Podcasts > Fly on the Wall with Dana Carvey and David Spade > Neal Brennan | Full Episode | Fly on the Wall with Dana Carvey and David Spade

Neal Brennan | Full Episode | Fly on the Wall with Dana Carvey and David Spade

By Dana Carvey, David Spade

In this episode of Fly on the Wall with Dana Carvey and David Spade, the comedians are joined by Neal Brennan to discuss the creative process and challenges of writing and producing comedy. They delve into the unique pressures of crafting and performing comedy, particularly for high-profile platforms like Saturday Night Live (SNL). The conversation also explores the evolution of comedy and comedians' approaches, reflecting on changing performance styles and the need to adapt to technology and audience habits.

Additionally, the guests touch on the more personal aspects of being a comedian, including mental health struggles and finding therapeutic approaches for well-being. Brennan shares his experiences with depression and the practices that help him navigate the industry's pressures, while Carvey and Spade offer their perspectives on these topics.

Listen to the original

Neal Brennan | Full Episode | Fly on the Wall with Dana Carvey and David Spade

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the May 29, 2024 episode of the Fly on the Wall with Dana Carvey and David Spade

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Neal Brennan | Full Episode | Fly on the Wall with Dana Carvey and David Spade

1-Page Summary

The creative process and challenges of writing and producing comedy

Comedians discuss the unique pressures of crafting and performing comedy, especially for high-profile platforms

  • Dana Carvey recounts the competitive environment at Saturday Night Live (SNL), likening it to "Game of Thrones." He discusses balancing competitiveness with fostering creativity.
  • Neal Brennan shares insights on the chaotic writing process at SNL, including significant late-night rewrites to sketches like the Rick James one he wrote with Michael Che.
  • Carvey and David Spade reflect on the often disorganized rewriting process at SNL that sometimes made them doubt the show could proceed.
Balancing creative control with production realities
  • Brennan describes physically moving sketch cards to assert creative control during SNL meetings.
  • For "Chappelle's Show," Brennan and Dave Chappelle rewrote all pitches to match their vision, maintaining full control unlike "Half Baked."
  • Carvey talks about using a faster "presentational" format on "The Dana Carvey Show" to deliver jokes quickly.
Delivering fresh content consistently
  • Brennan contrasts his finite material with endless creativity of comedians like Chappelle.
  • They discuss unpredictable audience reactions and the high standards for making the weekly live show.

The Evolution of Comedy and Comedians' Approaches

Reflecting on evolving performance styles

  • Carvey notes how Steve Carell and Stephen Colbert evolved from hesitant performers.
  • Spade now prefers longer, personal stories in his stand-up for a unique touch.
Club shows vs. specials
  • Carvey prefers intimate 50-seat venues but also does larger theaters.
  • Brennan and Spade note the pressures of filming a perfect special, inspiring more visual comedy for TV.
Adapting to technology and audience habits
  • Brennan incorporates visual effects like appearing on a big iPhone for home viewers.
  • They discuss adapting classic bits for modern, younger viewers with evolving expectations.

Mental health and the personal experiences of comedians

Discussing mental health struggles

  • Carvey comments on the commonality of personal struggles among comedians.
  • Brennan shares his battles with depression intertwined with comedy.
Therapeutic approaches for wellbeing
  • Brennan discusses using psychedelics like ayahuasca in a ceremonial context, helping him transition from depression.
  • He practices daily gratitude checklists inspired by Islamic prayers.
  • Brennan's gratitude combats cynicism from comedy's demands.
  • Spade expresses apprehension about psychedelics, reflecting the fears that come with fame.
  • Carvey casually mentions taking ayahuasca, signaling altered states they sometimes explore.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • At Saturday Night Live (SNL), the competitive environment is compared to "Game of Thrones" due to the intense rivalry and ambition among cast members and writers, mirroring the power struggles depicted in the popular TV series. This analogy highlights the cutthroat nature of the entertainment industry and the constant battle for recognition and success within the show. The comparison suggests that like in the fictional world of "Game of Thrones," individuals at SNL must navigate complex interpersonal dynamics and strategic moves to advance their careers. The reference underscores the high stakes and challenges faced by those involved in creating comedy for a prestigious platform like SNL.
  • At Saturday Night Live (SNL), the writing process can be chaotic due to the tight deadlines and the live nature of the show. Late-night rewrites are common as sketches are constantly refined and adjusted up until the last minute before the show airs. This fast-paced environment often leads to significant changes being made to sketches even hours before they are performed live on air. Comedians and writers at SNL have to be quick on their feet and adaptable to these last-minute changes to ensure the show's success.
  • In the context of "Chappelle's Show," rewriting all pitches to match Dave Chappelle and Neal Brennan's vision means that they would modify and refine the initial ideas submitted for sketches or segments to align closely with their creative direction and comedic style. This process ensured that every aspect of the show, from the concept to the execution, reflected their specific comedic sensibilities and intentions. By reworking all pitches, Chappelle and Brennan maintained creative control over the content produced, allowing them to shape the show according to their unique perspectives and preferences. This approach helped them craft a cohesive and consistent comedic narrative throughout the series, showcasing their distinct voices and humor.
  • Dave Chappelle is known for his ability to consistently generate new and innovative comedic material, showcasing a seemingly endless well of creativity. In contrast, other comedians may have a more limited pool of material or themes they draw from, making their content more finite in comparison. This comparison highlights the varying approaches and outputs of comedians in terms of generating fresh and original material over time.
  • Steve Carell and Stephen Colbert evolved from initially hesitant performers to become highly successful and versatile comedians. Their early careers showcased their comedic talents, but they gradually honed their skills and confidence through experience and diverse roles. Both actors transitioned from comedic roles to more dramatic and nuanced performances, demonstrating their range and adaptability in the entertainment industry. Their evolution highlights the importance of persistence, growth, and embracing new challenges in the pursuit of artistic development.
  • David Spade's preference for longer, personal stories in his stand-up comedy indicates a shift towards more narrative-driven content that delves into his personal experiences and perspectives. This approach allows Spade to connect with his audience on a deeper level by sharing anecdotes and insights from his own life, adding a unique and intimate touch to his performances. By focusing on longer stories, Spade can explore themes, emotions, and humor in a more detailed and engaging manner, showcasing a different facet of his comedic style compared to shorter, punchline-driven jokes. This shift may reflect Spade's evolving comedic sensibilities and desire to offer a more introspective and storytelling-focused experience to his audience.
  • Adapting classic bits for modern, younger viewers with evolving expectations involves taking traditional or well-known comedic routines or jokes and updating them to resonate with today's audience, particularly the younger generation. This process may include modernizing cultural references, adjusting humor styles to align with current trends, and incorporating new technologies or platforms for delivery. Comedians often need to balance honoring the original essence of the joke while making it relevant and engaging for a contemporary audience with different tastes and sensibilities. This adaptation ensures that timeless humor remains fresh and appealing to new viewers who have different preferences and expectations compared to audiences from the past.
  • Ayahuasca is a plant-based psychedelic brew traditionally used by indigenous tribes in the Amazon for spiritual and healing purposes. In a ceremonial context, it is consumed under the guidance of experienced shamans or facilitators to explore one's consciousness and address mental health issues. The brew's psychoactive compounds can induce intense introspection, emotional release, and potentially profound insights. Many individuals report therapeutic benefits from the experience, such as gaining clarity, confronting past traumas, and fostering personal growth.
  • Neal Brennan and David Spade express apprehension about psychedelics in the context of fame due to the potential risks and challenges that come with public visibility and the demands of the entertainment industry. The mention of psychedelics in relation to fame highlights the complexities and pressures that celebrities may face when considering alternative forms of therapy or exploration. This apprehension could stem from concerns about how experimenting with psychedelics could impact their public image or mental well-being in the spotlight. The intersection of fame and psychedelics can raise questions about privacy, personal growth, and the balance between seeking therapeutic experiences and managing the expectations of a public persona.
  • Ayahuasca is a psychoactive brew traditionally used in spiritual and healing ceremonies in South America. It contains DMT, a potent hallucinogenic compound, and is known for inducing intense visual and introspective experiences. People may consume ayahuasca for various reasons, including spiritual exploration, personal growth, and therapeutic purposes. Exploring altered states typically refers to experiencing shifts in consciousness or perception induced by substances like ayahuasca, leading to profound insights, emotional processing, and sometimes spiritual revelations.

Counterarguments

  • While Dana Carvey likens SNL to "Game of Thrones," some might argue that this comparison is hyperbolic and that the competitive nature of SNL, while intense, does not reach the life-and-death stakes of the fictional series.
  • The chaotic writing process at SNL described by Neal Brennan might be seen by some as a necessary part of a show that thrives on topical and timely humor, rather than a negative aspect.
  • The disorganized rewriting process at SNL could be defended as part of the show's charm and a contributor to its spontaneity and authenticity.
  • Brennan's method of physically moving sketch cards for creative control could be criticized as an outdated approach in the digital age, where collaborative software could streamline the process.
  • The full creative control Brennan and Chappelle maintained on "Chappelle's Show" might be seen as limiting the potential for diverse perspectives that could come from a more collaborative environment.
  • Carvey's use of a "presentational" format to deliver jokes quickly on "The Dana Carvey Show" might be critiqued for sacrificing depth for the sake of speed.
  • The contrast between Brennan's finite material and Chappelle's seemingly endless creativity could be challenged by pointing out that all comedians have their own unique pace and style of generating content.
  • The preference for intimate 50-seat venues or larger theaters is subjective, and some comedians might argue that the size of the venue does not necessarily correlate with the quality of the performance.
  • The pressures of filming a perfect special might be seen as a positive challenge that pushes comedians to refine their craft.
  • The use of visual effects, like appearing on a big iPhone, could be criticized for potentially distracting from the content of the comedy itself.
  • Adapting classic bits for modern audiences might be seen by some as unnecessary, with the argument that timeless comedy transcends generational differences.
  • The commonality of personal struggles among comedians could be viewed as a stereotype that overlooks the diversity of experiences within the comedy community.
  • The use of psychedelics like ayahuasca in a ceremonial context is controversial, and some might argue that there are other, less risky ways to address mental health issues.
  • The practice of daily gratitude checklists, while beneficial for some, might not be universally effective, and others might advocate for different mental health practices.
  • The fears associated with fame and the use of psychedelics, as expressed by Spade, could be countered by arguing that these fears are not inherent to fame but rather to personal disposition and past experiences.
  • The casual mention of taking ayahuasca could be criticized for potentially normalizing the use of powerful psychoactive substances without sufficient context regarding their risks and legality.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Neal Brennan | Full Episode | Fly on the Wall with Dana Carvey and David Spade

The creative process and challenges of writing and producing comedy

Comedians discuss the unique pressures of crafting and performing comedy, especially for high-profile platforms like Saturday Night Live (SNL), and reveal the complexities of balancing creativity with the demanding nature of production environments.

Comedians discuss the unique challenges and pressures of crafting and performing comedy, especially for high-profile projects and platforms

Dana Carvey speaks from his experience on SNL, recalling the show’s competing environment, which he likens to the "Game of Thrones of Saturday Night Live." He discusses his own approach to competing for parts and the moderation of his competitive nature. Reflecting on his early stand-up days, Carvey mentions his comfort in smaller venues, which allowed him the space to develop confidence and perfect improvisation.

Neal Brennan shares his insights as well, discussing the chaotic writing process during the week Dave Chappelle hosted SNL in 2016, especially on election night. Brennan and Michael Che wrote a sketch involving Rick James that underwent significant changes throughout the night, showcasing the mutable nature of the show's content and the relentless late-night rewrites that are common practice.

David Spade and Carvey further discuss the often chaotic sketch revision process, with Carvey noting instances when he doubted the show could proceed due to disorganization.

Balancing the desire for creative control over their material with the realities of working within established production environments and frameworks

These comedians express the reality of needing to assert creative control while adapting to the structures within shows like SNL. Brennan recounts a moment when he physically moved a sketch card on a board during an SNL meeting to assert influence over the content that would be aired, a metaphor he refers to as "rushing the cockpit."

In contrast, Brennan and Dave Chappelle had to write all sketches themselves for "Chappelle's Show," rewriting pitches from others like Brian Tucker, a future SNL writer, to better match their vision.

Reflecting on the film "Half Baked," Brennan acknowledges that he and Chappelle should have kept rewriting the script after it was greenlit. He notes their limited foresight over production aspects, indicating the challenge of maintaining creative control, which they achieved later with "Chappelle's Show," where every decision went through him or Chappelle.

Carvey describes a fiasco during "The Dana Carvey Show" due to the practical challenges of producing cont ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The creative process and challenges of writing and producing comedy

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Writing for shows like Saturday Night Live (SNL) involves intense competition among writers to get their sketches selected for the live show. The process includes multiple rewrites and edits, often happening late into the night before the show airs. Writers must navigate a fast-paced and high-pressure environment where ideas can be scrapped or changed rapidly based on feedback and last-minute decisions. The competitive nature of SNL pushes writers to constantly deliver fresh and compelling content under tight deadlines.
  • "Rushing the cockpit" is a metaphor used by Neal Brennan to describe asserting influence over content. It signifies taking bold action to steer the direction of a creative project, akin to taking control of an aircraft by moving towards the cockpit. In the context of the text, it highlights Brennan's proactive approach to shaping the content of sketches on SNL by physically moving a sketch card during a meeting to assert his creative vision. This metaphor underscores the assertiveness and determination required to influence the outcome of a collaborative creative process.
  • During the chaotic writing process on SNL, especially on election night, the pressure intensifies as the writers and performers work to create timely and relevant sketches amidst rapidly unfolding events. The heightened atmosphere can lead to last-minute changes and revisions to ensure the show remains current and engaging for the audience. The unique challenges of crafting comedy in real-time during significant events like election nights require quick thinking, adaptability, and a keen understanding of the audience's expectations. This dynamic environment often pushes the creative team to their limits, testing their ability to deliver quality content under immense time constraints.
  • The practical challenges of producing content quickly in comedy involve tight deadlines and the need to generate material rapidly for shows. The term "presentational" in this context typically means a format that allows for quick delivery of jokes without elaborate setups, enabling comedians to efficiently showcase humor within limited time frames. This approach helps comedians overcome time constraints and deliver punchlines effectively in fast-paced production environments.
  • Creating fresh and compelling content for weekly sketch shows is challenging due to the need for constant innovation within tight d ...

Counterarguments

  • While the text emphasizes the pressures of writing for high-profile platforms like SNL, it's worth noting that some comedians thrive under pressure and may find that it enhances their creativity and performance.
  • The competitive nature of SNL is highlighted, but this environment can also foster collaboration and camaraderie among comedians, leading to better and more refined comedic content.
  • The need for multiple rewrites and edits is portrayed as a challenge, but this process can also be seen as an essential part of honing and improving sketches, ensuring only the best material is presented.
  • The assertion of creative control is important, but working within established production frameworks can also provide necessary structure and discipline that can benefit the creative process.
  • While the text suggests that maintaining creative control is challenging, some comedians might argue that constraints can actually fuel creativity by forcing them to think more innovatively.
  • The discussion about the rapid pace of content delivery might overlook the fact that some comedians excel in fast-paced environments and that the pressure to deliver quickly can lead to spontaneous and authentic comedic moments.
  • The idea that comedians struggle to deliver fresh content consistently may not acknowledge the role of a supportive writing team and the collaborative efforts that can help individual comedians maintain a steady output of material.
  • The variabil ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Neal Brennan | Full Episode | Fly on the Wall with Dana Carvey and David Spade

The Evolution of Comedy and Comedians' Approaches to Performance and Audience Engagement

Comedians discuss how their performance styles and methods for connecting with audiences have evolved, reflecting on the pressures and opportunities presented by changing technologies and audience behaviors.

Comedians reflect on how their performance styles and methods for connecting with audiences have evolved over time

Dana Carvey speaks on comedians’ initial challenges, recounting how Steve Carell and Stephen Colbert were not always the confident personas we know today, and how their stage presence evolved. David Spade shares how he now prefers to tell longer, personality-driven stories in his stand-up routine, creating a personal touch that makes his act more unique. This transition indicates a move towards more personal engagement with the audience.

Discussing the differences between intimate, club-style standup sets and larger-scale, polished specials or televised performances

Carvey expresses a preference for filming specials in intimate 50-seater venues, feeling smaller settings allow for the best comedic headspace. However, he also acknowledges the expectation to perform in larger theaters. Neal Brennan and David Spade juxtapose this with the very different energy and expectations of filming a special, where the pressure to capture the performance perfectly can dampen the show's dynamics. Brennan describes the effective use of more visual comedy to engage the home-viewing audiences, inspired by the vast range of options they have. He uses visual effects like appearing on a big iPhone, underscoring the use of multimedia to create a more impactful viewing experience.

Exploring how advances in technology and changes in audience consumption habits have influenced comedic approaches, including the incorporation of more visual elements and multimedia

Advances in technology have led comedians like Brennan to adapt their stand-up to incorporate visual elements that resonate more through screens to cater to viewers at home. Comics nowadays often augment their performances with visual effects, recognizing the power of mixing visuals with comedic content to enrich the audience's experience. Spade and Carvey acknowledge the necessity of refreshing comedic content wi ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The Evolution of Comedy and Comedians' Approaches to Performance and Audience Engagement

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The evolution of comedy is influenced by changing technologies and audience behaviors. Comedians adapt their performances to engage with audiences who consume content differently due to technological advancements. This adaptation includes incorporating visual elements and multimedia to cater to modern viewing habits. The evolving landscape requires comedians to stay relevant by adjusting their content to resonate with contemporary audiences.
  • In the world of comedy, there is a distinction between intimate club-style standup sets, typically performed in smaller, more casual venues, and larger-scale, polished specials or televised performances. The intimate club-style sets often allow for a more relaxed and interactive atmosphere between the comedian and the audience, fostering a sense of closeness and spontaneity. On the other hand, larger-scale specials or televised performances are meticulously planned and produced, aiming for a more polished and grand presentation that caters to a broader audience beyond the immediate live setting. This juxtaposition highlights the different dynamics, expectations, and approaches that comedians navigate when performing in these distinct settings.
  • Comedians are adapting their stand-up routines by incorporating visual elements and multimedia to appeal to audiences who consume content through screens. This includes using technologies like visual effects and text overlays to enhance the comedic experience for viewers at home. By embracing these tools, comedians can create a more engaging and impactful performance that resonates with mo ...

Counterarguments

  • While the text emphasizes the need for comedians to adapt to smaller attention spans with shorter content, one could argue that there is still a significant audience that appreciates and seeks out long-form comedy and storytelling.
  • The focus on integrating visual elements and multimedia might not always enhance a comedy routine; some purists might argue that stand-up should focus on the strength of the writing and performance rather than relying on visual gimmicks.
  • The idea that comedians must adapt their classic bits to modern audiences could be challenged by the notion that timeless comedy transcends generational divides and that true comedic talent lies in making the old relevant rather than constantly chasing new trends.
  • The text suggests that adapting to technology is necessary for comedians, but one could argue that the essence of comedy is in the human connection and that over-reliance on technology could detract from the authenticity of the performance.
  • The discu ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Neal Brennan | Full Episode | Fly on the Wall with Dana Carvey and David Spade

Mental health and the personal experiences of comedians

In pursuit of laughter and entertainment, comedians often tread through the shadowy terrains of their own mental health struggles. Dana Carvey and Neal Brennan unravel such personal journeys, touching on their respective battles with mental health challenges and the unique experience of comedians in the industry.

Comedians openly discuss their struggles with mental health challenges, including depression, and how they've sought to address and overcome these issues

Dana Carvey comments on the commonality of personal struggles among comedians. This observation gets backed by Neal Brennan, who shares his own encounters with depression, which had become interlaced with his comedic persona. Carvey acknowledges Brennan’s confrontations with depression despite his successful stand-up career, hinting at the widespread nature of such challenges.

Describing the use of psychedelics and other therapeutic approaches that have helped them achieve greater emotional balance and contentment

Neal Brennan speaks on utilizing psychedelics, specifically ayahuasca and MDMA, as a means to counteract his sadness. Inspired by an article sent by Chris Rock, Brennan embarked on ayahuasca experiences that were transformative, intense, and revealing. Contextualizing this within a ceremonial setting, Brennan distinguishes such sessions from recreational drug use, hinting at a journey toward neuroplasticity and a reshaping of the brain. Brennan credits these experiences with helping him wean off antidepressants, transitioning from atheism to a belief in a "central Creation force."

Emphasizing the importance of practices like gratitude and mindfulness in maintaining a healthy, productive mindset as a performer

Brennan shares his personal practice of a gratitude checklist, performed multiple times a day to combat negative thinking patterns. The technique draws inspiration from daily Islamic prayers and was adapted after a conversation with Rainn Wilson. By reminding himself of his accomplishments, Brennan reinforces a positive approach to his life and caree ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Mental health and the personal experiences of comedians

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While the personal experiences of Dana Carvey and Neal Brennan with psychedelics are positive, it's important to note that such substances can have varying effects on individuals and are not universally beneficial or therapeutic.
  • The transition from atheism to a belief in a "central Creation force" due to psychedelic use is a deeply personal experience and may not resonate with or be applicable to everyone's spiritual or philosophical beliefs.
  • The practice of gratitude, while beneficial, may not be a sufficient standalone treatment for some individuals with mental health challenges, and it's important to recognize the value of professional therapy and medical interventions.
  • Emphasizing the importance of mindfulness and gratitude could inadvertently minimize the complexities of mental health issues and the need for a multifaceted approach to treatment.
  • The unique pressures and demands of the comedy industry are acknowledged, but the text does not explore the systemic issues within the industry that may contribute to mental health struggles.
  • While the text presents an open discussion about mental health among comedia ...

Actionables

- You can start a personal "gratitude jar" where you write down something you're grateful for each day and place it in the jar, creating a physical representation of your positive thoughts and a resource to turn to on tougher days.

  • By physically writing down positive aspects of your life and collecting them, you create a tangible reminder of the good things you experience. This can be especially uplifting when you're feeling down or cynical, as you can read through your notes to remind yourself of the positives in your life.
  • Integrate a "mindfulness minute" into your daily routine, where you pause for 60 seconds to focus on your breathing and observe your thoughts without judgment.
  • This brief pause can be done anywhere, anytime and doesn't require any special skills or tools. It's a way to center yourself and can serve as a reset button during a stressful day, helping to maintain a healthier mindset.
  • Create a "comedy jour ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA