Podcasts > Creating Confidence with Heather Monahan > Confidence Classic: Being Yourself Is Your Biggest Advantage with Cody Rigsby

Confidence Classic: Being Yourself Is Your Biggest Advantage with Cody Rigsby

By Heather Monahan

In this episode of Creating Confidence, Peloton instructor Cody Rigsby shares his journey from concealing his identity as a young gay man in the South to becoming an instructor who embraces his authentic self. The conversation explores how his unscripted teaching style and expressive personality have contributed to his success, and how he adapted his approach during the COVID-19 pandemic to maintain connections with his community.

Host Heather Monahan also discusses strategies for developing public speaking skills, drawing from her extensive experience. She covers practical techniques for improvement, including methods for practicing at home, recording oneself, addressing potential objections upfront, and using audience feedback to refine one's approach. The episode highlights how embracing authenticity and building foundational skills can lead to professional growth.

Confidence Classic: Being Yourself Is Your Biggest Advantage with Cody Rigsby

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Aug 27, 2025 episode of the Creating Confidence with Heather Monahan

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Confidence Classic: Being Yourself Is Your Biggest Advantage with Cody Rigsby

1-Page Summary

Authenticity and Embracing One's Unique Self

Cody Rigsby shares his journey from hiding his identity as a young gay man in the South to becoming a celebrated Peloton instructor who embraces his authentic self. Despite initially concealing his true identity, Cody now advocates for living genuinely, using his platform to inspire others, particularly young gay men. His friends in New York's gay community helped build his confidence to express himself unapologetically.

As a Peloton instructor, Cody's success stems from his authentic, unscripted teaching style. Heather Monahan notes that his expressive personality and distinctive qualities have helped him transition from just an instructor to a notable personality with broader opportunities. His genuine approach resonates with diverse audiences, setting him apart from more traditionally scripted instructors.

Cody's transition from dancer to Peloton instructor demonstrates the value of embracing new opportunities. Initially hesitant about joining Peloton, he made the switch while seeking better compensation than the dance industry offered. When COVID-19 hit, Cody adapted to new challenges, creating online classes and using his platform to inspire and connect with his community during uncertain times.

Throughout this transition, Cody emphasizes the importance of trusting one's foundational skills when facing new endeavors. Despite feeling underprepared at times, he leaned on his resilience and raw talent to succeed in his new role.

Developing Confidence and Public Speaking Skills

Drawing from her extensive experience, Heather Monahan shares insights about public speaking development. With 24 years of experience starting at age 21, she has refined her approach through various speaking environments. Her techniques include practicing at home, recording herself, and addressing potential objections upfront using Chris Voss's technique.

Heather advocates for seeking diverse speaking opportunities, even unpaid ones, to gain valuable experience. She emphasizes the importance of continuous improvement through feedback, suggesting that speakers maintain a document to track audience responses and consistently refine their approach based on this feedback.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • You can embrace your authentic self by starting a daily journal where you reflect on moments you felt most genuine and why. This practice helps you identify patterns in your behavior that align with your true self, encouraging you to replicate these in various aspects of your life. For example, if you notice you're most authentic when engaging in a particular hobby, consider sharing this passion with others or incorporating it into your work.
  • Enhance your public speaking skills by volunteering to speak at local community events on topics you're passionate about. This gives you a low-pressure environment to practice and receive feedback, which can be less intimidating than professional engagements. You might talk about a community project, share a personal story, or educate others on a subject you're knowledgeable about, using the opportunity to refine your delivery and content based on audience reactions.
  • Build confidence in new endeavors by setting small, achievable goals that utilize your foundational skills. For instance, if you're looking to transition into a new career field, identify transferable skills from your current role and set weekly targets to apply these in the context of your desired job. This could involve volunteering for projects that require similar competencies, taking on freelance work, or even role-playing scenarios where you'd use these skills.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Confidence Classic: Being Yourself Is Your Biggest Advantage with Cody Rigsby

Authenticity and Embracing One's Unique Self

Embracing individuality and the unique qualities of one's identity are central themes for instructor Cody Rigsby, who shares his experiences and insights.

Cody Rigsby: Extrovert Living Authentically

Cody Embraced His True Identity to Inspire Others Despite Initially Hiding It

Growing up in the South as a young gay boy, Cody experienced the pressure to conceal his true identity. He recalls instances like turning down Britney Spears music in his car to avoid judgment. Despite these challenges, Cody now stresses the importance of living authentically and confronting one's own falsehoods, explaining that honesty is crucial for joy and happiness. By showing up as exactly who he is, Cody hopes to serve as an inspiration for others, especially young gay men, to also be their genuine selves.

Cody Believes Embracing Uniqueness Helps People Shine

Heather celebrates Cody's transparent self-description, "opinionated homosexual," on his Instagram handle as a courageous act of openness. He argues that by embracing uniqueness, individuals can truly shine. Cody's circle of friends in New York, particularly within the gay community, instilled in him the confidence to be comfortable in his own skin. His best friend Quentin and another friend John Michael stand as examples of living authentically, having encouraged Cody to express his true self unapologetically.

Cody Credits His Unapologetic Self For Success as a Peloton Instructor

Cody's Expressive Personality, Interests, and Quirks on Peloton Resonate With His Audience

Cody Rigsby's success as a Peloton instructor is ascribed to his genuine nature and distinctive qualities, as noted by Heather Monahan. She points out that Cody's transition from just an instructor to a notable personality with an agent and potential future opportunities is rooted in his ability to express his individual traits audaciously. Heather's son, ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Authenticity and Embracing One's Unique Self

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • Start a personal authenticity journal where you document moments you felt most like yourself and why. Reflecting on these moments can help you identify patterns in environments or activities that foster your genuine self-expression. For example, you might notice you feel most authentic when engaging in a particular hobby or with a certain group of friends, which can guide you to seek out similar experiences.
  • Create a "True You" mood board using images, quotes, and items that resonate with your identity. This visual representation can serve as a daily reminder of who you are and what makes you unique. You might include pictures from a memorable trip that sparked self-discovery, a ticket stub from a concert where you felt free, or a quote that speaks to your core values.
  • Practice saying "no" to ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Confidence Classic: Being Yourself Is Your Biggest Advantage with Cody Rigsby

Navigating Career Changes and Challenges During the Pandemic

Cody Rigsby's journey from dancer to renowned Peloton instructor illustrates how embracing new opportunities, even amid challenges like a global pandemic, can lead to fulfillment.

Cody's Shift From Dancer to Peloton Instructor Shows how Embracing Opportunities Leads To Fulfillment

Heather Monahan introduces the story of Cody transitioning from a high-pressure dance career to becoming a master Peloton instructor, highlighting Cody's view of his career as stepping stones, with each role a shift toward new opportunities.

Cody Hesitated With Peloton but Embraced It, Showing Resilience and Stepping Outside His Comfort Zone

Cody discusses his initial reluctance to join Peloton. He recalls the inauthentic networking and the desire to be seen, which ultimately left him dissatisfied in the dance industry. Seeking better pay and feeling used by the dance sector, he was working multiple jobs. The Peloton opportunity seemed like just another gig to make money, but it came through a connection at a club where Cody was working.

During a week of silence, a challenge for someone as communicative as him, Cody found value in pausing and connecting with himself amid the frenetic pace of life in New York. It was during this reflective time that he started to see the breadth of Peloton’s potential impact.

Covid-19 Posed Challenges, but Cody Inspired and Connected His Community Using His Platform

The pandemic brought a new set of challenges. When Covid-19 hit, the initial uncertainty and misinformation heightened fears. Peloton temporarily closed its studio for several weeks, yet as they gained more insight into keeping safe, Cody's fear diminished. He felt pride in how New Yorkers navigated the crisis, seeing the community come together to protect one another.

Cody embraced his role during these times, realizing his ability to inspire and connect his community through Peloton, providing joy and hope. His reciprocal relationship with Peloton members reinforced a sense of community. He appreciated New York's less crowded spaces and adapted by joining movements like Black Lives Matter and having socially distant gatherings.

New online classes, including meditation and dance cardio, were parts of his and Peloton's pivot to adapting new content for those confined at home.

Trusting Skills ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Navigating Career Changes and Challenges During the Pandemic

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While embracing new opportunities can lead to fulfillment, it's also true that not all transitions are successful, and some individuals may struggle to find the same level of satisfaction in a new career.
  • Stepping outside one's comfort zone is often praised, but it can also lead to stress and anxiety, which should not be overlooked when considering a career change.
  • The ability to inspire and connect with a community is commendable, but it's important to acknowledge that not everyone has the platform or personality to do so effectively, especially during a crisis like a pandemic.
  • Trusting in foundational skills is important, but it's also necessary to recognize the value of continuous learning and preparation, as underprepa ...

Actionables

  • You can identify and leverage your existing skills by listing them out and brainstorming how they could apply to a new field or opportunity. For example, if you're good at organizing, consider how that could be useful in project management or event planning, even if you've never worked in those fields before.
  • Create a "comfort zone challenge" where once a week, you deliberately choose an activity that feels slightly uncomfortable or unfamiliar. This could be as simple as attending a new fitness class, trying a different genre of book, or cooking a complex recipe. The goal is to build resilience and adaptability through regular, small acts of courage.
  • Start a "transformat ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Confidence Classic: Being Yourself Is Your Biggest Advantage with Cody Rigsby

Developing Confidence and Public Speaking Skills

Heather Monahan champions the significance of public speaking for personal and professional growth, based on her two decades of experience in sales and communication.

Heather's Public Speaking and Sales Experience Enhanced Her Communication Skills

Decades of Speeches Have Honed Heather's Abilities

Starting at 21 years old, Heather began leading sales meetings which involved delivering speeches for about an hour. Over 24 years, she has honed her public speaking skills through the frequency and variety of her speaking engagements, ranging from large stages to local schools. Heather speaks about adapting to different speaking environments and audiences, even shortly after giving birth, which has dramatically improved her public speaking skills, demonstrating the positive impact that diverse experiences can have on communication skills.

Techniques for Effective Speeches

In terms of techniques, Heather reflects on the importance of practice, recounting how she rehearses at home, in front of a mirror, records herself, and critiques the recordings to improve. She finds that the best speeches are those delivered off the cuff about subjects she's confident and knowledgeable in. Adopting Chris Voss's technique, she leads with objections to preemptively address audience concerns and create a sense of trust and safety. Part of her preparation routine includes visiting the speaking location beforehand, dressing in power colors, writing notes on her shoes, bringing lavender for nerves, and listening to a motivational playlist.

Heather Urges Others to Practice Public Speaking and Embrace Feedback for Continual Improvement

Seeking Speaking Engagements, Even Unpaid, Offers Valuable Experience and Exposure

Heather encourages people to seek various speaking opportunities for experience and exposure. She shares her own experiences from the radio business when she was expected to speak as part of her job. Despite not being paid for these engagements, she accepted them, donating her time, and as a result, she gained invaluable experience speaking in front of diverse audiences and in different environments.

...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Developing Confidence and Public Speaking Skills

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While Heather Monahan emphasizes the importance of public speaking, it's worth noting that not all professions require strong public speaking skills, and some individuals may succeed without them.
  • The idea that unpaid speaking engagements always offer valuable experience can be challenged, as sometimes these opportunities may not align with one's career goals or may exploit professionals by not compensating them for their expertise.
  • The technique of leading with objections, while useful in some contexts, may not be appropriate for all audiences or speaking engagements, and could potentially lead to a negative tone if not handled carefully.
  • The suggestion to visit the speaking location beforehand might not be feasible for everyone due to time constraints or geographical limitations.
  • Dressing in power colors and using lavender for nerves are personal strategies that may not resonate with or be effective for everyone.
  • The emphasis on seeking feedback is important, but it's also crucial to recognize that not all feedback is constructive or useful; discernment is needed to identify which feedback to implement.
  • Storytelling is highlighted as a crucial element, but some effective speeches may be heavily da ...

Actionables

  • You can enhance your public speaking by joining a local improv group to develop quick thinking and adaptability. Improv can teach you to think on your feet, a valuable skill when fielding unexpected questions or dealing with unforeseen issues during a speech. For example, participating in improv scenarios where you must respond to prompts spontaneously can mirror the experience of handling live audience reactions.
  • Create a personal feedback app using a simple survey tool to gather audience impressions immediately after your speeches. By setting up a QR code that links to a feedback form, you can collect real-time responses on your performance, which can be more accurate than recalling comments later. This method ensures you get a wide range of feedback, as people may be more willing to share their thoughts anonymously.
  • Start a public speaking vlog to document your journey and progre ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA