This episode of American History Tellers examines the racism and discrimination faced by Black cadets and soldiers in the U.S. military. It recounts the experiences of early African American graduates of West Point, such as Johnson Chestnut Whittaker and Henry Ossian Flipper, who encountered blatant hostility and injustice despite their accomplishments.
The episode also explores the roles of the Buffalo Soldiers, the first peacetime all-Black regiments in the U.S. Army. It details their courage in battles against Apache groups and their involvement in controversial operations like the Wounded Knee Massacre and the forced relocation of Native Americans. Additionally, it sheds light on the troubling neglect and lack of support that decorated Black veterans like George Jordan endured, even after serving their country with distinction.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
The U.S. Military Academy at West Point and the U.S. Army have been places where Black cadets and soldiers faced significant racism and discrimination, as evidenced by the experiences of individuals like Johnson Chestnut Whittaker and Henry Ossian Flipper.
In 1880, one of West Point's first Black cadets, Whittaker, was found unconscious in his room, with injuries and tied up. Despite his account of being attacked by masked assailants, authorities like Lieutenant Colonel Henry Lazell immediately suspected Whittaker had staged the incident, accusing him of self-infliction.
Though initially commended by superiors, Flipper, West Point's first Black graduate, faced a career derailment over a minor financial error. A shortfall in commissary funds prompted charges of embezzlement against him, leading to his court-martial - a reflection of the discriminatory treatment faced by Black officers.
The Buffalo Soldiers displayed bravery in battles with Apache groups, while also participating in morally complex situations involving the forced relocation of Native Americans.
First Sergeant Moses Williams of the 9th Cavalry Regiment showed exceptional leadership against Apache leaders like Nana, serving diligently under a less experienced white officer. Williams and other Buffalo Soldiers endured grueling conditions while campaigning.
After tensions arose from the government's treatment of the Lakota Sioux, Buffalo Soldiers were sent to Pine Ridge Reservation, unfortunately participating in the Wounded Knee Massacre. The 10th Cavalry Regiment also played a role in the capture of Geronimo and the subsequent forced relocation of peaceful Apache families to Florida.
Despite their distinguished service, Buffalo Soldiers like George Jordan, a Medal of Honor recipient, faced dire neglect and discrimination from the army they served.
Despite alarming symptoms, Jordan was denied treatment for a kidney condition at Fort Robinson Army Hospital due to racial prejudice. He died soon after in abandonment and poverty.
Upon returning home, Black veterans like Reuben Walder of the 10th Cavalry faced racial violence, limited opportunities, and little government assistance, despite their valor and sacrifices during the Indian Wars.
1-Page Summary
The U.S. Military Academy at West Point and the wider U.S. Army have both been places where Black cadets and soldiers have encountered significant racism and discrimination. Throughout history, individuals such as Johnson Chestnut Whittaker and Henry Ossian Flipper have faced hostility that reflects the systemic prejudice within the military institutions.
Johnson Chestnut Whittaker, one of the first Black cadets at West Point, faced severe hostility and abuse from his white counterparts. In a shocking incident, Whittaker was found in his room unconscious, with injuries and tied to his bed. Despite his account of being attacked by masked assailants, authorities quickly suspected him of staging the incident for sympathy. On April 6th, 1880, after a violent incident that left him slashed and bound, Lieutenant Colonel Henry Lazell interrogated Whittaker, showing suspicion and disdain toward the cadet's story. Whittaker was consistent in his account, detailing a brutal attack by men dressed in cadet gray. However, Lazell accused him of self-infliction, going so far as to have potential evidence destroyed by cleaning Whittaker's room.
Whittaker was barred from the inquiry into the attack and was ultimately found guilty and dishonorably discharged, though the case was later overturned due to procedural issues. Despite the overturning of his court-martial, he was dismissed from West Point without graduating after failing an exam subsequent to the ordeal he faced.
Henry Ossian Flipper, who roomed with Whittaker during his first year at the Military Academy, became the first Black cadet to graduate from West Point. However, Flipper's success did not shield him from racism's harsh realities.
Despite making a promising start in the Army and receiving commendations from superiors, Flipper’s career derailed when a minor financial error put him under scrutiny. As the quartermaster and ...
Racism and Discrimination Against Black Army Cadets and Soldiers
The story of the Buffalo Soldiers during the Indian Wars is one marked by bravery in battle against formidable opponents as well as difficult conditions, compounded by participation in morally complex scenarios involving the forced relocation of Native Americans.
First Sergeant Moses Williams of the 9th Cavalry exhibited exceptional leadership and valor in clashes with Apache groups led by the likes of Nana. Williams' military prowess came to the forefront during a patrol near Cuchillo, New Mexico, where he led flanking maneuvers in response to Nana's attack on a nearby ranch. Despite his more extensive service, Williams served dutifully under the less experienced White West Point graduate Lieutenant George Burnett. As they pursued Apache leaders such as Nana and Geronimo, Buffalo Soldiers like Williams encountered grueling challenges likely including harsh winters, scarcity of food, and thirst, although these specific details are not elaborated in the content provided.
As tensions escalated following the U.S. government’s seizure of lands from the Lakota Sioux and their confinement to inadequate reservations, Buffalo Soldiers from the 9th Cavalry and other units were dispatched to Pine Ridge Reservation to contain the unrest spurred by the Ghost Dance movement and the subsequent killing of Sitting Bull. Their mission culminated in the unfortunate involvement in the Wounded Knee Massacre, an event that saw the deaths of up to 300 Lakota Sioux, predominantly unarmed women and children. The end of the Indian Wars found the 9th Cavalry performing guard duty in a frigid winter at Pine Ridge, a time they pondered over the injustices witnessed and suffered, even as some expressed their sentiment through poetry.
Another regiment, the 10th Cavalry, which included Buffalo Soldiers, t ...
Buffalo Soldiers' Experiences and Challenges in the Indian Wars
The stories of valued Buffalo Soldiers, like George Jordan and Reuben Walder, reveal a pattern of neglect and discrimination even after their distinguished service.
George Jordan, a Medal of Honor recipient and veteran of the 9th Cavalry, experienced dire neglect by the very nation he served. He visited the Fort Robinson Army Hospital for a kidney condition, but despite alarming symptoms such as blood in his urine, swollen feet, and constant fatigue, the doctors denied him treatment and advised him to seek help in Washington, D.C. Jordan expressed his inability to travel, especially without the funds for a train ticket. At the Fort Robinson hospital, a doctor favoring a white veteran underscored the racial discrimination Jordan faced, leaving him forgotten and marginalized as he was forced to sit untreated in the waiting area.
In a stark illustration of disregard for a decorated hero, George Jordan was not only denied essential medical treatment for his kidney condition but died shortly thereafter in abandonment and poverty with just eleven dollars to his name.
The broader Black veteran community, exemplified by Buffalo Soldiers like the 10th Cavalry's Reuben Walder, endured racial violence, overt Jim Crow segregation, and scant economic opportunities ...
Neglect of Black Medal of Honor Veterans
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser