Podcasts > American History Tellers > History Daily: The Attempted Assassination of Pope John Paul II

History Daily: The Attempted Assassination of Pope John Paul II

By Wondery

This episode explores the attempted assassination of Pope John Paul II on May 13, 1981. It delves into the background of would-be assassin Mehmet Ali Ağca, a Turkish man with ties to a far-right group, as well as the potential external forces that may have supported his actions. The Pope's origins in occupied Poland and the significance of his 1979 visit, which challenged communist control, are also examined.

Particular emphasis is placed on the Pope's remarkable act of forgiveness—embracing Ağca in prison in 1983 and later advocating for his pardon. Their reconciliation and the lasting impact of the Pope's benevolent stance towards his attacker provide a powerful testament to his belief in redemption.

History Daily: The Attempted Assassination of Pope John Paul II

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the May 13, 2024 episode of the American History Tellers

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

History Daily: The Attempted Assassination of Pope John Paul II

1-Page Summary

The Assassination Attempt on Pope John Paul II

Mehmet Ali Ağca's Background and Motives

On May 13, 1981, Mehmet Ali Ağca, a young Turkish man with ties to the far-right Gray Wolves group, attempted to assassinate Pope John Paul II in St. Peter's Square. Ağca had previously murdered a newspaper editor in Istanbul and, after escaping prison, left a note threatening to kill the Pope, whom he labeled an "imperialist."

During the investigation, Ağca confessed but gave conflicting accounts that cast doubt on his true motives. Sanger-Katz notes Ağca claimed shooting the Pope would liberate people in El Salvador and Afghanistan, despite no direct connections.

Potential Connections and External Support

Intense speculation swirled about whether Ağca acted independently or had external support. Allegations implicated the Soviet KGB, intending to suppress uprisings in Poland, though no conclusive evidence emerged. Prosecutors questioned how the impoverished Ağca could have financed and executed such a complex attack alone.

Pope John Paul II's Background

Polish Origins and Experiences Under Occupation

Born in 1920 near Krakow, Poland as Karol Wojtyla, John Paul II witnessed Nazi and Soviet invasions of Poland as a youth. After a friend's accidental gunshot nearly killed him, Wojtyla found solace in the church under occupation, deciding to become a priest.

1979 Poland Visit Challenges Communist Control

In 1979, the Pope's visit to communist-controlled Poland included sermons challenging religious suppression. At Warsaw's Victory Square, he proclaimed banning religion was cruel, stirring Poles to chant "we want God." Soviet officials grew concerned as the Pope stoked resistance against their influence.

The Pope's Forgiveness and Reconciliation

1983 Prison Visit to Embrace Ağca

In 1983, the Pope visited Ağca in prison, embracing his would-be assassin in a powerful gesture of forgiveness. Though filmed, the Pope kept their 20-minute conversation private, later declaring he forgave Ağca as a brother.

Lasting Impact Leading to Ağca's Pardon

The Pope's benevolence toward Ağca continued, maintaining contact with him and his family. In 1998, at the Pope's behest, Ağca received a pardon and release, testament to the Pope's belief in redemption. Ağca later paid respects at the Pope's tomb, reflecting their reconciliation.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Mehmet Ali Ağca had ties to the far-right Gray Wolves group, a Turkish nationalist organization known for its militant and extremist ideologies. The Gray Wolves group has been involved in various violent activities and has a history of political violence in Turkey. Ağca's association with this group suggests a possible influence on his radical beliefs and actions. The Gray Wolves have been linked to assassinations, bombings, and other acts of terrorism in Turkey and abroad.
  • Mehmet Ali Ağca, the individual who attempted to assassinate Pope John Paul II, provided conflicting explanations for his actions. He mentioned motives related to global liberation causes in El Salvador and Afghanistan, despite lacking direct connections to these issues. These conflicting accounts raised doubts about the true motivations behind his assassination attempt.
  • Allegations of Soviet KGB involvement in supporting Ağca stem from suspicions that the KGB may have had a hand in the assassination attempt on Pope John Paul II to suppress uprisings in Poland. However, conclusive evidence linking the Soviet intelligence agency to Ağca's actions has not been found. The theory suggests a potential geopolitical motive behind the attack, given the Pope's influence in challenging communist control in Poland.
  • Pope John Paul II's 1979 visit to communist-controlled Poland was significant as he openly challenged the oppressive regime, advocating for religious freedom and human rights. His visit inspired hope and unity among the Polish people, leading to increased resistance against Soviet influence. The Pope's powerful speeches and interactions with the public during this visit played a crucial role in fostering a spirit of defiance and solidarity against the communist authorities. This visit is often seen as a pivotal moment in the eventual collapse of communism in Eastern Europe.
  • The Pope's forgiveness and reconciliation with Ağca were significant because they demonstrated the Pope's commitment to forgiveness and redemption, rooted in his Christian beliefs. This act of forgiveness led to a personal relationship between the Pope and Ağca, culminating in the Pope advocating for Ağca's pardon and eventual release from prison. The Pope's actions exemplified his belief in the transformative power of forgiveness and reconciliation, showcasing his dedication to extending mercy even to those who had committed grave offenses.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
History Daily: The Attempted Assassination of Pope John Paul II

The assassination attempt on Pope John Paul II on May 13, 1981

The assailant Mehmet Ali Ağca's background and motivations

On May 13, 1981, Mehmet Ali Ağca, a young man from Turkey, attempted to assassinate Pope John Paul II in St. Peter's Square, Vatican City. He fired four shots with a 9mm Browning semi-automatic pistol, striking the Pope twice and injuring two others in the crowd. Pope John John Paul II was seriously wounded, but ultimately survived the encounter.

Ağca's history of violence and extremist views, including a previous murder conviction and assassination threats against the Pope

Mehmet Ali Ağca had ties to the extremist right-wing Turkish group known as the Gray Wolves. Two years before the attack on the Pope, he murdered the editor of a prominent left-wing newspaper in Istanbul. After being imprisoned for his crime, Ağca managed to escape, leaving behind a threatening note labeling the Pope a "crusader" and an "imperialist," and vowing to kill him.

Ağca's conflicting accounts and confessions during the investigation, casting doubt on his true motives

Following his arrest in Rome, Ağca confessed to the attempted assassination but later gave conflicting accounts of his activities, damaging the credibility of his claims. For instance, he once claimed he had traveled to England with plans to assassinate the king, only to find there was a queen. In a bizarre note left in his hotel room, he professed that shooting the Pope would liberate the people of El Salvador and Afghanistan, despite the lack of direct connections to the Catholic Church in the situations within these countries.

The investigation into Ağca's potential connections and outside support

Intense speculation swirled about whether Ağca acted independently or was an agent of a larger organization.

Allegations of involvement by the Soviet KGB or other foreign entities, with no conclusive evidence

Emerging theories suggested that the Soviet KGB might have been involved, intending to avert potential uprisings in Poland. Though these allegations captured media attention, concrete evidence was never provided. Co ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The assassination attempt on Pope John Paul II on May 13, 1981

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The Gray Wolves is a Turkish nationalist and neo-fascist organization. They have been involved in various violent activities and have been linked to political assassinations and terrorism. Mehmet Ali Ağca, the assailant who attempted to assassinate Pope John Paul II, had ties to this extremist group.
  • The Soviet KGB, or Committee for State Security, was the main security agency for the Soviet Union from 1954 to 1991. It was responsible for internal security, foreign intelligence, counter-intelligence, and secret police functions. The KGB was a powerful and secretive organization that played a significant role in Soviet politics and espionage activities during the Cold War. After the dissolution of the Soviet Union in 1991, the KGB was officially disbanded, with its functions divided among successor agencies like the Russian Foreign Intelligence Service (SVR) and the Federal Security Service (FSB).
  • The potential uprisings in Poland referred to the fear among Soviet authorities that Pope John Paul II's influence could embolden anti-communist movements in Poland, particularly the Solidarity movement. The Soviet Union was concerned about the Pope's support for the Polish people's desire for freedom and democracy, which could destabilize the communist regime in Poland and potentially spread to other Eastern Bloc countries. The assassination attempt on the Pope was seen by some as a way to silence his voice and prevent further challenges to Soviet control in the region.
  • El Salvador was embroiled in a civil war during the 1980s, with government forces fighting leftist guerrillas. Afghanistan was also in turmoil, facing a Soviet invasion in 1979 that led to a prolonged conflict with mujahideen fighters. These conflicts were complex and had international implications, with various groups involved in the fighting. Mehmet Ali Ağca's mention of these countries in his notes was puzzling and lacked a clear connection to his attempted assassination of the Pope.
  • Mehmet Ali Ağca's acquisition of a forged passport implies that he obtained a travel document illegally, typically through unauthorized means such as counterfeiting or falsification. This action allowed him to move across borders without official scrutiny, aiding in his ability to carry out the assassination attempt on Pope John Paul II. Acquiring a forged passport is a serious offense and is often associated with criminal activities that require individuals to conceal their true identities or intentions. The possession of a forged passport can facilitate illegal activities like human trafficking, smuggling, or acts of terrorism.
  • Mehmet Ali Ağca's travels across Europe were a subject of scrutiny due to questions about how he financed his movements, obtained false documents like a forged passport, and acquired a firearm without raising suspicions. These aspects raised doubts about his ability to carry out the assassination attempt alone, leading to speculation about potential external assistance in facilitating his movements and actions. The investigation into his travels aimed to uncover any possible connections or support networks that could have aided him in planning and executing the attack on Pope John Paul II. The ...

Counterarguments

...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
History Daily: The Attempted Assassination of Pope John Paul II

The biographical and political background of Pope John Paul II

The Pope's Polish origins and his personal experiences under Nazi and Soviet occupation

Karol Wojtyla, who would become Pope John Paul II, was born in 1920 near Krakow, Poland. He grew up in a middle-class family, the son of a military officer and a seamstress. During his formative years, Karol had a brush with death when a friend accidentally fired a loaded gun at him, narrowly missing him. World War II cast a significant shadow over his youth, as Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union invaded Poland. It was during these challenging times, while Karol was working in a quarry in German-occupied Poland, that he decided to become a priest, finding solace and support in the church amidst the turmoil.

The Pope's challenge to Poland's communist government during his 1979 visit

Pope John Paul II made a historic nine-day tour of Poland in 1979, which included over 40 sermons, lectures, and addresses that noticeably discomforted communist officials. In his speech at Warsaw’s Victory Square, he challenged Poland's communist government by proclaiming that banning religion was an act of cruelty, a bold statement in a suppressed society.

The government only granted permission for his visit because they feared that denying the Pope could result in a national uprising. However, his sermons had a profound impact on the Polish people, stirring them to publicly chant "we want God," expressing their yearning for religious and political liberty. The Pope's defiance became apparent when he stated that those who fought against Nazi domination would not be g ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The biographical and political background of Pope John Paul II

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Karol Wojtyla's decision to become a priest while working in a quarry in German-occupied Poland was influenced by the challenging times of World War II. The turmoil and hardships he faced during this period led him to seek solace and support in the church. Wojtyla found a sense of purpose and spiritual fulfillment in the midst of the occupation, ultimately shaping his decision to pursue a religious vocation.
  • During Pope John Paul II's visit to Poland in 1979, the use of crucifixes and rosaries as emblems of defiance symbolized the people's resistance against the communist regime. These religious symbols represented a form of peaceful protest and a visible expression of the population's desire for religious and political freedom. By openly displaying crucifixes and rosaries, the Polish people conveyed their unity and determination to uphold their faith and resist the oppressive government policies. The act of carrying these symbols in public spaces served as a powerful statement of solidarity and defiance against the authorities.
  • The unease of the Polish government and Soviet officials during the Pope's addresses stemmed from his criticism of the suppression of religion and his calls for political and religious freedom, which directly challenged the ideologies and control of the communist regimes in power. The Pope's ability to mobilize public sentiment against communist rule posed a threat to their authority, leading to concerns about potential uprisings and destabilization of their grip on power. The Polish government feared his influence on the population, especially after witnessing the public's strong response to his messages of defiance and calls for change. Soviet officials, already wary of dissent in the region, saw the Pope as a catalyst for anti-communist ...

Counterarguments

...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
History Daily: The Attempted Assassination of Pope John Paul II

The Pope's forgiveness and reconciliation with Aja after the event

Pope John Paul II’s visit to Mehmet Ali Ağca in prison became a profound example of forgiveness and the possibility of reconciliation, even in circumstances overshadowed by violence and betrayal.

The Pope's 1983 visit to Aja in prison, where he forgave and embraced his would-be assassin

On December 27th, 1983, Pope John Paul II made a significant gesture of compassion by visiting Mehmet Ali Ağca, who had attempted to take the Pope's life. In a stark prison setting, the Pope found Ağca alone in his cell dressed in casual attire, including a blue sweater and white running shoes without laces.

The Pope, after confirming that Ağca spoke Italian, began a private conversation that lasted about 20 minutes. Although the visit was filmed, the details of their conversation were kept confidential, as the footage did not capture audio. The Pope's visit was intended as a powerful public display of reconciliation, echoing his frequent messages on the topic.

The Pope's message of tolerance and mercy, keeping the details of their conversation private

Following their discussion, Pope John Paul II openly declared his forgiveness for Ağca and expressed a deep trust in him as if he were a brother. Remaining true to his commitment to privacy, the Pope chose not to disclose the specifics of their interaction, solidifying the personal nature of their exchange.

The lasting impact of the Pope's actions, leading to Aja's eventual pardon and release from prison

The Pope's gesture had a lasting impact, not only publicly but also on a personal level between the two men. Pope John Paul II maintained contact with Ağca after the visit and extended his benevolence to Ağca's family.

The ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The Pope's forgiveness and reconciliation with Aja after the event

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Mehmet Ali Ağca is a Turkish national who attempted to assassinate Pope John Paul II in 1981 in St. Peter's Square, Vatican City. Ağca's motives for the assassination attempt were initially unclear but were later linked to his extreme right-wing political beliefs. Ağca had a history of involvement with far-right militant groups in Turkey before the assassination attempt.
  • The Pope chose to keep the details of his conversation with Ağca private to maintain the personal and intimate nature of their exchange. By not disclosing the specifics, the Pope emphasized the sincerity and depth of his forgiveness towards Ağca. This decision also highlighted the transformative power of reconciliation through actions rather than words. The private nature of their conversation allowed the focus to remain on the message of forgiveness and redemption without distractions or sensationalism.
  • Ağca's eventual pardon and release from prison were facilitated by the Pope's influence and advocacy for forgiveness and reconciliation. The Pop ...

Counterarguments

...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA