Podcasts > Conspiracy Theories > Mummy Murder Cover-Up

Mummy Murder Cover-Up

By Spotify Studios

The 1923 discovery of King Tutankhamun's tomb sparked a sensational archaeological find and fueled enduring tales of the "Mummy's Curse" — a myth propagated by suspicious deaths surrounding the expedition. This episode of Conspiracy Theories dissects the age-old questions surrounding the tragic boy king's demise.

From anomalies like the mummy's erect penis and missing heart to signs of deliberate erasure by succeeding rulers seeking power, the podcast explores competing theories regarding Tut's death and the validity of the infamous curse. Was Tut's body tampered with? Was he murdered? Or does evidence point to the more mundane culprit of unsanitary embalming techniques? Journey through the clues and investigations attempting to unravel this ancient mystery.

Mummy Murder Cover-Up

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Oct 2, 2024 episode of the Conspiracy Theories

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Mummy Murder Cover-Up

1-Page Summary

The Discovery of King Tut's Tomb

In 1923, Howard Carter and Arthur Mace uncovered King Tutankhamun's nearly untouched tomb, a serendipitous discovery after centuries hidden beneath the sands. The tomb's pristine state excited Carter, though he claimed a prior break-in to navigate Egyptian laws restricting artifact removal from untouched tombs. Over months, Carter's team meticulously catalogued thousands of artifacts before accessing the burial chamber.

Inspecting the Mummy and Investigating Tut's Death

Early examinations revealed anomalies like the mummy's erect penis and a missing heart, fueling theories of tampering or foul play. 1968 x-rays suggested head trauma, but 2005 CT scans refuted this, showing the loose skull fragments likely resulted from embalming processes. With missing records, the cause of death remains unresolved.

The "Curse" and Suspicious Deaths

After the tomb's opening, several individuals connected to the excavation suffered untimely deaths, sparking the enduring myth of the "Mummy's Curse." Psychics purportedly warned Lord Carnarvon of grave consequences before the tomb's discovery. The suspicious circumstances surrounding these deaths, from infections to violent ends, perpetuated the legend.

Power Struggles and Erasing King Tut

Recent archeological evidence revealed powerful figures like Vizier Ay and General Horemheb deliberately removed records of Tutankhamun's reign and predecessors to establish their own legitimacy after the boy king's death. Ay may have even orchestrated Tut's death and hastily married his widow. The rediscovery of this attempted erasure sheds new light on the intrigue surrounding Tut's life and unexplained death.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • Explore the impact of historical narratives by creating a personal journal entry imagining how future generations might interpret your life. Reflect on what artifacts, digital footprints, or stories would represent you and how they could be misinterpreted or lost over time, much like the fragmented history of King Tutankhamun.
  • Develop critical thinking by analyzing news stories or social media posts for potential biases and missing information. Just as records of Tutankhamun's reign were deliberately removed, question what might not be shown or told in current events and how this could shape public perception.
  • Foster an appreciation for historical preservation by volunteering at a local museum or historical site. Engage with the process of cataloging and preserving artifacts, gaining insight into the meticulous work similar to Carter's team, and understand the importance of protecting history for future generations.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Mummy Murder Cover-Up

The discovery and exploration of King Tutankhamun's tomb

The podcast explores the remarkable discovery of King Tutankhamun's tomb by Howard Carter and the challenges faced during its excavation and study.

The serendipitous discovery of Tut's untouched tomb by Howard Carter in 1923

In early 1923, Howard Carter and Arthur Mace experienced the serendipity of uncovering King Tut's tomb, a find that had remained unseen for nearly 3,000 years. Concealed under sand and without any visible markers, the tomb's discovery was nothing short of a stroke of luck. The pristine condition of the tomb indicated that it had escaped the hands of grave robbers.

Carter's initial telegram to his financier, Lord Carnarvon, described the tomb as untouched with seals intact. This later presented a controversial contradiction to his claim of a break-in, as mentioned in Egyptologist Bob Breyer's book, "The Murder of Tut'n Common."

Carter and his team were the first to enter the tomb in nearly 3,000 years, uncovering a wealth of ancient treasures and artifacts.

Carter's team spared no time in meticulously documenting each artifact before its removal, a process stretching over the subsequent three months. By February 1923, they had cleared a path to access the second chamber, which was expected to house the sarcophagus.

The challenges and bureaucratic obstacles faced by Carter's team in excavating and examining Tut's mummy

Carter's discovery was not without its challenges, chief among them being the bureaucratic hurdles imposed by the Egyptian authorities.

Carefully documenting and removing the tomb's contents over several months

To comply with Egyptian laws, which restricted the removal of artifacts from untouched tombs, Carter argued that the tomb had been previously entered by robbers, who had taken items so insignificant that their absence was nearly unnoticeable. However, this process of securing agreement from the authorities took an entire ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The discovery and exploration of King Tutankhamun's tomb

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The tomb may not have been entirely untouched, as evidence suggests there were at least two minor intrusions shortly after the initial burial.
  • Carter's claim that the tomb was untouched with seals intact is contradicted by his later admission of a break-in, which could imply that the tomb's condition was not as pristine as initially reported.
  • The meticulous documentation and removal of artifacts, while thorough, may have still caused some damage to the tomb's contents due to the limited archaeological techniques and technologies available at the time.
  • The bureaucratic obstacles faced by Carter's team could be viewed as necessary measures to protect Egypt's cultural heritage rather than mere hindrances.
  • Carter's argument that the tomb had been previously entered by robb ...

Actionables

  • You can explore the concept of discovery by organizing a "Hidden Treasures" scavenger hunt in your local area, using clues based on historical facts or trivia. This activity encourages you to learn about your local history and apply the thrill of discovery in a fun, interactive way. For example, you might research a historical figure from your town and create clues leading to locations they were associated with, hiding small tokens or "artifacts" for participants to find.
  • Enhance your problem-solving skills by creating a "Bureaucracy Board Game" where players navigate through layers of challenges to achieve a goal, mirroring Carter's experience with Egyptian authorities. This game could involve drawing cards that present obstacles or require players to obtain certain approvals, teaching you to strategize and negotiate effectively. For instance, the game could simulate the process of planning a community project, requiring permits and funding, with each step presenting a new challenge to overcome.
  • Develop a deeper appreciation f ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Mummy Murder Cover-Up

Theories about the "Mummy's Curse" and suspicious deaths related to the tomb's excavation

The enduring legend of the "Mummy's Curse" suggests a supernatural punishment befalls those who disturbed the resting place of an ancient Egyptian pharaoh. This narrative has been bolstered by numerous untimely and often strange deaths associated with the excavators of King Tutankhamun's tomb.

The sudden deaths of several individuals involved in the excavation, raising suspicions of a supernatural curse

Accounts of psychic warnings and ominous occurrences preceding the deaths

Before the uncovering of King Tutankhamun's tomb, psychics reportedly issued stark warnings to Lord Carnarvon, the expedition's financier, cautioning him against the endeavor. They foretold doom, asserting that his visit to Egypt and the pharaonic tomb would hasten his death and that a terrible fate awaited anyone who dared violate the young king's eternal slumber.

Examination of the suspicious causes and timing of the deaths, including illnesses, accidents, and assassinations

Following the tomb's reveal, a series of untimely deaths occurred among those linked to the excavation. These deaths fueled suspicion and fascination with the idea of a curse, each demise adding to the enigma:

  • Lord Carnarvon succumbed to an infection from a mosquito bite shortly after the tomb opened.
  • George J. Gould contracted pneumonia after a visit to the tomb.
  • Sir Archibald Douglas-Reed, a radiologist who X-rayed King Tut’s mummy, perished from an undefined illness.
  • Prince Ali Kamel Fahmy Bey was murdered—shot by his wife.
  • Sir Lee Stack, the Governor-General of Sudan, was assassinated in Cairo.
  • Hugh Evelyn White, a witness to the events, ended his own life, reportedly driven by haunting inscriptions of curses.
  • The Egyptologist Erin Ember died in a biz ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Theories about the "Mummy's Curse" and suspicious deaths related to the tomb's excavation

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The belief in a "Mummy's Curse" is not supported by scientific evidence and can be attributed to coincidences and the human tendency to find patterns where none exist.
  • The number of deaths associated with the excavation of King Tutankhamun's tomb is not statistically higher than would be expected given the number of people involved and the period's health conditions.
  • Many of the individuals who died after the tomb's opening lived for many years afterward, which would be inconsistent with a sudden and lethal curse.
  • The reports of psychic warnings could be embellished or fabricated stories that emerged after the fact, playing into the sensationalism of the time.
  • The variety of causes of death among those involved with the tomb could reflect the normal range of mortality risks of the era rather than a supernatural cause.
  • The "Mummy's Curse" narrative can be seen as a form of cultural appropriation and sensationalism that dis ...

Actionables

  • Explore the power of storytelling by creating a fictional short story or novella that weaves in elements of the "Mummy's Curse." Use the theme to craft a narrative that explores the consequences of human actions, similar to how the curse is a response to the disturbance of a tomb. This can be a personal creative project that allows you to delve into the themes of respect for history and the unknown.
  • Develop a themed board game or card game that captures the intrigue of the "Mummy's Curse." Design gameplay that involves players taking on the roles of explorers who must navigate risks and rewards associated with uncovering ancient artifacts. This can be a fun way to engage with friends and family in the mystery and excitement surrounding the curse, without needing any special skills beyond imagination and a love for games.
  • Start a virtual book club focused ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Mummy Murder Cover-Up

Investigations into the cause and circumstances of King Tut's death

Investigations into King Tutankhamun's death have intrigued both the public and scholars alike, as initial examinations revealed anomalies and signs that pointed toward potential foul play.

Initial examination of Tut's mummy in the 1920s, revealing anomalies and signs of potential foul play

The examination of King Tut's mummy initially sparked debates about the cause of his death. British doctor Douglas Derry and Egyptian doctor Saleh Behamed conducted an early examination but could not reach any firm conclusions. Notably, the mummy’s body had an erect penis, which is unusual, and the heart was missing. In ancient Egyptian belief, the heart was essential for the transition to the afterlife, suggesting that whoever buried Tut may not have intended for him to make this journey. The condition of the mummy’s body also suggested possible tampering post-mortem.

Inconclusive findings by the examining doctors regarding the cause of Tut's death

The examining doctors were experienced anatomists, but the task of determining King Tut's cause of death was daunting, and they felt overwhelmed. They were unable to provide conclusive findings regarding how Tut died, leaving many questions unanswered and opening the door to speculation and further inquiry.

Renewed scientific investigations in the late 20th and early 21st centuries

Continued curiosity and the advancement of technology led to new studies of King Tut's mummy, providing clearer insights into the young pharaoh's death.

The 1968 X-ray examination that uncovered evidence of a potential head injury

Dr. Ronald Harrison and a team of British and Egyptian scientists used X-ray technology to scientifically examine the mummy for the first time since the initial assessment in the 1920s. The X-ray revealed small bone fragments loose inside Tut's skull. This discovery led to th ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Investigations into the cause and circumstances of King Tut's death

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The anomalies and signs of potential foul play observed in the 1920s could be attributed to the embalming and burial practices of the time, which may not have been fully understood by early examiners.
  • The missing heart might not indicate foul play but rather an error or variation in the mummification process, as the practices could vary and were not always consistent.
  • The condition of the mummy's body suggesting post-mortem tampering could also be explained by the rushed nature of Tutankhamun's burial, as some theories suggest, rather than intentional malice.
  • The inability of the 1920s doctors to determine the cause of death is not surprising given the limitations of medical knowledge and technology at the time, and it may not necessarily point to a mystery or cover-up.
  • Renewed scientific investigations, while more advanced, still have limitations and are interpreting evidence that is thousands of years old, which can lead to misinterpretations or overestimations of the certainty of their conclusions.
  • The 1968 X-ray examination's findings of a potential head injury could be a misinterpretation of the da ...

Actionables

  • You can explore the history around you by visiting local museums or historical sites to learn about the mysteries and untold stories in your own community. Just like the fascination with King Tut's death, every place has its own tales and historical puzzles. Take a guided tour, read the informational plaques, and ask questions to dive deeper into the history that surrounds you.
  • Start a book club focused on historical mysteries and invite friends or community members to join. Choose books that delve into historical enigmas, such as the death of famous figures or unsolved archaeological puzzles. This will allow you to engage with historical investigations in a social setting, encouraging discussion and critical thinking about the past.
  • Engage in a creative writing exercise by cra ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Mummy Murder Cover-Up

The cover-up and attempted erasure of King Tut's reign in Egyptian history

Professor Ray Johnson's discovery of ancient carvings on medieval masonry in Luxor brought to light a concerted effort to erase King Tutankhamun's legacy from Egyptian history.

The rise to power of Vizier Ay and General Horemheb following Tut's death

Following King Tut's death, Vizier Ay and General Horemheb became powerful figures in Egypt, and both had a hand in shaping the narrative of the past pharaoh's legacy.

Ay's potential involvement in Tut's death and subsequent marriage to Tut's widow, Ankhesenamun

Ay, acting as Vizier and regent during Tut's reign, may have been involved in his death. He potentially orchestrated the deaths of Tut's father Akhenaten and brother Smankhare, paving his way to become Tut's regent and solidify his power. As Egypt urgently needed a new leader after Tutankhamun’s death, Ay maintained his hold on power by marrying Tut's widow, Ankhesenamun, who had limited options for survival.

In the backdrop of these power struggles, Queen Ankhesenamun sought an alliance with the Hittites, possibly to counter Ay’s influence. Furthermore, Ay's unusual depiction on Tut's tomb murals, performing the duties of a priest, suggests he tried to present himself as the righteous successor to Tut's throne. Speculation surrounds his actions as potentially leading to Tut's death through poison or other means, as he feared that Tut would not remain a puppet ruler.

Horemheb's systematic removal of references to Tut and other preceding rulers to establish his own legitimacy

After Ay's death, General Horemheb came to power and actively sought to erase the mentions of Tut and his recent predecessors. Horemheb demolished temples and renounced the records of rulers like Akhenaten, Smenkare, Tutankhamun, and Ay by defacing monuments and statues to establish himself as the rightful successor to Amenhotep III, ignoring those who came before him.

The rediscovery and reconstruction of Tut's legacy by modern archaeologists and Egyptologists

The uncovering of ev ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The cover-up and attempted erasure of King Tut's reign in Egyptian history

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The assertion that Ay was involved in Tutankhamun's death is speculative and not conclusively proven; alternative theories suggest that Tutankhamun died from an accident, illness, or genetic complications.
  • The marriage of Ay to Ankhesenamun could be interpreted as a political necessity rather than a power grab, as royal marriages were often used to stabilize transitions of power in ancient Egypt.
  • The depiction of Ay performing priestly duties in Tutankhamun's tomb could be a traditional role for a regent or acting ruler, rather than an attempt to claim legitimacy as a successor.
  • Horemheb's erasure of Tutankhamun and other rulers from historical records could be seen as an attempt to restore stability and traditional values after the religious upheaval of Akhenaten's reign, rather than a mere power play.
  • The lack of documentation and evidence regarding Tutankhamun's reign could be attributed to the passage of time and the deterioration of mate ...

Actionables

  • Explore your local history by visiting nearby historical sites or museums to understand how the past is presented and what might be missing. By doing this, you'll gain a hands-on appreciation for how history is recorded and remembered, similar to how the story of King Tutankhamun has been pieced together from artifacts and carvings. You might discover plaques, statues, or exhibits that tell a certain narrative and consider what perspectives or events are not being shown.
  • Start a creative project, like writing a short story or creating a piece of art, that reimagines a historical event from an alternative point of view. This can help you grasp the concept of historical bias and erasure, as seen with King Tutankhamun's legacy. For instance, you could choose a well-known event from your country's history and tell the story from the perspective of a lesser-known figure who might have seen things differently.
  • Engage in critical thinking exercises when consuming media by actively questioning the source, potential biases, a ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA