Podcasts > Conspiracy Theories > The Piri Reis Map

The Piri Reis Map

By Spotify Studios

This podcast episode explores the mysterious Piri Reis Map, an early 16th-century map that depicts surprising details of the South American and Antarctic coastlines. The summary introduces Ottoman cartographer Piri Reis, who compiled the map using ancient and medieval charts, including some allegedly captured from Christopher Columbus.

The map's depiction of what appears to be an ice-free Antarctica has sparked theories of an advanced ancient civilization that mapped the continent before it froze over. The episode delves into the potential origins of the map, including speculation about the lost city of Atlantis and claims of sophisticated astronomical knowledge needed to create such a precise map.

While some argue the map provides evidence of a "lost civilization," the episode also presents counterarguments from historians challenging the accuracy of the map's representation of Antarctica. The blurb invites listeners to explore the intriguing debate surrounding this historical artifact's enigmatic details.

The Piri Reis Map

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Nov 6, 2024 episode of the Conspiracy Theories

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

The Piri Reis Map

1-Page Summary

Piri Reis: The Ottoman Cartographer

Piri Reis was an Ottoman historian and cartographer who gained seafaring experience as a pirate alongside his uncle Kamal in the Mediterranean Sea. After joining the imperial navy in 1495, Piri Reis pursued his passion for cartography.

Over three years, Piri Reis compiled a highly detailed world map that combined over 200 different charts from ancient and medieval sources.

According to Piri Reis, he utilized charts attributed to Christopher Columbus, or "Kulunbu," that were captured from a Spanish explorer by his uncle. Despite intricate detail, Sultan Selim I never published the finished map presented in 1513.

Depiction of South America and Antarctica

The map displayed an extraordinarily accurate representation of the South American coastline for the time, surprising given Europeans had only recently discovered the continent.

Piri Reis claimed to have used charts created by the explorer "Kulunbu" (Christopher Columbus) as one of his sources.

A former US Navy captain, Arlington Mallory, noticed that the southern portion resembled the coastline of Antarctica, which was officially "discovered" centuries later.

Mallory and others suggested an ancient, advanced civilization had accurately mapped Antarctica before it froze over, per geological evidence. However, historian Gregory McIntosh challenged these claims, citing inaccuracies in the South American depiction and imaginative elements.

Theories on the Map's Origins

Historian Charles Hapgood proposed the map was based on work by an advanced civilization that charted Antarctica before its ice cover, possibly Atlantis.

Hapgood argued the map's mathematical precision suggested the existence of an ancient society with advanced astronomical and navigational knowledge.

Scholars Rand and Rose Philemaths theorized that Antarctica was the lost Atlantis, displaced southward by continental drift and pole shifts around 9500 BCE.

However, McIntosh directly refuted claims that the map accurately depicted Antarctica, suggesting the mapmakers likely received information from Portuguese sailors about the region.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The map's accuracy regarding the South American coastline could be due to the synthesis of existing knowledge and navigational charts of the time rather than evidence of an ancient advanced civilization.
  • The resemblance of the map to the coastline of Antarctica could be coincidental or due to misinterpretation, as the continent was not explored until much later.
  • Mallory's suggestion that an ancient civilization mapped Antarctica is speculative and not widely supported by the academic community.
  • Hapgood's hypothesis about an advanced ancient civilization, such as Atlantis, is considered fringe by mainstream historians and lacks concrete archaeological evidence.
  • The mathematical precision of the map could be overstated, and the techniques used by Piri Reis might have been within the scope of known cartographic methods of his time.
  • The theory that Antarctica was Atlantis and was displaced by continental drift and pole shifts is not supported by geological and paleoclimatic evidence, which shows that Antarctica has been in its current location for millions of years.
  • McIntosh's challenges to the accuracy of the map's depiction of Antarctica are supported by most scholars, who agree that the map does not provide reliable evidence of the continent's pre-ice topography.
  • The idea of continental drift and pole shifts occurring around 9500 BCE is not consistent with the scientific understanding of plate tectonics, which indicates such processes occur over much longer timescales.

Actionables

  • Dive into the world of cartography by creating your own map of a local area using various historical and modern references. Start by gathering old maps and satellite images of your neighborhood, then sketch out a composite map that includes historical landmarks and current features. This hands-on activity will give you a sense of how cartographers like Piri Reis may have merged information from different sources.
  • Explore the concept of ancient knowledge by reading up on different theories about lost civilizations and their possible contributions to modern science. Choose a theory that intrigues you, such as the idea of an advanced ancient society, and look for books, articles, or documentaries that challenge or support this theory. This will help you develop critical thinking skills and understand the debate surrounding historical interpretations.
  • Engage with the scientific community by attending a lecture or webinar on continental drift, pole shifts, or ancient geography. Look for events hosted by local universities or geological societies that are open to the public. Taking part in these educational sessions can broaden your understanding of the Earth's history and the scientific methods used to study it.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
The Piri Reis Map

The life and work of Piri Reis, the Ottoman cartographer who created the Piri Reis map

Piri Reis, an Ottoman cartographer renowned for his comprehensive world map, merged over two centuries of geographic knowledge into a single, elaborate chart in the early 16th century.

Piri Reis was a Turkish historian and cartographer who lived in the late 15th and early 16th centuries

Piri Reis, whose real name was Hajji Ahmed Muheddin Piri, joined the world of seafaring at the tender age of twelve. Under the command of his uncle Kamal, who led a crew of pirates, Piri Reis learned the arts of navigation and piloting—skills that would later underpin his cartographic legacy. For 14 years, Piri Reis honed his skills through battles and plundering missions aboard ships that roamed and terrorized the Mediterranean Sea, targeting Christian trading vessels.

As a young man, Piri Reis gained extensive seafaring experience as a pirate under the tutelage of his uncle Kamal

Piri Reis's early years were marked by the tutelage of his uncle, a seasoned pirate from whom Piri Reis accrued substantial knowledge in navigation and ship management, experience that would prove invaluable to his later career in the imperial navy and his passion for map-making.

In 1495, Piri Reis and his uncle were officially inducted into the Ottoman imperial navy, allowing Piri Reis to pursue his passion for cartography

After a life in piracy, Piri Reis and his uncle were absorbed into the Ottoman Navy in 1495. His service transitioned into a focus on cartography particularly upon the death of his uncle in 1510.

Over a three-year period, Piri Reis compiled a highly detailed world map that combined over 200 different charts from ancient and medieval sources

Dedicating three years to the project, Piri Reis undertook the herculean task of compiling his world map. He drew upon over 200 charts, encompassing a spectrum of geographic knowledge spanning two millennia, to create an incredibly detailed and complex rendering of the known world.

Piri Reis had to reconcile the often conflicting geographical details from h ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The life and work of Piri Reis, the Ottoman cartographer who created the Piri Reis map

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • Explore your family history to uncover unique skills or professions that you can learn more about. Just as Piri Reis learned navigation from his uncle, you might find inspiration in the careers or hobbies of your relatives. Start by asking family members about their past experiences or dig into online genealogy resources to discover a skill you can adopt or a field to research further.
  • Create a personal map of your life's journey, incorporating places you've lived, traveled to, or wish to visit. Use various sources like photos, journals, and digital maps to piece together your own "world map." This can be a creative project where you annotate your map with personal milestones, much like Piri Reis included Columbus's voyages, to visualize your past and future adventures.
  • Write a narrative of a significant event or journey in your life, similar to how ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
The Piri Reis Map

The contents and accuracy of the Piri Reis map, especially its depiction of South America and Antarctica

The Piri Reis map has sparked intrigue and debate regarding its depiction of the South American coastline and a region resembling Antarctica, given that it predates the official discovery of the latter.

The Piri Reis map displayed an extraordinarily accurate representation of the South American coastline, even though European explorers had only recently discovered the continent

Created in 1513 by Ottoman cartographer Piri Reis, the map impressively depicted the Atlantic Ocean, Africa, North and South America at a time when Europeans had just discovered South America in 1492. Piri Reis claimed to use various sources for his map, including charts by an explorer known as "Kulunbu," the Turkish name for Christopher Columbus.

Piri Reis claimed to have used charts created by the explorer known as "Kulunbu" (the Turkish name for Christopher Columbus) as one of his sources

Piri Reis included a description of Columbus's voyages and the assertion that he used charts from Columbus to inform his own. These charts were supposedly acquired by Piri’s uncle, who captured a Spaniard that had sailed with Columbus.

The map also included depictions of geographic features that had not yet been discovered, such as mountain ranges and rivers

The map also featured details such as mountain ranges, rivers, and representations of people and exotic animals in parts of the world that Europeans had not yet explored. Moreover, some scholars like Charles Hapgood were astonished to find depictions similar to the Andes mountain range present on the map despite these features not having been discovered by Europeans at the time.

A former US Navy captain, Arlington Mallory, noticed that the southern portion of the Piri Reis map resembled the coastline of Antarctica, which was not officially "discovered" until the 19th century

Captain Arlington Mallory scrutinized the map's southern portion, which appeared surprisingly akin to the coastline of Antarctica—a region officially discovered much later in the 19th century.

Mallory and other scholars argued that this suggested the map was based on a much more ancient source that had accurately mapped a still-temperate Antarctica

Mallory and others suggested that because the map showed a detailed and seemingly accurate depiction of a warm Antarctica, the map must have been based on a very ancient source. This improbability is supported by geological and astronomical consensus that Antarctica has been covered in ice for millions of years.

Piri Reis described the mapped southern region as hot, which contradicts modern knowledge that the continent is icy. Additionally, Piri Reis mentioned that Portuguese explorers refused to land in the region because of its serpentine infestation, which again con ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The contents and accuracy of the Piri Reis map, especially its depiction of South America and Antarctica

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The accuracy of the South American coastline on the Piri Reis map may be exaggerated, as cartographic techniques of the time were not precise by modern standards, and the map could be a composite of accurate and inaccurate information.
  • The claim that Piri Reis used charts from Columbus is based on Piri Reis's own annotations, but there is no independent verification of the existence or accuracy of these charts.
  • The depiction of geographic features like mountain ranges and rivers could be coincidental or based on second-hand reports rather than direct knowledge or ancient sources.
  • The resemblance of the southern portion of the map to Antarctica's coastline could be a result of pareidolia, where observers perceive familiar patterns in random or vague images.
  • The argument that the map depicts a warm Antarctica and is based on an ancient source is speculative and not supported by concrete evidence; it may also conflict with established geological and historical knowledge about the continent's climate history.
  • Gregory McIntosh's challenges to the map's accuracy are based on a detailed analysis of the map's features compared to known geography, which sugg ...

Actionables

  • You can explore historical cartography by creating a replica of an ancient map using publicly available historical data and artistic elements. Start by researching maps from the same era as the Piri Reis map and gather information about the geographical knowledge of the time. Then, using drawing or digital design tools, create your own map that includes both accurate and imaginative elements, such as mythical creatures or speculative landmasses. This activity will give you a hands-on understanding of how historical maps were a mix of exploration and creativity.
  • Enhance your critical thinking skills by comparing old and new maps. Get a copy of a historical map, like the Piri Reis map, and a modern map of the same region. Analyze the differences and similarities in geographic features, noting what might have led to the discrepancies. This comparison will help you understand how knowledge of the world has evolved and the importance of skepticism and inquiry in interpreting historical documents.
  • Develop a game that challenges players to identify real versus ficti ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
The Piri Reis Map

Theories about the origins of the Piri Reis map, including the idea that it was based on a map made by an ancient, technologically advanced civilization like Atlantis

Speculation abounds regarding the origins of the Piri Reis map, particularly theories surrounding the involvement of an ancient civilization such as Atlantis, which some believe created an antecedent to the map due to their advanced navigational capabilities.

Historian Charles Hapgood proposed that the Piri Reis map was based on the work of an advanced ancient civilization that had the capability to accurately chart Antarctica before it became covered in ice

Charles Hapgood, in his book "Maps of the Ancient Sea Kings," put forth a startling hypothesis. He suggested that the Piri Reis map was created with information from an earlier source that depicted Antarctica without ice, asserting that the source maps must have originated around 8,000 BCE, before ice started covering the continent. Hapgood also laid out the idea that this ancient civilization had advanced astronomical and navigational knowledge that allowed them to not only reach but accurately chart Antarctica.

Hapgood believed this ancient society, which he speculated could have been Atlantis, must have possessed advanced astronomical and navigational knowledge

Hapgood theorized that the advanced techniques used to create the map implied the existence of an ancient society with superior tools for navigation. He believed this civilization could reach and map remote areas of the globe with precision long before the era of Columbus.

To support this theory, Hapgood pointed to the mathematical precision of the grid system evident on the Piri Reis map, which he claimed was more advanced than what should have been possible at the time

Further support for Hapgood's theory came from his creation of a grid using several compass roses included by Piri Reis on the map. This, he believed, affirmed the map's high precision and accuracy, which he deemed too advanced for the time it was supposedly made.

Other scholars, like Rand and Rose Philemaths, built on Hapgood's ideas, arguing that Antarctica was in fact the lost continent of Atlantis

The Philemaths claimed that the geological features of Antarctica matched descriptions of Atlantis, and that it was displaced southward by continental drift and a shifting of the Earth's poles

Building on Hapgood’s theories, Rand an ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Theories about the origins of the Piri Reis map, including the idea that it was based on a map made by an ancient, technologically advanced civilization like Atlantis

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The Piri Reis map is widely accepted by historians and cartographers to be based on earlier source maps, but there is no concrete evidence linking it to a civilization like Atlantis.
  • The idea that an ancient civilization had the capability to accurately chart Antarctica is not supported by mainstream archaeological or historical evidence.
  • Hapgood's theories about advanced ancient civilizations are considered fringe by the academic community and lack empirical support.
  • The mathematical precision of the grid system on the Piri Reis map can be attributed to the cartographic knowledge of the time, which was more advanced than Hapgood credited.
  • The hypothesis that Antarctica is the lost continent of Atlantis is not supported by geological or paleoclimatological evidence, and the theory of continental drift does not ...

Actionables

  • You can explore historical cartography by creating a replica of an ancient map using available historical data and artistic techniques. Start by researching different ancient maps online or in history books, focusing on their unique features such as symbols, color schemes, and geographical representations. Then, using art supplies like parchment paper, ink, and watercolors, try to recreate one of these maps, such as the Piri Reis map, to gain a deeper appreciation for the skill and knowledge required in ancient map-making.
  • Enhance your understanding of geography by comparing historical and modern maps. Print out a map from a historical period, like the Piri Reis map, alongside a current map of the same region. Look for differences and similarities in landforms, coastlines, and place names. This hands-on comparison can help you appreciate the evolution of cartography and the geographical knowledge of ancient civilizations.
  • Develop your critical think ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA