The Murder of Roberta "Bobbie" Miller (New Hampshire)
Dive into the chilling details of an unresolved crime with the "Dark Downeast" podcast as host Kylie Low, joined by experts including Advertiser and Ken Dionne, unravel the mysterious murder of Roberta "Bobbie" Miller in New Hampshire. Despite over a decade passing since the crime, the quest for justice continues as Bobbie’s tragic end, alongside her dog in her own home, remains an enigma with suspects close to home but no arrests to provide closure.
Examine the intricate dynamics of a family rocked by suspicion and loss in an episode that intricately lays out the potential motives and peculiar circumstances surrounding those closest to Bobbie—her ex-husband Gary, embroiled in a bitter divorce settlement, and her son Jonathan, scrutinized for his criminal past. The case's transition to the Cold Case Unit and the mounting frustration of families seeking progress in their loved ones' unsolved murders paint a stark picture of an investigation mired in complexity and the desperate need for renewed efforts to find the answers that have evaded law enforcement for years.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Feb 15, 2024 episode of the Dark Downeast
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
Bobby Miller's Murder
The murder of Roberta "Bobby" Miller and her dog in her New Hampshire home in 2010 has remained unsolved for over a decade, with no arrests made. The 54-year-old's death, close to the finalization of her divorce with significant financial disputes, brought her ex-husband and son under suspicion.
Gary Miller - The Ex-Husband as Suspect
Gary Miller, Bobby's recently divorced husband, came under suspicion due to their acrimonious split. Having finalized their divorce just two months prior to the homicide, they were embroiled in a dispute over finances and assets, intensifying the suspicion on Gary. The fact that a cottage Gary obtained in the divorce was destroyed by arson shortly before Bobby's murder also raised questions about a possible connection to the homicide.
Jonathan Miller - Bobby's Son Scrutinized
Concerns about Jonathan Miller's potential involvement in his mother's murder were fueled by his criminal history and the inheritance he could receive. Founding Bobby's body and his subsequent behavior, which was uncooperative with efforts to solve the case, drew attention to him. However, there has been no evidence made public against him.
Closed Case Without Arrest for 14 Years
Despite the discovery of the murder weapon, a substantial reward offered, and ongoing public appeals from the family, the case remains cold. Initial interviews focused suspicions on the ex-husband, yet no charges were made. The transfer of the case to the state Cold Case Unit has not yielded progress, with staffing issues cited as an obstacle and families of unsolved case victims, including Bobby's brother, clamoring for greater attention to these cases.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- The destroyed cottage that Gary Miller obtained in the divorce being linked to the murder of Bobby Miller suggests a potential motive or connection between the ex-husband and the crime. The timing of the arson, occurring shortly before Bobby's murder, raises suspicions of a possible correlation between the two events. This connection implies a possible financial or emotional motive behind the destruction of the cottage and the subsequent murder. The destruction of the property could be seen as a precursor or warning sign to the violent act that followed.
Related Shortform Content
Murder on the Web: Catfish Gone Wrong! | Mystery & Makeup | Bailey Sarian
Bailey Sarian
Mommy Dearest Frames Her Daughter for Murder?! Ew. Stacey Castor | Mystery & Makeup | Bailey Sarian
Bailey Sarian
His Waterbed Secrets - Life Sentence At 14?! Joshua Phillips | Mystery & Makeup | Bailey Sarian
Bailey Sarian
Get access to the context and additional materials
Bobby Miller's Murder
The unsolved murder of 54-year-old Roberta "Bobby" Miller, who was found dead alongside her dog in her Guilford, New Hampshire home in 2010, remains a mystery without any arrests.
Gary Miller - The Ex-Husband as Suspect
Gary Miller, Bobby Miller's ex-husband, was naturally a suspect given the divorce they had just finalized two months before the homicide.
Divorce decree finalized two months before homicide
Bobby and Gary filed for divorce in 2007 due to irreconcilable differences. The divorce, finalized on August 13th, 2010, was characterized as bitter, involving significant wealth and protracted legal disputes over splitting their assets. Despite the divorce decree, Gary was still challenging Bobby in court over shared taxes and legal costs amounting to around $81,000.
Conflicts over finances and assets amid prolonged divorce
Bobby had recently bought a house for Gary, which was paid off upon her death, a point that fueled speculation about a financial motive. Gary’s attorney accused Bobby of squandering over a million dollars and dragging out proceedings, while Bobby claimed the funds were legitimately distributed assets.
Maine cottage fire occurred two days before murder, possible connection
Gary and Bobby once co-owned a cottage in Maine, which Gary received in the divorce settlement. This cottage was destroyed by arson two days before Bobby’s murder, with implications of a potential connection to the motive for homicide.
Jonathan Miller - Bobby's Son Scrutinized
Jonathan Miller, Bobby Miller’s son, also came under scrutiny due to his past criminal history and behavior after the murder.
Had criminal history including burglary convictions
Jonathan had multiple burglary indictments when he was 18, along with other convictions and jail time. He was living nearby in a house purchased with a loan from his mother.
Reportedly found mother's body but frustrated investigators, was possibly a suspect
Jonathan was 23 when he discovered Bobby mortally wounded and called 911. However, he did not participate actively in the family's efforts to solve the crime. Questions arose regarding his potential involvement and motivation related to possibly inheriting money after his mother's death. Although there is no publicly disclosed evidence against him, a controversial billboard raised suspicions about Jonathan's reluctance to take a polygraph test.
Closed Case Without Arrest for 14 Years
Bobby's case went unsolved despite extensive interviews and investigations.
Bobby, 54, found shot to death in kitchen of her New Hampshire home in 2010; dog killed too
Two years after her murder, no specific individuals were labeled as suspects. Despite the revelation of the murder weapon’s details in 2014 and a $55,000 reward for information leading to an arres ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Bobby Miller's Murder
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- The divorce between Bobby and Gary was contentious, involving significant wealth and legal battles over asset division. Gary accused Bobby of mismanaging funds, while Bobby maintained that the assets were fairly distributed. The financial conflicts escalated even after the divorce was finalized, with ongoing disputes over shared taxes and legal expenses. These disputes, along with the destruction of a property owned by the couple shortly before Bobby's murder, raised suspicions of a potential financial motive in the case.
- The connection between the Maine cottage fire and Bobby's murder suggests a potential link between the destruction of the property and the motive for the homicide. The timing of the arson, occurring just two days before Bobby's death, raises suspicions of a possible correlation between the two events. This connection implies that the destruction of the cottage could have been a precursor or related factor to the tragic incident at Bobby's home. The circumstances surrounding the fire and its proximity to the murder investigation add complexity to the case, prompting further scrutiny into potential motives and suspects.
- Jonathan Miller, Bobby's son, had a criminal history that included burglary convictions when he was 18 years old. After his mother's murder, questions arose about his behavior and potential involvement in the crime, especially regarding his actions following the discovery of her body and his reluctance to take a polygraph test. These factors led to scrutiny and suspicion surrounding Jonathan's actions and motivations in relation to the unresolved murder case.
- The lack of progress in solving Bobby Miller's murder case despite extensive investigations indicates the challenges faced by law enforcement in gathering sufficient evidence to make an arrest. Despite interviewing numerous individuals and exploring various leads, the case remains unsolved due to the complexity of the circumstances and the lack of conclusive evidence linking any specific individual to the crime. The involvement of multiple potential suspects, including Bobby's ex-husband and son, adds layers of complexity to the investigation, making it difficult to pinpoint a definitive perpetrator. The passage of time, changing dynamics among the involved parties, and the lack of new leads may have contributed to the stagnation in the case.
- Bobby's family's efforts to keep the case in the public eye involved offering rewards, holding press conferences, and organizing memorial events to generate attention and potentially gather new information or leads in the unsolved murder case. These actions were aimed at maintaining public interest and awareness ...
Counterarguments
...
Related Shortform Content
Murder on the Web: Catfish Gone Wrong! | Mystery & Makeup | Bailey Sarian
Bailey Sarian
Mommy Dearest Frames Her Daughter for Murder?! Ew. Stacey Castor | Mystery & Makeup | Bailey Sarian
Bailey Sarian
His Waterbed Secrets - Life Sentence At 14?! Joshua Phillips | Mystery & Makeup | Bailey Sarian
Bailey Sarian
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
