Listen Now - Empire City: The Untold Origin Story of the NYPD
The NYPD's origins in the 1800s were marred by controversial practices such as kidnapping Black New Yorkers and selling them into slavery. This troubling history stands in stark contrast to the department's current heroic image and global brand recognition.
This episode explores the challenges researchers face in uncovering the NYPD's true past, including censorship and limited access to official sources. It examines the ways the NYPD has carefully curated its public image over the years—by whitewashing its unsavory records, cultivating iconic imagery and pop culture depictions, and relying on a symbiotic relationship with the media to reinforce its positive reputation worldwide.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Sep 10, 2024 episode of the American History Tellers
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
The NYPD's Controversial Origins
Transformation from Kidnapping to Brand Recognition
While currently a recognized global force, Lindsay Graham reveals the NYPD's origins in the 1800s included officers kidnapping Black New Yorkers and selling them into slavery. Graham notes the stark contrast between the NYPD's dark past and iconic, heroic present persona.
Corruption Allegations in the NYPD Museum
Historian Ed O'Donnell was censored from mentioning NYPD violence or corruption while writing for the NYPD's museum. The museum director actively revised Donnell's work, removing negative details and accepting improper gifts. This corruption scandal ultimately led to the museum's closure.
Researching the Origins: Challenges and Censorship
Roadblocks to Accessing Origins
Lindsay Graham faced obstacles when pursuing the NYPD's roots at the police museum. Ed O'Donnell recounts explicit directives to censor his writings on NYPD wrongdoing. His accounts were altered to downplay or erase details like indictments.
Relying on Newspapers Despite Biases
With limited access to official sources, researchers have relied on old newspapers, though these often shaped positive public opinion by overlooking the NYPD's contentious past.
Curating the NYPD's Heroic Image
Censoring Negative History
The police museum's censorship attests to broader NYPD efforts to whitewash unflattering records, Lindsay Graham notes. This protects the global brand from contrasting with unpleasant realities like kidnapping.
Imagery and Pop Culture Reinforcement
Graham observes the NYPD's meticulous use of iconic imagery and cultural depictions like "Law & Order" to cultivate and preserve its heroic reputation worldwide.
Historical Shaping by Media
In shaping public understanding, Graham says newspapers have defined the narrative around police work for years. The symbiotic relationship between media and NYPD portrayal continues reinforcing the department's positive image.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- The historical context of the 1800s may have involved practices that are abhorrent by today's standards, but it is important to assess historical events within the context of their time.
- The transformation of the NYPD into a globally recognized force could be seen as a positive evolution from its controversial origins, demonstrating institutional reform and progress.
- Censorship in the NYPD museum could be argued as an attempt to focus on the positive aspects and contributions of the NYPD to society, although this approach is debatable.
- The closure of the museum due to corruption allegations could be seen as a proactive measure to address and rectify wrongdoing within the institution.
- Challenges faced by researchers like Lindsay Graham could be indicative of broader issues of access to historical records, which is not unique to the NYPD.
- Reliance on old newspapers, despite their biases, may still provide valuable historical insights and serve as a starting point for further research.
- The use of iconic imagery and cultural depictions could be argued as a means for the NYPD to engage with the community and foster a sense of shared identity and pride.
- The media's role in shaping the narrative around police work could be seen as a reflection of society's values and interests at the time of reporting.
- The symbiotic relationship between the media and the NYPD could also be viewed as a way to highlight the positive impact of police work on public safety and order.
Actionables
- You can explore the multifaceted history of your local law enforcement by visiting your city archives and requesting access to historical records, such as police logs, reports, and correspondence. By examining these primary sources, you'll gain a more nuanced understanding of the institution's past, which may include both commendable and controversial actions. For example, if you live in a city like Boston or Chicago, you might find records that reveal how law enforcement interacted with different communities throughout the decades.
- Start a book club focused on non-fiction works that delve into the history of law enforcement and its impact on society. Choose books that offer a range of perspectives, including those from historians, sociologists, and former law enforcement officers. This will encourage informed discussions and a deeper comprehension of the complexities surrounding police history and public perception. For instance, you could read "The New Jim Crow" by Michelle Alexander to discuss the intersection of race and law enforcement in the United States.
- Engage with your community by organizing a "history versus perception" discussion group, inviting members to share and contrast their personal experiences with law enforcement against the historical context you've learned. This can be done in informal settings like coffee shops or via online platforms. The goal is to foster a dialogue that acknowledges the layered reality of law enforcement, recognizing both the positive contributions and the problematic aspects. For example, a participant might share a positive personal interaction with local police, which can then be discussed in the light of historical events that have shaped the police's role in society.
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
The NYPD's controversial origins and hidden history
"Empire City" reveals the tumultuous and dark origins of the New York City Police Department (NYPD), which starkly contrast with the department's current perception as an iconic and heroic police force.
The NYPD's transformation into a powerful police force with a global brand
In the 1800s, New York City was a place of deadly riots and violence. During this era, the police, who were supposed to protect the public, were instead involved in the kidnapping of Black New Yorkers. These civilians were forcibly taken off the streets and sold into slavery in the South. Despite this, the NYPD has grown into a powerful and recognized global entity. However, its early history, which includes instances of violence, bribery, and kidnapping, remains largely overshadowed by its public persona.
Allegations of corruption and censorship within the NYPD's own museum
Significant allegations of corruption and censorship have emerged relating to the NYPD's own museum. The museum, which was managed by active-duty NYPD officers, was caught editing historical narratives. The director of the museum, who was also an active ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The NYPD's controversial origins and hidden history
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- The historical context of the NYPD's actions in the 1800s should be considered, as law enforcement practices and societal norms were vastly different from today's standards.
- The transformation of the NYPD into a powerful global entity could be seen as a positive evolution from its troubled past, demonstrating an ability to reform and improve over time.
- The public persona of the NYPD as an iconic and heroic police force may be supported by numerous instances of service and sacrifice by its officers that have positively impacted the community.
- Allegations of corruption and censorship within the NYPD's museum, while serious, may not represent the values or actions of the department as a whole.
- The actions of the museum director, if true, could be viewed as the failings of an individual rather than indicative of sy ...
Actionables
- You can deepen your understanding of local history by researching the origins of your own city's law enforcement through historical societies or online archives. By doing so, you'll gain a more nuanced view of the institutions that shape your community, similar to how the book "Empire City" explores the NYPD's past. For example, you might find old newspaper articles or records that shed light on the actions and reputation of law enforcement throughout history.
- Start a book club focused on non-fiction works that uncover lesser-known historical narratives, including those about law enforcement and social justice. This encourages informed discussions and critical thinking about historical context and its impact on present-day institutions. Select books that challenge the official narratives and provide a platform for diverse perspectives, much like "Empire City" does for the NYPD.
- Engage in ethical consumerism by supporti ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Attempts to research and uncover the NYPD's early history
Scholarly pursuits to understand the New York Police Department's (NYPD) beginnings have met with various hindrances, suggesting an often sanitized vision of the force's origins.
Challenges in accessing and understanding the NYPD's origins
Lindsay Graham attempted to delve into the roots of the NYPD starting with the New York City Police Museum, which professed a mission to preserve the department's history. However, he quickly encountered roadblocks, indicating that the museum may not be a reliable source of information.
Historian Ed O'Donnell experienced firsthand the challenges of documenting the NYPD's history while working for the police museum. He was constrained by directives that censored references to negative aspects of the NYPD's past. For instance, he was explicitly instructed not to use the words "violence" or "corruption" in his writings.
Moreover, the museum director actively censored O'Donnell's historical account, going so far as to expunge entire pages and alter phrases to downplay or erase incidences of wrongdoing. An example of such censorship includes changing a sentence about an officer being indicted for corruption to merely stating the officer was let go.
Turning to alternative sources, like old ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Attempts to research and uncover the NYPD's early history
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- The museum's approach to presenting history could be intended to focus on educational and inspirational aspects of the NYPD's history, rather than its controversies.
- Directives to avoid terms like "violence" or "corruption" might be aimed at maintaining a positive public image, which could be seen as necessary for fostering community trust and support.
- The museum director's censorship could be viewed as an effort to protect the reputations of officers and the institution, which might be considered important for morale.
- Old newspapers, despite their limitations, could still provide valuable insights ...
Actionables
- You can explore the social history of your own city by visiting local landmarks and taking notes on any information that seems incomplete or biased. This can help you develop a more nuanced understanding of your city's past, similar to how researchers look beyond official accounts to piece together historical narratives. For example, if you visit a historical site and find that the information presented seems one-sided, take note of what's missing and research those aspects independently through local archives or interviews with long-time residents.
- Start a community discussion group focused on local history, where members can share findings from alternative sources like diaries, letters, and personal accounts. This can provide a fuller picture of historical events and figures, much like how researchers use old newspapers to understand the NYPD's past. You might find someone with family stories that offer a different perspective on your city's history, or you could discover personal documents that shed light on lesser-known events.
- Create a ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
The role of institutions and media in shaping the NYPD's public image
The New York Police Department (NYPD) has actively worked to cultivate a positive and heroic public image, utilizing a range of strategies from censoring unfavorable historical facts to leveraging pop culture. Media outlets have also played a significant role in reinforcing this positive narrative.
The NYPD's efforts to maintain a positive, heroic public image
The NYPD has long been focused on presenting itself as a force for good, often overshadowing the more controversial aspects of its history.
The police museum's attempts to censor and whitewash the NYPD's history
Evidence of the NYPD’s efforts to manage its public image can be found in the way the police museum has handled its historical portrayal. An example of this is O'Donnell's assignment to write about the NYPD without mentioning violence or corruption, which illustrates the institution’s attempt to whitewash the NYPD's past. Moreover, the public perception of the NYPD is shaped to contrast its global brand with the less savory episodes of its history, such as the kidnapping of Black New Yorkers.
The use of iconic imagery and branding to cultivate the NYPD's global reputation
The NYPD meticulously uses iconic imagery and branding to not only cultivate but also protect its global reputation. The selection of what is displayed or omitted in the museum attests to a deliberate effort to maintain this positive image.
The media's influence in propagating the NYPD's heroic narrative
Media outlets have been essential partners in cementing the NYPD’s favorable image in the eyes of the public.
Newspapers' historical role in shaping the public's understanding of the NYPD
Historically, newspapers have significa ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The role of institutions and media in shaping the NYPD's public image
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- The NYPD's efforts to cultivate a positive image may overlook or minimize legitimate concerns and criticisms regarding police conduct, accountability, and transparency.
- Presenting a one-sided narrative in the police museum could be seen as an attempt to control the narrative and avoid a full examination of the NYPD's complex history.
- The use of iconic imagery and branding might oversimplify the multifaceted nature of police work and the diverse experiences of the communities the NYPD serves.
- Media outlets may not always critically assess the information provided by the NYPD, potentially leading to a lack of journalistic scrutiny.
- Newspapers and other media forms have sometimes been complicit in disseminating biased or one-sided information that favors the NYPD, which can skew public perception.
- P ...
Actionables
- You can develop a critical eye for media by analyzing the portrayal of organizations in your favorite TV shows. Start by taking notes on how these organizations are depicted, looking for patterns in the narrative that may suggest a bias or a one-sided story. For example, if a show consistently portrays a certain profession as heroic, question what aspects of that profession are not being shown and why.
- Create a personal blog or social media page dedicated to discussing the nuances of public perception versus reality in various institutions. Use this platform to share your thoughts on recent portrayals of these institutions in the media, and encourage discussions that delve into the complexities that are often overlooked. For instance, after watching an episode of a crime drama, post a reflection on the real-life challenges and controversies that the show might have omitted.
- Engage in community discussio ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
