This episode of American History Tellers explores the life and influence of Martha Washington, the nation's first First Lady. It delves into her personal journey, from her upbringing on a Virginia plantation to her marriage to George Washington and their shared sacrifices during the Revolutionary War.
The blurb examines Martha's role in shaping the First Lady's position, establishing traditions like formal receptions and sparking criticism for emulating royal courts. It also sheds light on the controversies the Washingtons faced, such as accusations of elitism and anti-Republican sentiments, as well as their complex stance on slavery, exemplified by Martha's entanglement with the injustices of the institution.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Martha Dandridge was born in 1731 on a Virginia plantation, raised to become a dutiful wife and hostess. At 17, she married Daniel Parke Custis, one of Virginia's wealthiest men. After his death, Martha, only 26, became a skilled manager of the Custis estate and its enslaved laborers.
Martha met George Washington in 1759. Initially a pragmatic match, their marriage grew into genuine affection. For 14 years, the couple enjoyed domestic tranquility at Mount Vernon before the Revolutionary War forced sacrifices to support the cause.
As the nation's first First Lady in 1789, Martha had to navigate an undefined role without precedent. She established traditions like formal receptions and drawing rooms, sparking accusations of recreating a royal court. Yet Martha's patriotic efforts during the war boosted George's popularity.
Privately, Martha longed for Mount Vernon's tranquility, feeling confined by social obligations. This internal struggle highlighted the sacrifices involved in being First Lady.
The Washingtons faced criticism from Jeffersonian Republicans who saw Martha's formal receptions and George's levees as elitist and anti-Republican. They were accused of imitating European monarchies, countering democratic principles.
Martha avoided the partisan fray, focusing on hosting rather than debates. Her neutral stance and desire for private life were clear.
While George Washington grew conflicted about slavery, Martha showed no such misgivings. She spent years trying to recapture an escaped enslaved maid. After George's death, Martha feared freeing her first husband's "dower slaves" due to uprising concerns.
In 1801, Martha freed Washington's slaves per his will but not the Custis dower slaves, painfully separating enslaved families. This underscored the founding generation's complex moral entanglement with slavery's injustices.
1-Page Summary
Martha Washington's early life on a tobacco plantation and her subsequent marriages to Daniel Parke Custis and then George Washington shaped both her personal narrative and her role in American history. From a dutiful wife to the original First Lady, Martha Washington's life was one of both personal resolve and public sacrifice.
Martha Dandridge, born in June 1731, was raised on a small tobacco plantation east of Richmond, Virginia, into a family with deep Virginia roots—her father was an immigrant from England who became a successful planter. As the eldest of eight children, Martha received a solid education that prepared her for domestic life, including homemaking skills such as cooking and sewing, as well as reading, writing, and math. Strong-willed by nature, she was nonetheless raised to manage her own household and make a good marriage, which she did at the tender age of 17 when she married Daniel Parke Custis.
Martha's first husband, Custis, was twenty years her senior and one of the wealthiest men in Virginia. When he unexpectedly passed away due to a throat infection, Martha, only 26, became one of the wealthiest widows in the colony. She found herself in charge of 17,000 acres and nearly 300 enslaved laborers across five plantations. Demonstrating proficiency in business, Martha effectively maintained the vast properties and oversaw the well-being of hundreds of people. She could not, however, free the 153 dower slaves from the Custis estate due to legal constraints.
Martha met George Washington a year after becoming a widow. At the time, George was a young colonel renowned for his service in the French and Indian War. Even though he came from a more modest background than Martha, she regarded him as kind and honorable. Their marriage in January 1759, which first appeared to be a strategic union, developed into genuine affection and mutual respect. Martha and her children moved to Mount Vernon, George's plantation, signaling the start of nearly 14 years of marital harmony.
Martha Washington's personal life and marriage
As the nation's first First Lady, Martha Washington carved out the role of the presidential spouse, setting traditions that incorporated both the need for accessibility and the prestige of the new nation.
When George Washington assumed the presidency in 1789, Martha became the first to serve as First Lady of the United States. She was celebrated as "Lady Washington" as she traveled to New York to join George after his inauguration, with supporters cheering her arrival. In an effort to uphold democratic principles while asserting the new nation's status, George and Martha Washington strove to adhere to European precedents to some degree. Martha hosted Friday evening drawing rooms for both men and women, during which, she would sit on a raised sofa and greet guests with curtsies or bows. These events offered a contrast to the aloof monarchs of Europe, and opened the doors of the executive mansion to the American people.
Additionally, during Congressional sessions, Martha invited cabinet members and other officials to dinner parties, reinforcing the social framework of the presidency. However, the grandeur and formality of these occasions sparked controversy, with accusations of recreating a royal court in the democratic republic. Despite this criticism, the Washingtons were determined to remain accessible, with George hosting formal weekly Tuesday afternoon receptions, or "levies."
The limitations of Martha’s public role, however, made her feel more confined as she referred to herself as "more like a state prisoner than anything else" due to the extensive formalities.
Despite feeling trapped, Martha's efforts during the Revo ...
Martha's role as First Lady and the establishment of that position
George and Martha Washington's approach to social gatherings and their domestic traditions raised eyebrows and controversies, fueled by Jeffersonian Republican criticisms of elitism and anti-republican sentiments.
Critics were questioning the state drawing room event, pointing to the formality and structural resemblance to monarchical functions as unfit for a democracy. Republican press and some attendees of George and Martha Washington's social events openly attacked these for their aristocratic demeanor. The President's levees were symbols of inequality, creating a parallel between Washington's practices and those of a monarchy.
Dialogues from the time reveal a deep concern for the presidential gatherings' resemblance to monarchical practices. Comparisons were drawn between Martha Washington's receptions and the grandeur one would expect in the palace of Versailles, pointing to perceived imitations of European royal customs. The Washingtons' critics saw their receptions as symbolic of elitism, frivolity, and in direct contrast to Republican principles. They were likened to British royal court practices, creating a stark contrast with the egalitarian values birthed from the Revolution. Access restrictions to the Executive Mansion only amplified these perceptions, with a Pennsylvania senator decrying the Washingtons' social traditions as regressive and anti-Republican.
Martha Washington was scrutiniz ...
The political and social controversies surrounding the Washingtons
The historical record provides a complex picture of Martha Washington’s relationship with the institution of slavery and how it resulted in lasting trauma for the families involved.
While George Washington showed a gradual shift in his stance against slavery, Martha Washington appeared to have no such internal conflict. She never publicly questioned whether slavery was wrong and, in contrast, spent years attempting to recapture an enslaved maid who escaped. After George's passing, out of fear of slave uprisings, Martha remained reluctant to free the enslaved people from her first husband's estate tied to her through dower rights.
On January 1st, 1801, Martha Washington did free the 123 slaves her husband owned outright, pursuant to his will. This act, however, underscored a painful reality: the emancipation did not extend to the 'Custis dower slaves' who came from her first husband's estate. As these enslaved people had intermarried and had children with George Washington's slaves for decades, the emancipation resulted in wrenching divisions amongst family units. For instance, the head carpenter at Mount Vernon, Isaac, was freed, but his wife Kitty remained enslaved as a dower slave.
Martha Washington's position was legally complex; while she could not free the Custis dower slaves, she did own individuals such as a man named Eilish outright. Yet, she chose to bequeath him to her grandson rather than grant his freedom.
Martha's stance on slavery and its impact on enslaved families
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser