Podcasts > American History Tellers > Transcontinental Railroad | The Golden Spike | 4

Transcontinental Railroad | The Golden Spike | 4

By Wondery

This episode of American History Tellers delves into the ambitious race to construct the Transcontinental Railroad across the American West in the 19th century. It explores the fierce competition between the Union Pacific and Central Pacific companies as they aggressively pushed their construction crews to lay track westward and eastward respectively. Their showdown was fueled by corruption, labor exploitation, and extreme hardships faced by workers in brutal conditions.

The blurb also examines how insider dealing and bribery by railroad executives enriched them while marginalizing the immigrant laborers who made the railroad possible. Though the railroad's completion was celebrated with a ceremonial golden spike, it came at a steep human cost and facilitated the expansion that decimated Native American populations.

Transcontinental Railroad | The Golden Spike | 4

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Dec 4, 2024 episode of the American History Tellers

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Transcontinental Railroad | The Golden Spike | 4

1-Page Summary

The race between the Union Pacific and Central Pacific

The two companies aggressively raced to lay track across the West

The Union Pacific laid track westward from Wyoming, employing thousands of Mormon laborers. The Central Pacific advanced eastward from Nevada, recruiting Chinese workers. Both pushed crews harshly, fueling accidents, shoddy construction, and ballooning costs as they battled to lay the most track.

Heated negotiations determined the meeting point

As the railroads neared each other in Utah, their executives clashed over the final meeting point, with the Central Pacific insisting on a more eastern location. Congress had to intervene to broker a compromise at Promontory Summit.

Corruption and exploitation within the railroad companies

The Union Pacific's parent company engaged in bribery and fund misuse

The Union Pacific's parent company, Credit Mobilier, enriched executives through profit diversion and congressional bribery, as exposed by investigative reports. This corruption led to unpaid wages and walkouts among Mormon crews.

The Central Pacific's executives amassed fortunes through insider dealing

The "Big Four" Central Pacific directors like Collis Huntington exploited Chinese workers to enrich themselves, concentrating wealth and power.

Extreme hazards faced by construction crews

Desert and winter conditions posed grave challenges

Central Pacific crews endured scorching Nevada desert, transporting water for survival. They resorted to explosives to break frozen ground, destabilizing tracks. Heavy snowfall frequently halted progress.

Worker safety was lacking, causing injuries and deaths

Lack of modern safeguards led to frequent collisions, derailments, and deadly accidents like boiler explosions. Violent clashes between Irish and Chinese crews also proved lethal.

The Transcontinental Railroad's completion

The race concluded with a ceremonial golden spike

After the Central Pacific set a track-laying record, the railroads met at Promontory Summit on May 10, 1869, where the golden spike was driven in celebration.

The railroad transformed America but marginalized its builders

The railroad enabled westward expansion and economic growth, but also the decimation of Native American populations. The Chinese workers behind its construction were then excluded through racist immigration laws.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The Union Pacific and Central Pacific's race to lay track was not merely aggressive but also a reflection of the competitive spirit and rapid technological and industrial development of the era.
  • While the Union Pacific and Central Pacific did employ thousands of Mormon and Chinese laborers respectively, it's important to recognize that these workers were crucial to the success of the project and their contributions, though under harsh conditions, were instrumental in the nation's progress.
  • The harsh treatment of crews may have been a product of the times and the immense pressure to complete the railroad, which does not excuse the practices but provides historical context for the working conditions.
  • The negotiations over the meeting point at Promontory Summit, while heated, were part of the complex political and economic negotiations necessary for such a large-scale national project.
  • The Credit Mobilier scandal, while indicative of corruption within the Union Pacific, was also a catalyst for subsequent reforms in business practices and government oversight.
  • The wealth amassed by the Central Pacific's executives could be viewed within the context of the era's lack of regulatory frameworks, which later led to the establishment of laws to prevent such insider dealings.
  • The challenges faced by Central Pacific crews, such as desert conditions and heavy snowfall, highlight the resilience and ingenuity of the workers in overcoming natural obstacles.
  • The lack of worker safety measures, while tragic, was not unique to the railroad industry and reflects broader historical issues regarding labor rights and safety that have since seen significant improvements.
  • The completion of the Transcontinental Railroad with the golden spike was not just a ceremonial event but a symbolic moment marking the unification of the nation's coasts and the culmination of a massive engineering feat.
  • The transformation of America through the railroad's completion had multifaceted effects, including the acceleration of the Industrial Revolution and the opening of new markets, which can be seen as positive developments despite the negative impacts on certain populations.
  • The marginalization of the builders, particularly Chinese workers, after the railroad's completion, while a dark chapter in American history, also led to increased awareness and eventual changes in immigration and civil rights policies.

Actionables

  • You can explore the impact of historical events on modern society by visiting local historical sites related to the Transcontinental Railroad to better understand its legacy and ongoing influence.
    • Visiting such sites can provide a tangible connection to the past, allowing you to reflect on how historical labor practices and immigration policies have shaped current societal structures. For example, find a nearby museum or historical marker commemorating the railroad and take a self-guided tour to see firsthand the remnants of this monumental project.
  • You can foster awareness of labor history by reading biographies of workers from the era of the Transcontinental Railroad to gain insight into the personal experiences behind the historical facts.
    • Reading about individual stories can humanize the broad strokes of history and give you a deeper appreciation for the struggles and triumphs of those who built the railroad. Look for books or articles that focus on the lives of the Chinese and Mormon laborers to understand their contributions and challenges.
  • You can support modern worker safety and fair labor practices by choosing to patronize businesses that are transparent about their labor policies and actively promote worker well-being.
    • By researching companies before making purchases and opting for those with a clear commitment to ethical labor practices, you contribute to a culture that values the safety and dignity of workers. This could involve checking for certifications or statements on worker safety on company websites or in-store information.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Transcontinental Railroad | The Golden Spike | 4

The race between the Union Pacific and Central Pacific to complete the Transcontinental Railroad

The Union Pacific and Central Pacific railroad companies faced off in a high-stakes race to lay track across the western United States. Grasping for land, resources, and profits, they pushed their workers to the limit, setting the stage for a dramatic showdown in Utah.

The companies aggressively advanced their track-laying efforts across the western United States, with each attempting to outpace the other.

In the spring of 1868, the Central Pacific began laying track eastward from Nevada, while the Union Pacific was advancing westward across Wyoming. Both railway companies sought to lay as much track as possible; the Union Pacific enlisted thousands of Mormon laborers, and the Central Pacific recruited Chinese workers to push their lines across the treacherous terrain.

The Union Pacific recruited thousands of Mormon workers to rapidly grade track in Utah, while the Central Pacific hired Chinese laborers to construct its line eastward through Nevada.

Thomas Durant and the Union Pacific directors wanted to claim Utah and swiftly contracted Brigham Young, who mobilized 5,000 Mormons to grade Echo and Weber Canyons and blast tunnels in eastern Utah. However, as their outstanding payments were delayed, some Mormon workers began walking off the job in the fall of 1868, but most continued working. Meanwhile, the Central Pacific picked up speed with crew boss James Strobridge doubling his workforce, averaging impressive rates of track laying, even accomplishing six miles in a single day.

Both companies adopted reckless strategies, pushing their workers to the brink and resulting in accidents, shoddy construction, and skyrocketing costs.

Union Pacific crews, led by Jack Casement, also set impressive records, laying down eight miles of track in one day and earning triple pay for their efforts. But the frenzied pace came at a cost — accidents, poor construction, and the use of dangerous explosives like [restricted term], matching the Central Pacific Chinese laborers' risky methods. This reckless advance ballooned the costs associated with the construction.

As the two railroads neared each other in Utah, their executives engaged in heated negotiations to determine the final meeting point.

The Union Pacific and Central Pacific railroads found themselves with parallel grading lines running from the Nevada border to Ogden, Utah. As they approached the disputed finish line, executives from both companies struggled to agree on a meeting point, threatening to delay the railroad's completion until Congress stepped in.

The Union Pacific proposed splitting the difference and meeting halfway, but the Cent ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The race between the Union Pacific and Central Pacific to complete the Transcontinental Railroad

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The aggressive advancement of the railroads could be seen as a testament to the industrial spirit and determination of the era, rather than solely a negative competition for land and resources.
  • The recruitment of Mormon and Chinese workers could be framed as an opportunity for employment and economic advancement for these groups, despite the harsh conditions they faced.
  • The strategies adopted by the companies, while indeed reckless, could also be viewed as a reflection of the lack of established safety standards and regulations of the time, which was common in many industrial endeavors.
  • The heated negotiations over the meeting point could be interpreted as a necessary part of the business process where each company was advocating for its own interests, which is a standard practice in negotiations.
  • Collis Huntington's insistence on a meeting poi ...

Actionables

  • You can explore the impact of historical events on modern infrastructure by mapping out the existing railroad lines that follow the original transcontinental routes. Use online maps and historical records to trace the lines, then plan a road trip or virtual tour to understand how these decisions made over a century ago still affect transportation and commerce today.
  • Dive into the art of negotiation by role-playing historical scenarios with friends or family. Assign roles based on the Union Pacific and Central Pacific standoff, and attempt to reach a compromise on a made-up issue of mutual interest. This can help you develop negotiation skills and understand the complexities of reaching agreements.
  • Reflect on the balance between progress and worker ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Transcontinental Railroad | The Golden Spike | 4

Corruption, financial troubles, and worker exploitation within the railroad companies

The late 1800s were a time of rapid expansion for the American railroad industry, but this growth was marred by corruption, financial instability, and worker exploitation.

The Union Pacific's parent company, Credit Mobilier, was embroiled in a major scandal involving the diversion of funds and the bribery of government officials.

In 1868, the Union Pacific's parent company, Credit Mobilier, distributed nearly $13 million in cash dividends to its members, including Thomas Durant and Congressman Oakes Ames. Charles Francis Adams Jr. exposed the corrupt nature of Credit Mobilier, with an article detailing its members' multiple roles, and highlighting the organization's inherent conflicts of interest.

Despite generating massive profits, Credit Mobilier failed to pay its workers, leading to unrest and walkouts among the Mormon laborers in Utah.

Thomas Durant, having resigned from the Union Pacific following the completion of the railroad, fell behind on payments, causing unrest among Mormon laborers. By January 1869, Durant owed the workers $750,000 in back wages, and despite Brigham Young covering wages to maintain labor, Durant continued to neglect payment requests.

Congressman Oakes Ames, a Credit Mobilier member, was singled out and censured for his role in the corruption.

The Credit Mobilier scandal came to light in 1872, following an investigation by the New York Sun. A committee investigated, interviewing Congressman Oakes Ames. Ames admitted to selling shares to 14 senators and congressmen but claimed these transactions were not bribes but rather favors to friends of the railroad. Despite his defense of the transactions as honest investments, Ames received a censure from Congress and died shortly thereafter. The major players in Credit Mobilier, however, largely escaped consequences from the congressional investigation.

The Central Pacific's construction arm was similarly structured to enable insider dealing and the concentration of wealth among the company's executives.

The Big Four directors of the Central Pacific, including Collis Huntington, amassed va ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Corruption, financial troubles, and worker exploitation within the railroad companies

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The Credit Mobilier scandal was a corruption scandal involving the construction of the Union Pacific Railroad. Credit Mobilier was a construction company formed by Union Pacific insiders who overcharged for the construction of the railroad, leading to massive profits for themselves. This scandal involved bribery of government officials to secure favorable legislation and contracts for the Union Pacific Railroad. The scandal highlighted the corrupt practices within the railroad industry during the late 1800s.
  • The Big Four directors of the Central Pacific, including Leland Stanford, Collis Huntington, Mark Hopkins, and Charles Crocker, were influential figures in the construction of the transcontinental railroad. They were known for their business acumen, political connections, and aggressive pursuit of wealth through railroad development. The Big Four played a significant role in the expansion of the Central Pacific Railroad, particularly in California and the western United States. Their actions, including the exploitation of Chinese immigrant labor, contributed to their immense fortunes and the growth of the railroad industry in the late 19th century.
  • Chinese immigrant workers played ...

Counterarguments

  • The Credit Mobilier scandal, while indicative of corruption, could be seen as a product of its time, where regulations and oversight were not as stringent as they are today, and such practices might have been more commonplace and less scrutinized.
  • The failure of Credit Mobilier to pay its workers could be attributed to financial mismanagement or the chaotic economic conditions of the time rather than a deliberate intent to exploit labor.
  • Congressman Oakes Ames' involvement in the Credit Mobilier scandal could be reinterpreted as a misguided attempt to secure investments for the railroad, which was seen as a national project of great importance, rather than a clear-cut case of corruption.
  • The construction arm of the Central Pacific might have been structured in a way that was typical for the time, and the concentration of wealth among executives could be a reflection of the lack of antitrust laws rather than an inherent flaw in the individuals involved.
  • The exploitation of Chinese immigrant workers by the Central Pacific could be contextua ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Transcontinental Railroad | The Golden Spike | 4

The extreme challenges and hazards faced by railroad construction crews

Railroad construction in the 19th century was a perilous endeavor, with crews facing a myriad of life-threatening conditions as they laid tracks across the American frontier.

The Central Pacific's workers encountered brutal conditions as they pushed eastward through the Nevada desert

The Central Pacific Railroad's workers toiled in some of the most extreme environments, particularly as they moved through Nevada's formidable 40-mile desert. Mark Twain famously described this expanse as a bleak landscape dreaded by pioneers.

Crews grappled with scorching heat, a lack of water, and an unforgiving terrain that was entirely devoid of natural resources. They depended on water that had to be transported thousands of gallons daily for themselves and their livestock. The relentless heat and scarcity of water made every day a battle for survival.

The crews resorted to risky measures like using black powder to break up frozen ground, which compromised the stability of the tracks

During the piercing cold of a mid-January morning in 1869 at Humboldt Wells, Nevada, with temperatures plummeting to 18 degrees below zero, the problem of breaking through the hardened earth arose. The Central Pacific's leadership, under Strobridge, chose to tackle the frozen ground with black powder, an approach historically used in tunneling through the Sierra Nevada mountains. Despite concerns that this would compromise the track's stability come thaw, Strobridge decided the risk was worth taking, resolving to simply rebuild if necessary. The outcome was as feared; tracks became dangerously unstable with the spring thaw, leading to frequent derailments.

Severe winter weather in both Utah and Wyoming also frequently shut down operations and stranded passengers

To maintain continuous passenger service in heavy snowfall areas, the Central Pacific constructed wooden snow sheds to cover the tracks. Although these sheds served their purpose, they also introduced new hazards: they were fire traps due to sparks from the locomotives and posed dangers to crews working further east.

Accidents and safety issues were rampant, with a lack of modern safety features leading to many worker injuries and deaths

An absence of modern safety protocols made railway construction a ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The extreme challenges and hazards faced by railroad construction crews

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Wayside signals are visual indicators placed along the railroad tracks to communicate information to train operators. They provide crucial information such as speed limits, track conditions, and signals for upcoming hazards or instructions. Air brakes are a type of braking system used on trains that rely on compressed air to control the braking force applied to the wheels. This system allows for more efficient and synchronized braking across all cars in a train, enhancing safety and control during operations.
  • Railroad construction in the 19th century involved crews facing extreme conditions like scorching heat, lack of water, and unforgiving terrains. They used methods like transporting water daily and using black powder to break frozen ground, despite risks to track stability. Safety issues were prevalent due to the absence of modern safety features, leading to accidents and fatalities among workers. Conflicts between different crews, like the Irish and Chinese workers, also posed additional risks and challenges during construction.
  • The Central Pacific workers were primarily Chinese laborers hired to build the railroad tracks, facing harsh conditions in the Nevada desert. The Union Pacific workers, mainly Irish immigrants, were responsible for grading and preparing the land for track laying. Both groups faced challenges and tensions, leading to violent confrontations during the construction of the transcontinental railroad.
  • Railroad construction i ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Transcontinental Railroad | The Golden Spike | 4

The final negotiations and completion of the Transcontinental Railroad

The completion of the Transcontinental Railroad marked a significant moment in American history, culminating in a ceremony at Promontory Summit, Utah. Here's how the final days unfolded and the lasting impact this monumental feat had on the nation.

After years of bitter rivalry, the Union Pacific and Central Pacific executives finally agreed on Promontory Summit in Utah as the meeting point for their tracks.

By the end of February 1869, both the Union Pacific and the Central Pacific had set their sights on Promontory Summit as a potential meeting point for their rail lines. The Union Pacific was focused on building the Big Trestle, while the Central Pacific pressed on with the Big Fill, with both companies rivaling over the same ravine just 150 yards apart. Charles Crocker of the Central Pacific was determined to outpace the Union Pacific, which was then laying a mile of the track a day.

In a competitive spirit, the Central Pacific aimed to lay an extraordinary 10 miles of track in one day, requiring meticulous planning and coordination. Despite an initial setback due to a derailment after laying two miles on April 27th, the next day before dawn, they resumed their monumental effort. Over a thousand men worked in concert, laying over 10 miles of track in a 12-hour period, an achievement that involved an immense amount of material and labor and was never again replicated. After this record-setting day, only four miles remained for the Central Pacific to complete their stretch.

The Central Pacific set a new single-day track-laying record in a last-ditch effort to beat the Union Pacific to the finish line.

The Central Pacific's goal to establish a track-laying record was successful, effectively preventing the Union Pacific from having the opportunity to try to surpass it. With just four miles left between them and the finish line, the Central Pacific crews had effectively sealed their win in this part of the race against their rival.

On May 10, 1869, the two railroads were ceremonially joined with the driving of the golden spike, completing the Transcontinental Railroad.

The transcript does not explicitly mention the ceremonial driving of the golden spike, but it is known that on the morning of May 10, 1869, a significant ceremony was held at Promontory Summit. Leland Stanford, President of the Central Pacific, attempted to drive the ceremonial golden spike and, though he missed, a telegraph signal was sent across the country to celebrate the railroad's completion. With the Transcontinental Railroad finished, celebrations erupted, with San Francisco firing 200 cannon blasts and Chicago holding a massive parade.

The new railroad trans ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The final negotiations and completion of the Transcontinental Railroad

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • Explore historical landmarks to connect with the past by visiting local museums or historical sites related to the Transcontinental Railroad, which can deepen your understanding of how such projects shaped modern America.
  • Reflect on the impact of historical events on present communities by researching how the railroad affected Native American tribes and considering ways to support current indigenous initiatives or cultural preservation efforts.
  • Acknowledge the contributions of overlooked groups i ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA