Podcasts > American History Tellers > Buffalo Soldiers | Cadets of Courage | 2

Buffalo Soldiers | Cadets of Courage | 2

By Wondery

In this American History Tellers episode, the focus is on the Buffalo Soldiers, Black cavalry regiments that played a pivotal role in the American West during the late 19th century. The summary delves into their law enforcement duties, including apprehending individuals refusing to relocate to reservations and disrupting the trade of illegal weapons and alcohol to Native tribes. It also details the environmental challenges these soldiers faced, such as enduring extreme heat and drought.

The episode explores the experiences of Black officers like James Webster Smith, whose harassment at West Point led to his dismissal, and Henry Ossian Flipper, the academy's first Black graduate. Additionally, the summary highlights key campaigns involving the Buffalo Soldiers, including the Red River War and operations aimed at strategically weakening Victorio's forces in the Southwest.

Buffalo Soldiers | Cadets of Courage | 2

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Feb 12, 2025 episode of the American History Tellers

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Buffalo Soldiers | Cadets of Courage | 2

1-Page Summary

Buffalo Soldiers' Law Enforcement Duties and Challenges

Stopping Illegal Activities and Tribal Conflicts

The 10th Cavalry's duties included, according to Sanger-Katz, arresting those refusing to settle on reservations and apprehending white merchants suspected of illegally selling weapons and alcohol, as evidenced by their discovery of whiskey shipments. However, lenient court punishments often undermined their efforts to curb these illicit activities, which escalated tribal conflicts.

Environmental Hardships Faced by the 10th Cavalry

The environment posed immense challenges for the Buffalo Soldiers. In 1877, an expedition led by Captain Nolan had troopers endure over 80 hours without water in extreme heat, forcing desperate measures like drinking horse blood and urine, Sanger-Katz explains. The drought and lack of known water sources exacerbated their plight, known as the Staked Plains Horror.

Black Officers' Struggles and Triumphs

James Webster Smith's Dismissal from West Point

Smith, the first Black West Point cadet, faced vicious racial harassment and unfair disciplinary actions, including being deemed "deficient" in philosophy by a professor, leading to his dismissal in 1874 despite his appeals highlighting prejudice, Sanger-Katz notes.

Henry Ossian Flipper's Significant Achievements

In contrast, Henry Flipper became West Point's first Black graduate in 1877. As a 10th Cavalry officer, he made vital contributions like discovering illegal ammunition sales, designing Fort Sill's long-lasting drainage system, and pursuing Apache leader Victorio relentlessly, even riding nearly 100 miles in under 24 hours to alert his commander, demonstrating immense dedication.

Key Buffalo Soldiers Campaigns

Red River War

The 9th and 10th Cavalries played a crucial but unrecognized role in ending Southern Plains resistance during the Red River War, capturing hundreds of Native Americans and destroying lodges and equipment, Sanger-Katz states.

Victorio's War

Grierson commanded the 10th Cavalry in cutting off Victorio's water access, forcing him into Mexico where Mexican forces killed him. This strategic campaign weakened Victorio's forces significantly.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • Explore local history by visiting a nearby military fort or battlefield to gain a deeper understanding of the challenges soldiers faced. Many historical sites offer self-guided tours or informational plaques that detail the events that took place there, allowing you to walk in the footsteps of figures like the Buffalo Soldiers and reflect on the environmental and tactical challenges they overcame.
  • Start a journal to document instances of perseverance in your daily life, drawing inspiration from historical figures like Henry Flipper. By recording moments when you face and overcome adversity, you can create a personal account that mirrors the resilience demonstrated by individuals who broke barriers despite facing discrimination and hardship.
  • Engage in water conservation efforts at home, inspired by the resourcefulness of the Buffalo Soldiers during the Staked Plains Horror. Simple actions like fixing leaks, taking shorter showers, and collecting rainwater for plants can make you more aware of your water usage and the importance of preserving this vital resource, just as the soldiers had to be mindful of their limited water supply.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Buffalo Soldiers | Cadets of Courage | 2

Buffalo Soldiers' Duties and Challenges In Maintaining Order, Including Stopping Illegal Activities

Buffalo Soldiers, specifically the 10th Cavalry, faced a fraught task in maintaining order on the frontier, grappling with not only law enforcement but also severe environmental challenges.

10th Cavalry Issues: Merchants Trespassing, Supplying Weapons/Alcohol To Raiders, Escalating Tribal Conflicts

The 10th Cavalry played a critical role as watchdogs for native tribes, observing and arresting those refusing to settle on reservations. Under the command of Colonel Benjamin Grierson at Fort Sill, they demonstrated discipline and restraint, notably when they successfully arrested Kiowa war chief Satanta without a massacre, which saved Sherman's life. Yet these troops consistently battled against the chaos of off-reservation activities.

10th Cavalry Ousts Intruders; Courts Give Lenient Punishments, Merchants Resume Activities

During their patrols near the Texas border and the Kiowa Comanche Reservation, the 10th Cavalry troopers confronted white trespassers suspected of peddling whiskey. With the arrest of a merchant and the discovery of whiskey cases in his wagon, their suspicions were confirmed. However, their efforts were often undermined by local courts that provided lenient penalties, permitting apprehended merchants to quickly resume their illegal trades.

Frontier Challenges Like Heat and Drought Hindered the Buffalo Soldiers’ Pursuit of These Outlaws

The environment posed a daunting obstacle for the 10th Cavalry.

1877 Scouting Expedition Nearly Kills 10th Cavalry Troopers

In July 1877, an ill-fated scouting expedition led by Captain Nicholas Nolan had the cavalry pursue Apache and Comanche. With searing temperatures above 100 degrees, the mission turned into a desperate fight for survival as soldiers endured ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Buffalo Soldiers' Duties and Challenges In Maintaining Order, Including Stopping Illegal Activities

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • You can enhance your resilience by setting up a personal challenge that mimics endurance without water, like a day without any beverages except water. This can help you appreciate the value of resources and your own capacity to endure discomfort, similar to the soldiers' experience, but in a safe and controlled way.
  • Develop a habit of learning about local laws and actively participating in civic duties to mirror the Buffalo Soldiers' role in maintaining order. For example, attend town hall meetings or volunteer for community patrols, which can give you a sense of contributing to your community's safety and well-being.
  • Create a personal reflection journal to d ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Buffalo Soldiers | Cadets of Courage | 2

Black Soldiers' Struggles For Army Leadership: James Webster Smith & Henry Ossian Flipper

A tale of formidable challenges and achievements, the stories of James Webster Smith and Henry Ossian Flipper underscore the struggles and contributions of Black individuals in the U.S. military.

James Webster Smith: First Black Cadet at West Point, Faced Racial Harassment, Dismissed

James Webster Smith, born enslaved in South Carolina, surmounted significant barriers early in his life.

Smith Was Repeatedly Disciplined and Deemed "Deficient," Resulting In His Dismissal From West Point, Which He Unsuccessfully Appealed To the Secretary of War

After attending school via the Freedmen's Bureau and receiving a congressional nomination, Smith was admitted to West Point in 1870. As the first black cadet, Smith experienced intense verbal and physical attacks from his classmates. Despite the abuse and against his father's advice—a Civil War veteran—Smith refused to give up his pursuit.

Smith's struggles at West Point were compounded by multiple disciplinary actions taken against him; he was even court-martialed for lying. His persistent arguments with white classmates and a suspension for a year marked his tenure. Tragically, in June 1874, a professor declared Smith deficient in philosophy, which led to his dismissal just one year before completing his studies.

Smith made an appeal to the Secretary of War, William Belknap, explaining how the racial prejudice he faced impacted his studies. Nevertheless, the Secretary upheld the decision on the grounds of maintaining West Point's standards, denying Smith a second chance to demonstrate his capability.

Henry Ossian Flipper: First Black West Point Graduate (1877), 10th Cavalry Officer, Bravery, Intelligence, Dedication

Meanwhile, in a historic milestone, Henry Ossian Flipper became the first black cadet to graduate from West Point in 1877.

Flipper Led Efforts Against Apache Leader Victorio and Designed a Long-Lasting Fort Sill Drainage System

Flipper's post-graduation service saw him join the 10 ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Black Soldiers' Struggles For Army Leadership: James Webster Smith & Henry Ossian Flipper

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • Explore local military history by visiting nearby military sites or monuments to learn about the contributions of minority soldiers in your area. By doing this, you can gain a deeper appreciation for the local stories that mirror the national narratives of individuals like Smith and Flipper, and it may inspire you to share these stories with others or advocate for more inclusive historical recognition.
  • Create a simple blog or social media page dedicated to sharing lesser-known stories of minority military figures. Use platforms like WordPress for blogging or Instagram for photo storytelling to highlight individuals similar to Smith and Flipper, focusing on their achievements and challenges. This can help educate others and preserve the memory of these important figures.
  • Volun ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Buffalo Soldiers | Cadets of Courage | 2

Buffalo Soldiers' Incidents and Campaigns: Red River War and Victorio's War

The Buffalo Soldiers' crucial roles in military campaigns of the late 19th century, such as the Red River War and Victorio's War, are integral yet often under-acknowledged chapters of history.

Role of 9th & 10th Cavalries in Red River War

During the Red River War, the 9th and 10th Cavalries were instrumental in subduing resistance in the Southern Plains.

Buffalo Soldiers Unrecognized For Ending Southern Plains Resistance

The 9th and 10th Cavalries captured nearly 400 Native Americans and over 2,000 animals, destroyed more than 700 lodges, and eliminated large quantities of camp equipment, actions that were vital in bringing an end to armed resistance and moving tribes onto reservations in the Southern Plains. Despite their substantial impact, the Buffalo Soldiers received little credit for their contributions.

Following the Red River War, the cavalries, particularly the 10th, became the primary military presence in far West Texas for a decade, mapping the area and patrolling under often challenging conditions. Their efforts continued to go largely unrecognized in maintaining order and ending resistance in the region.

Victorio's War: 10th Cavalry Under Colonel Grierson Cut Off Apache Leader Victorio's Water Access, Forcing Him Into Mexico, Where He Was Killed by Mexican Forces

The 10th Cavalry, under the command of Colonel Benjamin Grierson, played a pivotal role in the conflict known as Victorio's War, which involved fights with the Apache leader Victorio's forces.

Victorio had led his followers off the San Carlos Reservation, conducting attacks and raids across the U.S. and Mexico. In a strategic move, General Sheridan ordered the 10th Cavalry to pursue Victorio, leading Colonel Grierson to station his soldiers at key watering holes. This tactic was vital because it cut off water access for Victorio's warriors and was essential given Victorio's re-entry into the U.S. through Texas.

In combat near a watering hole on the El Paso-San Antonio road, the 10th Cavalry engaged with ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Buffalo Soldiers' Incidents and Campaigns: Red River War and Victorio's War

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • You can explore local history by visiting sites related to the Buffalo Soldiers to gain a deeper understanding of their impact. Start by researching historical markers, museums, or preserved sites in your area that are connected to the Buffalo Soldiers. Plan a day trip to visit these places, take notes or photographs, and reflect on the significance of their contributions to American history.
  • Create a visual timeline of the events involving the Buffalo Soldiers to better grasp their historical context. Use online tools or a simple poster board to map out the key events mentioned, like the Red River War and Victorio's War. This activity will help you visualize the sequence of events and the scale of the Buffalo Soldiers' involvement.
  • Engage with histori ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA