In this American History Tellers episode, the United States' rapid transformation from military unpreparedness at the outset of World War I to becoming a global military power by the war's end is explored. The early debate around potential US involvement, overshadowed by Wilson's preference for neutrality, eventually gave way to the establishment of a draft and an expedited training process that churned out over a million new soldiers at 32 camps across the country.
The episode sheds light on the African American troop experience, recounting both the discrimination they faced and the perspective-altering interactions that fueled their civil rights movement upon returning home. It also spotlights key WWI battles like Meuse-Argonne, the valor of soldiers like the Lost Battalion, and the war's abrupt conclusion—serving as a prelude to America's continued rise on the global stage.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
The U.S. military in 1914 was modest with around 125,000 troops, focused primarily on naval power. It valued a rapidly mobilizable force over a large standing army, reflecting the Minutemen tradition.
As President Woodrow Wilson navigated pressures from interventionists like Theodore Roosevelt calling for US entry, and isolationists opposing involvement, he personally hoped for a negotiated peace to avoid military engagement, Author Bator reports.
However, Wilson signed the National Defense Act of 1916, expanding the military and giving the federal government power to mobilize the economy, anticipating potential US involvement.
With the Selective Service Act of 1917 establishing a draft, the US underwent a profound shift in military mobilization, training over 1 million recruits in 32 camps across the country through an expedited process, often with inadequate equipment until deploying to Europe.
To foster community involvement, registration occurred locally, and recruits traveled by train to training camps, transitioning rapidly from civilians to soldiers.
African American soldiers encountered segregation and discrimination within the US military, often relegated to labor roles. However, serving in Europe exposed them to more equitable treatment, as evident with the exploits of the Harlem Hellfighters, transforming their perspectives on civil rights upon return despite facing continued racism and violence.
At the Meuse-Argonne offensive in 1918, over 1 million American troops played a crucial role breaking through German defenses, overcoming immense challenges like the story of the "Lost Battalion" trapped under friendly fire, with carrier pigeons like Cher Ami proving vital for communication.
Fighting abruptly ended on November 11, 1918, with American troops rapidly demobilized. While the massive American Expeditionary Force returned home, US military cemeteries in Europe stand as solemn reminders of their sacrifices, Author Baro notes.
The war necessitated rapid expansion and modernization of the US military, laying foundations for America's emergence as a global superpower in the 20th century, the author concludes.
1-Page Summary
In 1914, the U.S. military maintained a modest force of approximately 125,000 troops. Despite its small size, it possessed the capacity to effectively pursue and safeguard American national interests.
The emphasis of the U.S. military during this period was on naval power, as it prepared mainly for potential confrontations at sea rather than extensive land battles. This decision reflected strategic priorities and a historical reluctance to maintain a large standing arm ...
The US military before WWI
As President Woodrow Wilson navigated through a turbulent period, the decision on whether or not to enter World War I was met with divergent pressures from within the United States.
Theodore Roosevelt, a Republican and vociferous former president, emerged as a significant interventionist voice, strongly advocating for the U.S. to join Britain and France in the war effort. At the same time, President Wilson was also grappling with internal pressures steering him away from the conflict. Populists in the South and West vehemently opposed large military involvements, fearing the implications of war. Additionally, substantial opposition came from German Americans who were concerned about the U.S. entering a war against Germany, their ancestral homeland.
Despite the external pressures to enter the war, Wilson admired Britain's political system and ethos during that time, which aligned him more with the British and French interests. However, a careful examination of Wilson's limited personal documents indicates his leanings towards peace and his hope for a diplomatic solution to emerge, circumventing the need for U.S. military involvement.
Domestic politics around US entry into WWI
During World War I, the United States underwent a profound transformation in its military mobilization and training methods, enabled by the 1917 Selective Service Act—a major shift in American tradition towards a rapid and community-involved expansion of its armed forces.
The Selective Service Act of 1917 was transformative for American military history, marking a radical departure from earlier traditions without a regularized draft process. Men between 21 to 30 years of age, and later expanded to those between 18 to 45, were required to register for potential service—not immediate induction—in the armed forces. The act modeled its structure after European conscription laws, like Britain's, carefully balancing the need for soldiers with the need to maintain the labor force essential for industry and production at home.
It was during this time the U.S. government built 32 training camps across the country, strategically located in both the north and the south to unify the nation post-Civil War and to expand the military's reach. Recruits were rushed through these facilities, which were like small cities complete with hospitals, schools, and theaters. Despite being rapidly processed—usually within two to three months and outfitted for deployment to Europe—many recruits found themselves training with inadequate or obsolete equipment like wooden rifles. They did not handle modern rifles until they arrived in France.
To humanize and localize the registration process and encourage community engagement, the draft was administered at local, community-centric places like post offices and church basements. This approach meant that selection and training of soldiers for the Great War became a community-involved effort, contrasting starkly with previous top-down militarization.
New recruits were inducted through a system called entrainment, which involved traveling by train to the military camps for their abbreviated and often chaotic preparation for war. Their rapid transition from civilians to soldiers, usually in a disorienting and hectic environment, was aimed at meeting the urgent need for military personnel overseas.
Military mobilization and training
The experience of African American soldiers in the US military during times of war was a journey of profound contrasts, marked by segregation and discrimination at home but a taste of more equitable treatment abroad. Their service was transformative, reshaping their perspective on civil rights upon their return to the United States.
African American soldiers entered the military knowing that their service was a chance to demonstrate their worth to America. Despite this, white American elites were reluctant to arm and train them, often relegating them to labor battalions or service roles. The heavy work of unloading materials in Europe was mostly undertaken by African American soldiers assigned to these labor battalions.
They faced the challenge of a segregated army and a president who maintained segregationist policies. Yet, serving in Europe was a transformative experience. Away from the rigid structures of segregation that were rampant in early 20th century America, African American soldiers encountered a different kind of racism, one that did not enforce the explicit barriers they were accustomed to.
African American troops, particularly those who served under French command, experienced fewer restrictions and more opportunities for combat. The Harlem Hellfighters and other black combat units often endured some of the war's toughest conditions and prolonged engagements on the front lines.
The experience of African American troops
...
The Meuse-Argonne offensive in 1918 stands as a crucial chapter in the annals of World War I, showcasing the mettle and determination of American troops as they confronted the horrors of trench warfare.
The Meuse-Argonne region, by the war's end, had become a landscape of devastation. It was here that the American Expeditionary Forces, about 1 million strong, launched their largest and one of the most successful offenses against the German fortifications. This pivotal moment was instrumental in turning the tide of the war in favor of the Allies.
In October 1918, a significant contingent of the U.S. forces, led by Major Charles Whittlesey, engaged in what would become a grim tale of resilience. Nine companies of the U.S. 77th Division executed a synchronized attack on the German line but found themselves cut off and isolated in the Argonne Forest. Stranded on the north slope of a ravine, the roughly 550 men of the "Lost Battalion" endured the lethal error of friendly fire. Despite their dire situation and facing relentless assaults from German forces, Major Whittlesey and his men held fast, refused to capitulate, and miraculously held out until rescue.
Communication lines severed, and couriers unable to breach the surrounding h ...
Key battles and incidents on the front lines
The First World War's conclusion brought not only an abrupt end to the fighting but also lasting influences on international relations and military practices.
On the final day of conflict, troops were still preparing to be deployed. However, at 11 a.m. on November 11, 1918, when the armistice came into effect, this operation ground to a halt. Trains loaded with soldiers ready for battle stopped and turned around, tasked instead with returning these men to their homes, signalling a sudden and dramatic end to their wartime duties and beginning the process of transition to peacetime.
While the troops were sent back home, the legacy of their sacrifice remains unmistakably etched across Europe's landscape in the form of military cemeteries. These sacred grounds continue to remind visitors of the immense cost of the conflict and the lives of those American soldiers who gave everything in distant lands.
The end of the war and the legacy of WWI
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser