During Argentina's military dictatorship, thousands faced arrest and torture in secret detention centers like Esma. This episode centers on Miriam Lewin, a detained activist whose survival and linguistic skills led to an unexpected release after enduring yearlong imprisonment and "death flights."
The episode also examines Lewin's later efforts with photographer Giancarlo Serrato to investigate these flights — logbooks revealed irregular routes carrying drugged prisoners to their deaths from aircraft. Their work contributed to convictions for crimes against humanity committed under Videla's regime.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
The period of military dictatorship in Argentina saw the rise of Peronism and its eventual suppression by Jorge Rafael Videla's regime, which launched a campaign against political dissidents. As Miriam Lewin recalls, this led to the arrest and detention of thousands, including herself, in clandestine centers like Esma.
Victims, including activists like Lewin, were abducted and subjected to torture, rape, enforced disappearance, and theft. Lewin was questioned and tortured at Esma. An estimated 30,000 were detained, many drugged and dropped alive from planes in "death flights," as Andrés Caballero notes.
Investigations revealed logs of suspicious flights and identified pilots involved. Over 1,100 have been convicted of crimes against humanity, though debate continues over the dictatorship's atrocities, with some downplaying or denying their severity.
From a young age, Lewin was drawn to politics, dreaming of an equitable society. Involved with Peronist groups, she distributed leaflets, unaware of the impending coup. At 19, she was arrested for her activism.
Held at Esma, Lewin was tortured to extract information. She lived in fear of death and betraying comrades under interrogation. Despite the terror, she held a secret ceremony with her boyfriend Juan.
Likely due to her multilingual abilities, Lewin translated articles and propaganda, which Admiral Massera found useful. After a year, under surveillance, she was released to live with her parents. She eventually married another prisoner, had a child, and fled to New York in 1981.
Lewin and photographer Giancarlo Serrato investigated "death flights," relying on witness testimony, ownership records, and flight logs to identify irregular flights and implicate pilots. Their efforts contributed to over 1,100 convictions for crimes against humanity.
1-Page Summary
The period of military dictatorship in Argentina saw the suppression and disappearance of dissidents under the rule of Jorge Rafael Videla.
The Peronist movement, led by Juan Perón, gained the support of the working class and labor unions in Argentina. Perón, who rose to power in the 1940s and served as president, was overthrown, exiled, and later re-elected in 1973. Following his death in 1974, his wife Isabel Perón took over the presidency, but escalating violence led to political instability.
Miriam Lewin recalls the weakening of Isabel Perón's government, as a military coup became inevitable. This coup led to Lieutenant General Jorge Rafael Videla taking power and the suppression of Peronism. His dictatorship launched a campaign against political dissidents, rationalizing acts of violence as a necessary part of a civil war against these individuals.
Miriam Lewin describes her experience of being detained at Esma, a clandestine center that outwardly functioned as a Navy mechanic school but secretly held around 5,000 Argentine citizens. The government acted without due process, engaging in enforced disappearances, torture, rape, theft, and public assassination. Activists like Lewin were abducted and sent to detention centers, becoming part of the "desaparecidos," or the disappeared.
An estimated 30,000 people were subjected to these practices. Many victims were drugged, hooded, tied up, and thrown from planes alive in what became known as death flights.
Human rights groups opposed the laws that shielded Argentina's d ...
Military Dictatorship in Argentina and Repression of Dissidents
Miriam Lewin's harrowing experience of arrest, torture, and eventual survival illustrates the stark reality of political upheaval in Argentina during her youth. As a passionate journalist and political activist, she faced unimaginable challenges but managed to make it through to tell her story.
From a very young age, Miriam Lewin was drawn to journalism and politics. With a deep passion for reading, traveling, and justice, she dreamed of a world where housing, health, and education were accessible to all, regardless of their family's socioeconomic status. At 13, Lewin started engaging with political literature and participated in an anarchist club.
In college, Miriam got involved with a political group associated with Peronism. An active member of Peronist groups, Miriam wrote, printed, and distributed leaflets at rallies, considering her role as non-violent and mainly staying oblivious to the looming threat of a military coup and crackdown on dissidents.
Miriam Lewin was arrested by Argentina's secret police at the age of 19. During her arrest, she was unable to take a homemade cyanide pill she carried for such emergencies. Held in a secret center called Esma, she was questioned and tortured, receiving electric shocks to extract information about her friend and fellow activist, Patricia. Despite the violent and fearful circumstances she faced, the beauty and quietness of Esma struck her as a disturbing contrast to its true purpose.
The rise of Videla to power forced Miriam into hiding, as fears of death and betrayal became a constant concern. The military regime's omnipresence led to a shrinking support network. Relationships intensified under the looming threat of capture and torture, amidst which Miriam and her boyfriend, Juan, held a secret ceremony, unable to marry officially. The terror of betraying comrades under interrogation haunted her throughout her detention.
Despite the lack of explicit mention in the provided materials, Miriam's multilingual abilities and journalism tr ...
Miriam Lewin's Survival From Detention and Torture Experiences
Investigations and efforts towards accountability unveil the harrowing details of "Death Flights" during Argentina’s unelected military rule. Miriam Lewin, a surviving victim, leads a crucial probe to uncover the truth and seek justice for victims, alongside her colleagues and witnesses of the clandestine cruelty.
In December 1978, the military employed a method called "Death Flights" to dispose of detainees. Thirty-five decomposing bodies, including two nuns aiding in the search for missing residents of Buenos Aires, washed ashore, having been thrown unconscious from planes into the ocean.
Eyewitnesses like Andrés Caballero, who learned of the death flights from his grandfather, and rumors provided initial leads. But the bodies lost at sea impeded easy proof of this practice due to the difficulty in retrieving evidence.
The lack of evidence from bodies lost at sea made it difficult to prove the existence of these "death flights," although victims being washed up due to unusual weather conditions allowed a judge to connect at least 10 deaths, including the two nuns, to one of the planes and its pilots.
Miriam Lewin and Italian photographer Giancarlo Serrato undertook a thorough investigation to trace ownership and flight records of planes implicated in these death flights.
They relied on repentant navy officers' testimony, transaction history, and technical logs of a plane called Skyvank. Discoveries revealed three planes still in operation in Luxembourg, the UK, and Florida.
With the help of a pilot translating the logs, investigators identified irregularities in certain flights. Convictions of pilots ensued, with two dying before and after the trial, but the identification remains a professional and personal victory for survivor Miriam.
Over 1,100 military personnel, police officers, and civilians have been convicted of crimes against humanity, with ongoing investigations. The debate is rife about the dictatorship's atrocitie ...
"Death Flights" Investigations and Accountability Efforts
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser