Podcasts > American History Tellers > History Daily: England Becomes a Republic

History Daily: England Becomes a Republic

By Wondery

In this episode of American History Tellers, the story of England's brief period as a republic unfolds through the lens of the English Civil War. The summary examines how tensions between King Charles I and Parliament erupted into open conflict, leading to the parliamentary forces' victory at the Battle of Naseby and the subsequent trial and execution of the king in 1649.

The episode covers the challenges faced by the new republic, including economic difficulties and threats from royalist forces. It traces Oliver Cromwell's rise from military leader to Lord Protector, his attempts to govern England without a monarch, and the ultimate collapse of the republican experiment following his death—culminating in the restoration of the monarchy under Charles II in 1660.

History Daily: England Becomes a Republic

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the May 19, 2025 episode of the American History Tellers

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

History Daily: England Becomes a Republic

1-Page Summary

English Civil War and Cromwell's Rise to Power

The English Civil War emerged from growing tensions between King Charles I and Parliament, centered on issues of sovereignty and authority. The conflict reached a decisive turning point at the Battle of Naseby in 1645, where Oliver Cromwell's tactical brilliance led the parliamentary forces to a crushing victory over the Royalists. This defeat ultimately led to King Charles I's surrender within a year.

The Establishment of the English Republic

Following the war, the parliamentary army took control, purging Royalist supporters from Parliament. The remaining assembly, known as the "Rump Parliament," tried and executed King Charles I in 1649—an action Cromwell supported by signing the death warrant. This revolutionary act paved the way for the establishment of the Republic of England.

The new republic faced significant challenges during its transition from 600 years of royal rule. Cromwell and the council of state moved to suppress the Leveller movement, which demanded equality in wealth and power distribution. The government also confronted financial difficulties, economic struggles, and threats from Charles II's royalist forces, though Cromwell's military prowess helped secure victories in Ireland, Scotland, and at the Battle of Worcester.

Cromwell as Lord Protector and Republic's End

In 1653, frustrated with the Rump Parliament's reluctance to implement reforms and their attempt to manipulate elections, Cromwell dissolved the House of Commons in a dramatic show of force. He then declared himself Lord Protector of England, wielding monarch-like power while refusing the actual title of king.

Upon Cromwell's death in 1658, his son inherited his position but lacked the necessary support to maintain control. The recalled Rump Parliament failed to establish effective governance, creating a power vacuum that ultimately led to the restoration of the monarchy under Charles II in 1660, bringing an end to England's republican experiment.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The Leveller movement was a political group during the English Civil War advocating for democratic reforms, including equality in wealth and power distribution among all Englishmen. They proposed a more egalitarian society with expanded voting rights, religious tolerance, and social justice measures. The Levellers' demands challenged the existing social hierarchy and called for a fairer distribution of resources and political influence. Their ideas influenced later democratic movements and contributed to the development of modern political thought on equality and civil liberties.
  • Oliver Cromwell's victory at the Battle of Worcester in 1651 marked the final major conflict of the English Civil War. The battle resulted in the defeat of Charles II's royalist forces, solidifying Cromwell's military reputation and the Parliamentarian hold on power. Worcester was a significant event as it effectively ended the Royalist threat and paved the way for the eventual restoration of the monarchy in 1660.
  • Cromwell dissolved the House of Commons in 1653 due to frustration with their reluctance to implement reforms and their attempts to manipulate elections. He believed that the Parliament was hindering progress and preventing effective governance. Cromwell's actions were driven by a desire to consolidate power and ensure stability in the face of political challenges. This move allowed him to assert his authority as Lord Protector of England.
  • During the transition from royal rule to the Republic of England, challenges included suppressing the Leveller movement advocating for wealth and power equality, managing financial difficulties and economic struggles, and facing threats from royalist forces supporting Charles II. Additionally, the government had to navigate military campaigns in Ireland and Scotland to secure its position and authority.

Counterarguments

  • The assertion that the English Civil War was solely about sovereignty and authority oversimplifies the complex array of social, economic, and religious factors that also played crucial roles in the conflict.
  • While Cromwell's tactics at the Battle of Naseby were indeed effective, attributing the victory solely to his brilliance may discount the contributions of other parliamentary commanders and the overall state of the Royalist forces.
  • The narrative that Cromwell supported the execution of King Charles I without reservation could be nuanced by acknowledging that there was significant debate and reluctance among some factions of Parliament regarding the regicide.
  • The term "Rump Parliament" is often used pejoratively, and the description of the trial and execution of Charles I might not fully represent the legal and moral arguments presented by contemporaries who supported the king.
  • The suppression of the Leveller movement by Cromwell could be criticized as a betrayal of the republican ideals that many had fought for during the Civil War.
  • Cromwell's role as Lord Protector and his refusal of the crown could be seen not as a rejection of monarchy but as a strategic move to maintain his power without the political liability of the title of king.
  • The description of the end of the Republic and the restoration of the monarchy might be challenged by suggesting that it was not simply a failure of the Rump Parliament but also a complex interplay of political maneuvering, public sentiment, and international pressures.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
History Daily: England Becomes a Republic

English Civil War and Cromwell's Rise to Power

The conflict between King Charles I and the English Parliament set the stage for a profound transformation in English history—the Civil War and the rise of Oliver Cromwell.

Civil War From King Charles I and Parliament Conflict

The English Civil War, a major conflict already stretching over three years, was rooted in political disputes between King Charles I and Parliament. Central to these disputes were issues of sovereignty, authority, and the role of the monarchy.

Cromwell's Victory at Naseby Ends Royalist Hopes

At the Battle of Naseby, on June 14, 1645, Oliver Cromwell commanded the parliamentary cavalry and orchestrated a pivotal victory against the Royalists. Utilizing a tactical advantage, Cromwell led a cavalry charge that exploited the exposed flank of the Royalist infantry. This maneuver at Naseby crushed Royalist aspirations and marked a turning point in the war. The defeat was so severe that Oxford, the Royalist headquarters which had stood staunchly by King Charles I, was eventually compelled to honor Cromwell—a key figure in their defeat.

Following this sweeping victory at Naseby, King Charles I's situation deteriorated rapidly, culminating in his surrender less than a year later.

Cromwell's Victory Led To King Charles I's Trial and Execution, Establishing the English Republic

The domino effects of Cromwell's military success led to significant political repercussions, including the trial and execution of King Charles I.

Rump Parliament Urged King's Execution, Founded Republic of England, 1649

In the aftermath of the war, the parliamentary army stepped in, taking dramatic actions to shape the nation's future. Fe ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

English Civil War and Cromwell's Rise to Power

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • Explore the impact of leadership decisions by journaling about current political events and their potential long-term effects. By reflecting on the decisions made by today's leaders, you can draw parallels to the historical outcomes of the English Civil War, considering how sovereignty and authority play roles in modern governance.
  • Use historical events to enhance critical thinking skills by creating a "What If?" game with friends or family. Pose hypothetical scenarios based on the English Civil War, such as "What if the Battle of Naseby had been lost by Cromwell?" and discuss alternative historical outcomes. This can help you understand the significance of pivotal moments in history and their cascading effects.
  • Develop negotiation skills by role-playing scen ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
History Daily: England Becomes a Republic

The Establishment and Challenges of the English Republic

Following 600 years of royal rule in England, the country experienced a radical and uncertain transition from monarchy to republic. One of the key figures, Oliver Cromwell, helped to suppress a movement for equality as the new republic faced numerous challenges.

Radical and Uncertain Transition From Monarchy to Republic After 600 Years of Royal Rule

Cromwell and Council Suppressed Radical "Leveller" Movement For Equality to Maintain Order

After the defeat of King Charles I, there was a fervent debate about the country's direction. While some parliamentarians called for sweeping reforms, others desired to uphold the social hierarchy with minimal changes. To prevent England from descending into chaos without a monarch, a council of state was appointed, which included Oliver Cromwell, to serve as the executive body. Cromwell and the council faced opposition from the Levellers, a radical group within the army who demanded equitable distribution of wealth and power amongst the people. However, Cromwell believed firmly in maintaining order and authority and suppressed the Leveller movement, prioritizing stability over equality.

New Republic's Challenges: Bankrupt Government, Struggling Economy, and Threat of Royalist Invasion by Charles II

Cromwell led a fierce campaign in Ireland and secured major victories against royalist forces, then moved to Scotland and successfully captured Edinburgh. Charles II, declared leader by the Scots and the Irish, landed with an army in England. Cromwell responded by defeat ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The Establishment and Challenges of the English Republic

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The Levellers were a radical political movement during the English Civil War that advocated for social and political equality, including the redistribution of wealth and power among all people. They believed in expanding political rights, such as universal suffrage and religious tolerance, to create a more egalitarian society. The Levellers challenged the existing social hierarchy and called for a more democratic system that prioritized the rights and freedoms of the common people. Their ideas clashed with those who sought to maintain traditional structures of power and authority in post-Civil War England.
  • The Council of State was a key executive body in the English Republic, established to govern the country in the absence of a monarch. Comprised of influential figures like Oliver Cromwell, the council played a crucial role in maintaining order and stability during the transition from monarchy to republic. It faced challenges from various factions, such as the Levellers, who sought radical reforms for equality. The Council of State worked to navigate these tensions and uphold the authority of the new republic.
  • The Rump Parliament was the remaining parliamentary body after Pride's Purge in 1648, which removed members not supporting the trial of King Charles I. It faced criticism for its reduced size and composition, seen as unrepresentative. The Rump Parliament was ...

Counterarguments

  • The transition to a republic may not have been as "radical" as suggested, considering the gradual build-up of tensions and the previous establishment of parliamentary power during the reign of King Charles I.
  • The suppression of the Leveller movement by Cromwell could be seen as a betrayal of the republican ideals of liberty and equality, rather than a necessary measure to maintain order.
  • The appointment of the council of state, including Cromwell, might be criticized for concentrating power in the hands of a few rather than establishing a more democratic form of governance.
  • Cromwell's prioritization of stability over equality could be viewed as a missed opportunity to create a more equitable society, which was one of the aspirations of the Civil War.
  • The military campaigns led by Cromwell in Ireland and Scotland were marked by brutality and could be criticized for their harshness and the suffering they inflicted on civilians.
  • The safeguarding of the republic by Cromwell's victories is debatable, as his rule later became quasi-monarchical with the establishment of the Protectorate.
  • The tension between the army and the Rump Parliament coul ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
History Daily: England Becomes a Republic

Cromwell as Lord Protector and Republic's End

Oliver Cromwell's tenure as Lord Protector is marked by a tumultuous series of events leading to the eventual collapse of the English Republic after his death.

Cromwell Dissolves Rump Parliament, 1653

In April 1653, Oliver Cromwell, frustrated with the stagnating Rump Parliament that had been elected over a decade earlier, took the bold step to dissolve the House of Commons. Cromwell, who had been at odds with the Parliament over its reluctance to relinquish power and call for new elections, had proposed a compromise for a new ruling council composed of army and parliamentary members to implement reforms before holding elections. The suggestion of power-sharing with unelected soldiers took the Parliament by surprise, and although they promised to consider the proposal, they planned to move forward with an election that would only permit candidates vetted by MPs.

Upon learning that the Rump Parliament intended to proceed with this controlled election, Cromwell and his allies feared for everything they fought for during the Civil War. Determined to prevent the Parliament from entrenching their own power, Cromwell staged an extraordinary demonstration of military might, storming into the parliament with soldiers, expressing his disdain for the members' attempted manipulation of the electoral process, and resulting in the expulsion of MPs and the Speaker of the House.

Cromwell Declared Himself Lord Protector, Ruling England as a Virtual Monarch, Despite Refusing the Title of King

After disbanding the Parliament, Cromwell declared himself Lord Protector of England, a title laden with quasi-monarchical power despite his rejection of the crown itself. His supporters suggested that he become King, but Cromwell refused the title, believing that his reign was under divine guidance. As Lord Protector, Cromwell exercised power in a manner akin to that of a monarch.

Cromwell's 1658 Death Caused Rep ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Cromwell as Lord Protector and Republic's End

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • Cromwell's dissolution of the Rump Parliament can be seen as a power grab rather than a noble act to overcome stagnation, as it allowed him to consolidate power without the checks and balances of a parliamentary system.
  • The proposal for a power-sharing council could be criticized as undemocratic since it included unelected military officers, which might undermine the principles of representative government.
  • Cromwell's rule as Lord Protector, despite his refusal of the crown, might be viewed as hypocritical by some, as his powers were akin to those of a monarch, which contradicts the republican ideals he previously fought for.
  • The collapse of the Republic after Cromwell's death could be attributed not only to his son's lack of support but also to the unsustainable nature of the Protectorate, which relied heavily on Cromwell's personal authority and charisma.
  • The failure of the Rump Parliament to fill the power vacuum might be seen as a result of th ...

Actionables

- Reflect on decision-making in group settings by journaling about times when progress was stalled due to power struggles or lack of direction. Use this reflection to identify personal patterns and consider alternative approaches, such as seeking consensus or setting clear goals, to improve future group dynamics.

  • Practice proactive problem-solving by role-playing scenarios where you must navigate a power vacuum or leadership crisis. This could involve setting up a mock situation with friends or colleagues where you must make quick, decisive actions to maintain stability, mirroring the historical context of leadership transition.
  • Enhance your understanding of governance and powe ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA