Podcasts > Dan Carlin's Hardcore History > Show 71 - Mania for Subjugation

Show 71 - Mania for Subjugation

By Dan Carlin's Hardcore History

This episode of Dan Carlin's Hardcore History explores the life and accomplishments of Philip II of Macedon and the early years of his son, Alexander the Great. It delves into Philip's strategic military innovations, including the pioneering of the formidable pike phalanx, which solidified Macedon's supremacy over Greek city-states. The summary also examines Philip's political maneuverings through diplomacy and balance-of-power tactics.

The episode sheds light on Alexander's upbringing, education under Aristotle, and early leadership experiences before the controversial assassination of his father, Philip. It explores the theories surrounding Philip's assassination and the subsequent power struggle that ensued, setting the stage for Alexander's ascension and planned invasion of Persia.

Listen to the original

Show 71 - Mania for Subjugation

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Jun 7, 2024 episode of the Dan Carlin's Hardcore History

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Show 71 - Mania for Subjugation

1-Page Summary

The Rise of Philip II of Macedon

Philip II was a formidable Macedonian king whose military innovations and political acumen led to his rise to power. He came from a tumultuous royal family marked by violence and succession struggles, as Carlin puts it, a "murderous soap opera."

The Macedonian Army Under Philip II

Philip pioneered the nearly invincible pike phalanx with longer spears and deeper ranks, inspired by Theban military ideas. His disciplined and mighty army, superior to Greek city-state militias, made Macedon an unmatched military force. Philip excelled at diplomacy, bribery, and balance-of-power strategies, creating the League of Corinth to unite Greek states under Macedonian leadership.

Alexander the Great's Early Life

The son of Philip II and Olympias, a Molossian princess with an exotic background, Alexander received an elite education under Aristotle in subjects like ethics and politics. At 16, Philip appointed him regent, giving him leadership experience handling the northern insurrection. His precocious talents made Alexander a figure of fascination and scrutiny as heir-apparent.

The Assassination of Philip II

Tensions mounted from Philip's marriage to Cleopatra, straining his relationship with Olympias and Alexander. Alexander's legitimacy was challenged at a wedding, causing a rift with his father. Theories suggest Olympias or Alexander could have been involved in or benefited from the assassination. Other theories implicate Greek states seeking freedom or the Persians. The assassination itself seemed choreographed for Pausanias' escape.

Alexander was quickly proclaimed successor to prevent chaos. He faced consolidating authority and fulfilling his father's Persian invasion plans amid the geopolitical upheaval.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • Philip's military innovations may have been significant, but attributing the success of Macedon solely to his reforms could overlook the contributions of his predecessors and the broader socio-political context of the era.
  • While Philip's family was indeed marked by violence and succession struggles, it's important to consider that such turmoil was not uncommon in royal families across different cultures and time periods.
  • The effectiveness of the Macedonian phalanx can be debated, as it had its weaknesses, such as being less maneuverable, which were exploited in later battles after Philip's death.
  • The unification of Greek states under the League of Corinth may be seen as a forced alliance rather than a voluntary union, with many states joining under compulsion or fear rather than genuine diplomatic agreement.
  • Alexander's education under Aristotle was indeed elite, but it's worth noting that his success cannot be solely attributed to his formal education; his personal qualities, experiences, and the circumstances of his ascension played significant roles.
  • The tensions from Philip's marriage to Cleopatra and the subsequent rift with Alexander could be interpreted differently, considering the complex dynamics of royal marriages and political alliances at the time.
  • The assassination of Philip II and the subsequent theories about the involvement of Olympias, Alexander, or external forces are speculative, and without concrete evidence, these remain as theories rather than established facts.
  • Alexander's quick proclamation as successor and his subsequent actions could be viewed through various lenses, including those that critique his methods and the consequences of his campaigns for the regions he conquered.

Actionables

  • Explore historical strategy games to gain insight into Philip II's military tactics and diplomatic skills. By playing games that simulate ancient warfare and political maneuvering, you can better understand the complexities of Philip's innovations and strategies. For example, games like "Total War: Rome II" feature the Macedonian phalanx and require players to engage in both battlefield tactics and statecraft, mirroring the dual aspects of Philip's reign.
  • Create a family tree or a visual timeline of a historical figure's life to comprehend the impact of personal relationships on their legacy. By researching and visually mapping out the family dynamics and key events in the life of someone like Philip II, you can grasp how tumultuous relationships and political alliances shaped their decisions and historical footprint. This could be done using a simple drawing tool or a digital app designed for creating timelines and family trees.
  • Write a short story or a theatrical play based on the events leading up to Philip II's assassination to explore the various theories and characters involved. This creative exercise allows you to delve into the historical context, motivations, and perspectives of the people surrounding Philip, offering a deeper understanding of the political intrigue of the era. Sharing your work with friends or a local community group can also spark discussions and further exploration of the topic.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Show 71 - Mania for Subjugation

The background and rise to power of Philip II of Macedon

Philip II was a formidable king whose rise to power was marked by military innovation and shrewd political maneuvers, overshadowed only by his son Alexander's greater fame.

Philip II's Macedonian upbringing and royal lineage

Birth into a turbulent royal family

Born around 383-382 BCE into the turbulent atmosphere of the Macedonian court, Philip's life was destined for complexity. Known for a history filled with violence, assassination, and succession struggles, Philip's royal family was likened to a murderous soap opera. He was one of the three brothers who, in succession due to their royal bloodline, became kings, all meeting violent ends — one in wars and two by assassination. Philip's mother, Eurydice, was entangled in sexual and political scandals, and his father, King Amyntas III, practiced polygamy, which influenced the succession and Philip's ascent to power.

Macedonian heritage and royal complexities

Philip's Macedonian heritage set him apart from the southern Greek city-states, which often debated whether Macedonians were Greek. Nevertheless, Macedonians worked hard to assert their Greekness. Philip's upbringing in rugged Macedonian society, which valued toughness and hands-on experiences, likely played a role in defining his martial prowess. Complicated relationships within the royal family, involving infidelity and power machinations, have at times been compared to a mixture of a mafia crime family and a daytime soap opera. Interestingly, the Macedonian kings often intermarried with surrounding tribes, further complicating the royal lineage.

Philip's military reforms and the creation of the Macedonian army

Pioneering the pike phalanx

Philip transformed the Macedonian military, most notably by developing the pike phalanx, distinguishable by its longer spears, closer-packed soldiers, and deeper ranks. These innovations made the phalanx a nearly invincible force against traditional hoplite armies. Inspired by military ideas encountered during his time as a hostage in Thebes, Philip's Macedonian army became unmatched, famed for its professionalism and comprised of a variety of troops including the formidable companion cavalry, elite infantry, engineers, and light troops. All these elements worked together to form the so-called "Macedonian Maserati."

Superiority of the Macedonian army

The discipline and might of the Macedonian army, arguably the most effective in the world during its time, were amplified by Philip's leadership and strategic mind. Macedonians excelled in hand-to-hand combat, which was crucial given their tactical advantage over the less professional citizen militias of the Greek city-states. The Macedonian army's siege engineering capabilities were also revolutionary, allowing for the rapid capture of cities. Carlin highlights the controversial tactic of Philip's men possibly backing up during combat to destabilize the enemy, a maneuver still debated by historians.

Philip's strateg ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The background and rise to power of Philip II of Macedon

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The characterization of Philip's family as a "murderous soap opera" might oversimplify the complex political and social dynamics of the time, which were common in many royal families across different cultures.
  • While Philip's Macedonian heritage is noted, the text does not explore the nuances of Macedonian identity and its relationship with the broader Greek world, which was a matter of contention among ancient historians.
  • The term "Macedonian Maserati" to describe the army is anachronistic and may not effectively convey the historical context of Philip's military innovations to all readers.
  • The invincibility of the Macedonian army under Philip II could be overstated, as no military force is without its weaknesses, and the Macedonians did face challenges and setbacks in certain battles and campaigns.
  • The idea that the Macedonian army was unmatched might overlook the contributions and military capabilities of other contemporary states and cultures, which also had effective military forces.
  • The assertion that Philip's army excelled in hand-to-hand combat and siege engineering could be balanced by acknowledging that these skills were developed over time and through the experience of multiple campaigns.
  • The claim that Philip engaged in bribery and corruption to manipulate Greek politics could be contextual ...

Actionables

  • You can enhance your problem-solving skills by studying historical military strategies and applying their principles to everyday challenges. For example, learn about the pike phalanx formation and see how its principles of unity and strength in numbers can be applied when collaborating on a project at work or organizing a community event.
  • Improve your negotiation tactics by analyzing the diplomatic strategies used in ancient times and practicing them in role-playing scenarios. Take the concept of forming alliances and apply it to building a network of supportive peers; you could create a study group where each member brings a unique skill to the table, mirroring the alliances of Greek city-states.
  • Develop a ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Show 71 - Mania for Subjugation

Alexander the Great's upbringing and early life experiences

Kaya Henderson, Dan Carlin, and other commentators provide insights into Alexander the Great's early life, showcasing how a combination of privileged background, strategic education, and family dynamics shaped one of history’s most iconic leaders.

Alexander's privileged but tumultuous upbringing

Alexander was the son of Philip II and Olympias, a Molossian princess whose exotic background and rumored involvement in mystical practices made her a controversial figure.

Alexander's parents, King Philip II and Olympias, came from distinguished lineages, claiming descent from Heracles and Achilles, respectively. Olympias, particularly, was noted for her formidable character, her participation in Dionysian mystery cults, and her exotic Molossian background. Her strong personality and unorthodox religious practices contributed to her controversial reputation, and influenced Alexander during his early years.

Olympias demonstrated her strong and proactive nature, and she wouldn't take a background role, suggesting she was a significant influence on Alexander. Her mystical and potentially witchy background, alongside her fervor for religious mysteries, likely shaped the prince's early worldview. Olympias is also responsible for setting up Alexander's first tutors, including the Melossian man who instilled discipline in him.

As a young prince, Alexander received an elite education under the tutelage of Aristotle and other prominent scholars, giving him a well-rounded intellectual foundation.

Dan Carlin describes Alexander's education, arranged by Olympias, as progressing from practical discipline to intellectual development. Alexander's first tutor was tasked with toughening him up, his second tutor taught him reading, writing, and the manners of a king, and his third and most famous tutor was Aristotle. The philosopher personally educated Alexander and his friends in a wide array of subjects, ranging from ethics to zoology, providing a well-rounded foundation.

Philip II, understanding the importance of education for his son, offered to rebuild and repopulate Aristotle's hometown as a part of convincing him to become Alexander’s tutor. Under Aristotle’s guidance, Alexander studied subjects such as ethics, politics, and philosophy — knowledge that he would use effectively in his future conquests.

Alexander's early military and political experiences

At age 16, Alexander was entrusted by Philip to serve as regent of Macedon while his father was away on campaigns, gaining valuable leadership experience.

When Alexander was 16 years old, his formal education came to a halt as Philip II appointed him as regent, giving him early exposure to the responsibilities of rulership. During this period, Alexander handled an insurrection to the north of Macedonia, demonstrating his capability in both leadership and military matters.

Alexander distinguished him ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Alexander the Great's upbringing and early life experiences

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • Olympias' influence on Alexander's worldview might be overstated, as the impact of a mother's religious practices on a son's strategic and political acumen is difficult to quantify.
  • The claim that Olympias was responsible for setting up Alexander's first tutors could be challenged by the idea that as king, Philip II would have had the ultimate say in his son's education.
  • While Alexander received an elite education, it's possible that his natural talents and personal ambition played a more significant role in his later success than his formal schooling.
  • The rebuilding of Aristotle's hometown may have been a political move by Philip II with broader implications beyond just securing a tutor for Alexander.
  • The subjects Alexander studied under Aristotle are well-documented, but how much he applied this knowledge to his conquests is open to debate.
  • Alexander's role as regent at age 16 could be seen as a ceremonial position rather than an indication of his actual readiness to lead.
  • The handling of the insurrection in the north of Macedonia by Alexander might have been heavily assisted by Philip's generals and advisors, rather than being a s ...

Actionables

  • Explore your family's unique traditions and incorporate them into your daily routine to see how they shape your perspectives, much like the influence of Olympias on Alexander. For example, if your family has a tradition of storytelling, dedicate time each week to share stories that convey moral lessons or historical knowledge.
  • Seek out a mentor in a field you're passionate about to gain specialized knowledge and experience, similar to Alexander's education under Aristotle. This could be as simple as joining online forums or local clubs where you can connect with individuals who are willing to share their expertise and guide you in your learning journey.
  • Volunte ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Show 71 - Mania for Subjugation

The circumstances and theories surrounding Philip II's assassination

The assassination of Philip II remains one of history's intriguing mysteries, with several theories and much speculation surrounding the circumstances and motivations behind it.

The events leading up to Philip II's assassination

The period leading up to Philip II of Macedon's assassination was fraught with personal and political tensions.

Philip II's second marriage and the ensuing tensions

The marriage of Philip II to the young Cleopatra, which could have caused tensions with his first wife Olympias and his son Alexander, is often seen as a pivotal moment leading to his demise. Kaya Henderson mentions Olympias's rumored involvement in mystical practices, heightening the tensions after Philip found a serpent beside her, leading to a loss of affection. This superstitious and tumultuous backdrop could reflect on the stability of his court and potential motivations for murder. Philip's love-struck marriage to Cleopatra, portrayed as a midlife crisis by ancient sources, further complicated domestic matters and might have had political underpinnings aimed at securing support from influential Macedonians.

Philip's competitive relationships with his various wives and his daughter's politically charged wedding to Alexander of Epirus, to consolidate alliances before the campaign against Persia, also set a complex scene for rivalries and intrigues.

Alexander's legitimacy and the rift with Philip

At a wedding drinking party, Attalus, Cleopatra's uncle, made a provocative toast wishing for a legitimate Macedonian heir, leading to a public altercation with Alexander, who felt his legitimacy was being challenged. This infamous incident caused a sizable rift, and Alexander, along with Olympias, temporarily left Macedon, further straining the father-son relationship.

Theories about the motives and conspirators behind Philip II's assassination

Theories about the assassination range from family involvement to external political machinations.

Family involvement

Dan Carlin and others have noted the potential for Olympias and Alexander to be involved in or benefit from the assassination. The rift following the drinking party incident suggested a direct link between family tensions and the killing. With Cleopatra's marriage potentially sidelining Olympias and Alexander for regency roles, there might have been incentives for them to act. Plutarch's accounts of Olympias honoring Pausanias after the assassination fueled further suspicion of her involvement.

Other factions

External factors cannot be marginalized. Carlin discusses the possibility of Greek city-states orchestrating the murder to reclaim their freedom from Philip's rule. There were also concerns about the Persians, who stood to lose significantly from Philip's military campaigns and might have seen his death as an opportunity to incite Macedonian internal conflict.

The assassination's choreography

The killing itself has been suggested to be highly choreographed, with Pausanias' motives linked to both a personal vendetta and possibly wider conspiracies. Pau ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The circumstances and theories surrounding Philip II's assassination

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The suggestion that Olympias was involved in mystical practices and that this heightened tensions is based on ancient sources, which may be biased or exaggerated. It's important to consider the reliability of these sources and the possibility that such stories were politically motivated slanders.
  • The portrayal of Philip's marriage to Cleopatra as a midlife crisis is a modern interpretation and may oversimplify the complex political and personal motivations behind royal marriages in the ancient world.
  • The rift between Philip and Alexander due to Attalus's toast could be interpreted differently; it might have been a symptom of existing tensions rather than a cause of further conflict.
  • The idea that Alexander and Olympias would have been directly involved in the assassination is speculative. While they benefited from Philip's death, direct involvement has not been conclusively proven and should be treated as one of several theories.
  • The role of Greek city-states and Persians as potential orchestrators of the assassination is also speculative. While they had motives, there is no concrete evidence to confirm their involvement.
  • The assertion that Pausanias' assassination of Philip II was highly choreographed and part of a wider conspiracy is not definitively proven and ...

Actionables

  • Dive into historical detective work by creating a timeline of events surrounding Philip II's assassination using a free online tool like Tiki-Toki. Start by plotting the known events from various sources, then add speculative events based on different theories. This visual approach can help you understand complex historical events and their possible interconnections, much like solving a mystery.
  • Explore the impact of personal relationships on political decisions by journaling hypothetical scenarios. Write a short story where you're a ruler facing similar personal tensions as Philip II, and detail how you would navigate these challenges. This exercise can enhance your empathy and strategic thinking skills by placing you in the shoes of historical figures.
  • Understand the ripple effect of leadershi ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA