a privilege not a burden

Fields experienced a crucial shift in perception when ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

True Freedom in Parenting

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The analogy of parenting to the process of fishing suggests that parents should set the groundwork for their children's growth and development, much like setting nets to catch fish. It emphasizes the importance of patience and trust in the process, rather than trying to control every aspect of a child's life. Just as a fisherman must wait for the fish to come, parents must allow their children the freedom to ...

Counterarguments

  • While loving and accepting children as they are is important, it is also a parent's responsibility to instill values and guide behavior, which may sometimes require setting expectations.
  • Although parents are not responsible for their children's individual choices, they do play a significant role in shaping their children's decision-making processes and moral compass.
  • Guiding without controlling is a nuanced concept, and there are situations where more direct intervention and control are necessary for a child's safety and well-being.
  • Parenting can indeed be a privilege, but it is also accompanied by significant responsibilities and challenges that can sometimes feel burdensome.
  • Placing love for God first may be beneficial for some, but this perspective may not resonate with individuals of different faiths or those who are non-religious.
  • ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA