In the gripping episode of "Criminal," narrated by Phoebe Judge alongside guests such as Charles Thomas, Marijane Placek, and Ken Bedford, the dark saga of police brutality in Chicago is under the microscope. This particular installment investigates the systematic torture employed by John Burge and his detectives during their tenure at the police department—a chilling period from the 1970s to the 1990s. The episode brings to light the shockingly cruel techniques of electrocution, beatings, and suffocation utilized to extract confessions, primarily from Black men, revealing not just the actions of those directly involved but also a broader culture of racial bias within law enforcement.
Parallel to the harrowing details of these abuses, the episode paints a contrasting portrait of Russ Ewing, a figure of humanity whose reputation for safely escorting suspects to the police station became legendary. Ewing's dedication to protecting the rights of suspects earned him national admiration and underscored his role as a human rights defender. Additionally, the episode delves into the entrenched discrimination at the Chicago Fire Department, with Ewing once again at the forefront of efforts to draw attention to and combat systemic racial inequality. This narrative arch illuminates the pivotal role individuals like Ewing have played in fighting for justice and effecting change, presenting a powerful juxtaposition to the grim realities of corruption and abuse.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
John Burge and his detectives at the Chicago Police Department committed systematic torture to extract confessions, targeting mainly Black men. They employed devastatingly brutal interrogation methods that included electrocution, beatings, and suffocation. From the start of Burge's activities until his dismissal in 1993, over 100 individuals had suffered under this abuse, emphasizing the racial bias ingrained within the department's practices. Despite being fired, Burge avoided immediate criminal charges, prompting significant concern about accountability and justice in law enforcement.
Russ Ewing employed a compassionate approach to earn trust and ensure the safe surrender of suspects to police custody, thereby protecting them from potential abuse. Ewing's commitment to accompany suspects to the police station was a public promise that prevented officers from engaging in misconduct, a process he often made transparent through filmed documentation. He employed his unique communicative abilities to mediate tense situations, which became instrumental in peacefully handling over 100 cases. His efforts earned him national recognition as a defender of human rights and an advocate for the safe surrender of suspects.
The Public Defender's Office in Chicago exposed the alarming trend of police brutality targeted at Black suspects. An urgent appeal to the U.S. Attorney General and testimonies from legal representatives like Marijane Placek revealed the extent of the inhumane practices, including torture to extract forced confessions. These revelations illuminated the systematic abuse inherent within the system, sparking a call for greater accountability and transparency within Chicago's law enforcement.
Russ Ewing not only challenged the status quo within the Chicago Police Department but also took a stand against the pervasive discrimination in the Chicago Fire Department. As one of the few Black firefighters, he experienced and exposed the racial injustices, such as segregation, denial of promotions, and misuse of disciplinary procedures against Black personnel. By sharing these experiences with the media, Ewing incited a call to action that ultimately pressured the department to revise its discriminatory policies. His commitment to justice and equality demonstrated the transformative power of individual activism in instigating institutional reform.
1-Page Summary
Charles Thomas brings to light the heinous actions by John Burge and his group of detectives at the Chicago Police Department, explaining how they systematically used torture to extract confessions from suspects, primarily Black men, for homicides.
Burge and his detectives resorted to torture methods that included attaching electrodes to the genitals of suspects, along with burning, beating, and suffocating them to coerce confessions. This egregious violation of human rights took place during a harrowing period of law enforcement history in Chicago.
By the time John Burge was dismissed from the force in 1993, more than 100 individuals had allegedly been subjected to such torture. The victims of these brutal practices were predominantly Black men, and the racially charged pat ...
The torture of suspects under John Burge and his detectives at the Chicago Police Department in the 1970s - 1990s
...
Russ Ewing, a renowned figure in the field of criminal justice, has developed unique methods for gaining the trust of suspects and ensuring their safe surrender to prevent potential police abuse.
Ewing's journey in this unique role started when a mentally ill man, who was holding hostages, recognized Russ from TV and allowed him to facilitate a peaceful surrender. Ewing's promise to the suspects was clear: if they surrendered to him, he would escort them personally to the station and prevent them from being mistreated. He often documented these surrenders on film, which were broadcast on the evening news, creating a public record that aided in safeguarding them from police harm.
Authorities were aware that Russ was monitoring them closely, which in turn led to a reduction in misconduct and a stricter adherence to the rule of law among officials.
Russ's empathetic and reasoned approach, highlighted by his affirmation that "any kind of living is better than any kind of dying," allowed him to disarm and gain trust from individuals. During an incident with a mental patient holding hostages, he applied this philosophy, leading both of them to walk out safely together.
Ewing was known to be present with the individuals all the way to the police station, at times riding in police cars to ease the suspects' fears. It wasn't uncommon for him to physically link arms with them, showcasing his commitment to their protection. His ability to connect with potentially dangerous individuals on a human level increased his success rate in safely disarming suspects, exemplified by an incident where he disarmed a murder suspect by discharging the suspect’s gun into the ceiling.
Ken ...
Russ Ewing's methods for gaining people's trust and escorting them safely to the police station to avoid police abuse
...
...
The Chicago public defender's office has highlighted the dark legacy of systematic torture towards Black suspects, painting a disturbing image of law enforcement practices during the era in question.
The Public Defender's Office in Chicago takes the extraordinary step of writing to the U.S. Attorney General to bring attention to a grave issue: the systematic torture of Black suspects at the hands of police. They detail practices that are not only inhumane but also fundamentally compromise the justice system.
Public defender Marijane Placek’s testimony provides a harrowing glimpse into the era, confirming the brutal treatment of clients by police. Placek refers to it as a disgrace within the criminal justice system, highlighting that such barbarism was "well known." She recounts a specific incident where a client, driven to desperation by the torture inflicted upon him, scratched a message into a wooden bench explaining that his confession was the direct re ...
The environment of police brutality and the code of silence in Chicago during this era, especially towards Black residents
...
Exploring the impactful role of Russ Ewing, one of Chicago's few Black firefighters who took a stand against discriminatory practices within the fire department. His courageous efforts to bring these issues to light resulted in much-needed changes.
Russ Ewing was not just a firefighter; he was a beacon of change in a department fraught with prejudice. He did not stay silent about the racism he and his fellow Black firefighters faced. They were segregated within their own stations, rarely given promotions, and witnessed white firefighters with misconduct issues being sent to predominantly Black stations as a form of penal reassignment.
Instead of accepting the status quo, he acted. Despite the risks, he began anonymously sharing the troubling realities he faced within the department to the Chicago Defender, a local Black newspaper. Eventually, Ewing made the bold choice to shed his anonymity, which amplified the media's attention on the issue.
Ewing understood the power of visibi ...
Russ Ewing's role in exposing discrimination at the Chicago fire department and pursuing justice stories as a reporter
...
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser