In the latest episode of Crime Junkie, hosts Ashley Flowers and Brit Prawat delve into the harrowing case of a college freshman named Jodie Sanderholm. The episode begins with the ominous tale of Jodie's friend Lori Legeliter, who narrowly escapes a stalking incident involving the same perpetrator, Justin Thurber. Lori's close call serves as a chilling prelude to the ensuing tragedy that strikes her friend. The hosts describe the unfolding fear as Lori notices her slashed tire and fears for Jodie's safety, painting a vivid picture of the constant menace lurking behind the students.
The tragic abduction and murder of Jodie Sanderholm is recounted with meticulous detail, as Ashley and Brit explicate the sequence of events leading to Jodie's terrifying final encounter. Thurber’s past, laden with stalking and violence, is thoroughly examined, providing insight into the systemic issue of predatory behavior going unchecked. The episode also takes a more hopeful turn as the hosts discuss "Jody's Law," enacted in the wake of the tragedy to bolster stalking legislation in Kansas. The podcast not only draws attention to Jodie's story but also underscores the broader implications of her case on legal policies aimed at protecting potential victims from similar fates.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
College freshman Lori Legeliter realizes she is being followed by Justin Thurber after a dance practice on January 1, 2007. She uses evasive actions, driving to a police station, which causes Thurber to abandon the pursuit. Despite this, the stalking continues, and Lori discovers her slashed tire after a subsequent practice, leading her to suspect Thurber's involvement. Lori also fears for her friend Jodie Sanderholm, suspecting she may also be a target of Thurber.
Jodie Sanderholm, Lori's friend and fellow dancer, is abducted by Justin Thurber after stopping at her home mailbox, a common part of her routine. Her absence raises alarm when her mail isn't collected, and her family immediately suspects something has gone wrong. Ultimately, a friend witnesses Jodie in the passenger seat of her car with an unresponsive expression, leading to a search operation.
The search concludes with the heartbreaking discovery of Jodie’s car submerged in a lake and Jodie’s body hidden under brush nearby. The medical examination reveals that she is subjected to repeated strangulations and revived multiple times before being tortured, sexually assaulted, and murdered. The pattern of the injuries suggests an ambush at her mailbox, followed by the prolonged assault.
Justin Thurber has a documented history of violence and stalking extending back to the year 2000. His tendencies particularly focus on Jodie Sanderholm and her sister, Jennifer, whom he has been watching and stalking for years. Prior to Jodie's murder, several women obtain protection orders against Thurber, indicating a long-standing pattern of threatening behavior. His past actions range from attempted sexual assault to following, deceiving, and sexually assaulting young women. Testimonies reveal that he stalked Jodie and Jennifer, watched them without their knowledge, and displayed a consistent behavior of aggression and surveillance.
Following Jodie Sanderholm's murder, Kansas legislators pass "Jody's Law," a new anti-stalking legislation. The law addresses shortcomings in the previous framework, increasing protections for victims and imposing stiffer penalties on perpetrators. The enactment of "Jody's Law" signifies a commitment to safeguard individuals from stalking and prompts other jurisdictions to evaluate and strengthen their own legal defenses against such predatory behaviors.
1-Page Summary
College freshman Lori Legeliter faced a harrowing experience being followed and potentially targeted by an individual from her past, Justin Thurber.
After leaving a dance practice on January 1, 2007, Lori noticed she was being tailed by Thurber in a light-colored Cadillac. Concerned, she took random streets to confirm that she was indeed being followed, and her fears were validated. Not wanting to lead Thurber to her home and feeling increasingly frightened, Lori made the quick decision to drive to the nearest police station. This maneuver seemed to deter her pursuer, as Thurber sped past the station without following her further.
Unfortunately, the ordeal didn't end there. A few days later, on January 5, at the next dance practice, Lori noticed the same Cadillac—and this time she recognized the driver as Justin Thurber, someone from her brother's high school social circle who had made her uneasy in the past. Lori discussed these disturbing events with her friend Cindy and shared her concerns that Thurber might have started following her close f ...
College freshman Lori Legeliter stalked by Justin Thurber after dance practice
...
A tragic sequence of events unfolded when Jodie, unaware of the danger, didn't make it inside her home after practice because she stopped at her mailbox, a part of her daily routine. Her family and friends realized something was amiss when they discovered the mail hadn't been collected.
The investigation into Jodie's disappearance took a grim turn. A friend of Jodie witnessed her in the passenger seat of her own car being driven by a man, and describes that although she waved at Jodie, there was no response, and subsequent phone calls remained unanswered.
The search led by Tim culminated in the discovery of Jodie’s submerged car in a lake, indicating that the sunroof had been forced open from pressure. Close by, Jodie’s remains were found under a pile of deliberately placed brush. It was a harrowing sight – she was naked with purple bruises covering her body, evidence of the horrific ordeal she went through. The bruises and head t ...
Justin abducts Jodie at her home mailbox after lying in wait and assaults her
...
Justin Thurber’s history with Jodie and her sister, Jennifer, involved prolonged stalking and invasion of privacy, cultivating an atmosphere of fear and intimidation.
Before charges were filed against Justin for Jodie's murder, two women from Arc City sought protection orders against him. Although the specifics of Justin watching and stalking Jodie and her sister for years were not directly detailed, the pattern of his behavior with other young women provides a chilling context.
More young women came forward, sharing their unsettling stories about their encounters with Justin, revealing a consistent narrative of stalking and violence. Witnesses claimed to have seen Justin and Jodi together in her car near a wildlife area.
Justin had a long, violent past dating back to 2000, when a woman alleged an attempted sexual assault by him when she was just 14. In 2001, Justin pulled another girl into his car in a KFC parking lot and forced her to sit there for hours. On separate occasions, he sexually assaulted her and followed her when she attempted to leave town.
A 2004 incident involved a teenager who reported being followed home by Justin. In 2006, reports indicate that Justin deceived a young woman about a car for sale and drove her along with an 11-year-old to a remote area; they ran until they could find help and alert the authorities. That same year, another woman reported that Justin had forced her to undress at knifepoint in a remote location. ...
Justin had a long documented history of stalking and violence against women
...
In response to a tragic event, Kansas has passed a new piece of anti-stalking legislation known as "Jody's Law." This move comes after the murder of Jody, a victim of stalking, which highlighted the urgent need for more stringent measures to protect individuals from such predatory behavior.
The law aims to fill the gaps in the previous legal framework, offering stronger protection for stalking victims and ensuring that stalkers face significant consequenc ...
New anti-stalking legislation called "Jody's Law" passed in Kansas after her murder
...
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser