Podcasts > All About Change > Lani Anpo: The Erasure of Native American & Jewish Identity, and the Indijewnous Response

Lani Anpo: The Erasure of Native American & Jewish Identity, and the Indijewnous Response

By Jay Ruderman

In this episode of All About Change, Lani Anpo examines the intersection of Native American and Jewish identities, sharing her perspective as someone who fully embraces both heritages. She discusses the complex dynamics within Indigenous advocacy spaces, where some groups support certain Indigenous rights while denying others, particularly regarding Jewish indigeneity to ancestral lands.

The discussion explores how Indigenous peoples and Jews face various forms of erasure, from physical violence to cultural destruction and political marginalization. Anpo addresses the challenges of building meaningful allyship between marginalized groups, the importance of preserving Indigenous cultures, and the role of Indigenous passports as tools for sovereignty and self-determination. Throughout the conversation, she highlights how certain arguments used to delegitimize Jewish indigeneity could potentially impact other Indigenous peoples' rights.

Lani Anpo: The Erasure of Native American & Jewish Identity, and the Indijewnous Response

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Jul 21, 2025 episode of the All About Change

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Lani Anpo: The Erasure of Native American & Jewish Identity, and the Indijewnous Response

1-Page Summary

Indigenous Identity and Belonging

Lani Anpo, who identifies as both fully Indigenous and Jewish, challenges conventional notions of mixed-heritage identity. Rather than viewing her background as divided or partial, she embraces the completeness of both her Native American and Jewish lineages.

Anpo points out a significant contradiction within Indigenous advocacy spaces: while they support some Indigenous groups, they often deny the indigeneity of others, particularly Jews, using Eurocentric standards. She highlights how advocating for native land returns in the U.S. while condemning Jews as colonizers in their ancestral homeland represents a troubling double standard. This stance has led to personal backlash against Anpo, including hate messages and death threats from within native communities.

Experiences of Discrimination and Erasure

Indigenous peoples face multiple forms of erasure, as Anpo explains, including physical violence, cultural destruction, and political marginalization. She draws compelling parallels between the experiences of Indigenous peoples and Jews, particularly regarding their connections to ancestral lands. The rhetoric used to delegitimize Jewish indigeneity based on factors like skin color, DNA, and diaspora time could potentially threaten other Indigenous peoples' rights and status.

Allyship and Solidarity Between Marginalized Groups

Anpo emphasizes that meaningful allyship requires deep self-reflection and confrontation of internal biases. She notes how some Jewish individuals claim to support Indigenous rights only when convenient, while some Indigenous advocacy spaces deny Jewish indigeneity despite shared experiences of colonization. These dynamics, Anpo argues, threaten the potential for global Indigenous solidarity.

Preserving and Reviving Indigenous Cultures and Rights

Indigenous communities continue fighting to protect their lands, languages, and self-governance. Anpo advocates for Indigenous passports as symbols of sovereignty and self-determination, viewing them as crucial tools in resisting cultural erasure. She emphasizes the importance of ensuring future generations inherit more than just trauma, but also strong connections to their Indigenous identities and lands.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • You can expand your understanding of Indigenous and Jewish histories by reading books written by authors from these communities. Delving into literature such as "There There" by Tommy Orange or "Night" by Elie Wiesel can provide personal insights into the complexities of identity and the importance of land and heritage.
  • Start a virtual book club focused on Indigenous and Jewish narratives to foster dialogue and allyship. By selecting a diverse range of texts and inviting members from various backgrounds, you encourage open conversations about shared histories, cultural erasure, and the significance of self-determination.
  • Create a personal "allyship action plan" that includes educating yourself on Indigenous issues, reflecting on internal biases, and determining concrete steps to support Indigenous rights. This might involve regular self-reflection exercises, setting goals to attend educational events, or committing to amplify Indigenous voices on social media platforms.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Lani Anpo: The Erasure of Native American & Jewish Identity, and the Indijewnous Response

Indigenous Identity and Belonging

The discussions around indigeneity and ethnic identity continue to evolve as people like Lani Anpo courageously navigate the complexity of possessing mixed-heritage backgrounds.

Reclaiming Power: Embrace Mixed-Heritage Indigenous Identity

Lani Is Fully Indigenous and Jewish, Rejecting Partial Identities

Lani Anpo is an embodiment of embracement and resistance, identifying as fully Indigenous and Jewish and rejecting the idea of a partial identity. She grows up with a strong connection to her mother's Native American heritage while possessing knowledge of her Jewish lineage on her father's side, though without significant engagement with Jewish culture initially. Lani challenges the notion that mixed heritage should be seen as partitioned or incomplete; instead, she asserts the wholeness and totality of her identity, representing two distinct ethnic lineages.

Spaces for Some Indigenous Groups Often Deny the Indigeneity of Others, Like Jews, Using Eurocentric Narratives

Lani Anpo faces the complexities head-on as she reclaims truth and confronts hypocrisy within Indigenous and ethnic identity advocacy spaces. She points out an inconsistency within these spaces where support for some Indigenous groups is given precedence, while the Indigenous status of others, particularly Jews, is often denied based on Eurocentric standards. As an advocate, Lani argues against the hypocrisy of advocating for native lands being returned in the U.S. while also condemning Jews as colonizers in th ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Indigenous Identity and Belonging

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • You can expand your understanding of identity by reading books or articles written by authors from mixed heritage backgrounds. This will give you a broader perspective on the complexities of identity and the experiences of those who, like Lani, embrace their full heritage. For example, seek out memoirs or essays that explore the intersectionality of cultural identities, which can provide a nuanced view of the challenges and triumphs of living with a mixed heritage.
  • Start a personal journal to reflect on your own biases and preconceptions about identity. Use this as a tool to challenge yourself on how you perceive others and their claims to identity. For instance, when you encounter someone with a mixed heritage, write down your initial thoughts and then critically analyze why you might have those impressions and how they align with or differ from the inclusive perspective discussed by Lani.
  • Engage in conversations with friends or ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Lani Anpo: The Erasure of Native American & Jewish Identity, and the Indijewnous Response

Experiences of Discrimination and Erasure

Lani Anpo illuminates the multifaceted aspects of the erasure suffered by Indigenous peoples, and she also reveals how similar tactics of delegitimization are used against Jews, reflecting a broader pattern of discrimination.

Colonial tools have historically aimed to erase Indigenous identities through various forms, with race and blood quantum policies being central strategies for the genetic elimination of Indigenous societies. Lani Anpo addresses this racial erasure and the connected discrimination due to her mixed heritage as vivid examples.

Erasure Tactics: Violence, Removal, Destruction of Languages, Spirituality, Narratives

Indigenous erasure encompasses a range of tactics including physical violence, forced removal, and genocide, as well as sexual violence. Cultural erasure manifests in the destruction of languages, spiritual practices, and policies that criminalize Indigenous cultures. Legally and politically, sovereignty is denied, while historical erasure takes the form of rewriting or omitting Indigenous peoples from narratives.

Ruderman's discussion on the forcible removal of children from the Bad River Band of the Chippewa people, to Americanize them in schools, underscores the severity of these practices, alongside the trauma associated with being displaced from ancestral lands.

Indigenous Disconnection From Lands Delegitimizes Indigeneity, Mirroring Tactics Against Jews

Lani Anpo draws parallels between Indigenous people and Jews, particularly concerning the rhetoric surrounding ancestral homeland connections and identity.

Diaspora Time Threatens Indigenous Status and Rights

In her discourse, Anpo expresses profound concern over Indigenous peoples who echo agendas that are against Jews in Israel, in doing so, they inadvertently support strategies that could ultimately threaten Indigenous status and rights internationally. She also indicates the potential for employing arguments that delegiti ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Experiences of Discrimination and Erasure

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • You can educate yourself on Indigenous and Jewish histories by reading books or articles written by authors from these communities to gain a deeper understanding of their experiences. By choosing literature that focuses on personal narratives and historical accounts, you'll develop a more nuanced perspective on the issues of erasure and identity.
  • Start a monthly donation to a nonprofit that works directly with Indigenous communities to support their efforts in preserving their languages, cultures, and lands. Research organizations that have a clear mission to combat the effects of historical erasure and that are led by Indigenous individuals, ensuring your contribution has a direct impact.
  • Engage in conversations with friends an ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Lani Anpo: The Erasure of Native American & Jewish Identity, and the Indijewnous Response

Allyship and Solidarity Between Marginalized Groups

True Allyship Demands Introspection and Bias Awareness Before Action

Anpo emphasizes that true allyship requires a deeper self-reflection and confrontation of one’s own internal biases. When she reconnected with her Jewishness, she had to address her own prejudices and emphasizes the significance of listening and learning as the cornerstone of authentic allyship rather than immediately jumping to action.

Harmful Allyship: Failing to Listen and Learn Perpetuates Harm

The notion of harmful allyship comes to the fore when Jewish individuals claim to support Indigenous rights but only to an extent that doesn’t inconvenience them, exposing underlying anti-Indigenous biases that they might not be fully cognizant of. This form of allyship doesn't challenge the entrenched anti-Native prejudices present in society and can, in fact, perpetuate harm.

Breakdown of Indigenous, Jewish, and Other Marginalized Groups' Allyship Must Be Addressed

Anpo highlights the issue within advocacy spaces that claim to uphold Indigenous rights yet deny the indigeneity of Jews, negating the parallels in their experiences of colonization and oppression. This denial is not only antithetical to the foundations of Indigenous rights advocacy but also undermines the potential for global solidarity.

Advocacy Spaces Threaten Global Indigenous Solidarity By Turning Against Jews Despite Shared Colonization Experiences

Anpo points out the danger of anti-Jewish sentiment within some advocacy groups and the detrimental impact it has on solidarity between Indigenous populations, including Jews. She urges that Indigenous communities be cautious in sup ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Allyship and Solidarity Between Marginalized Groups

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • You can deepen your understanding of bias by keeping a journal where you note down moments you felt defensive or uncomfortable when discussing allyship. Reflect on why you felt that way and consider if it's linked to an unrecognized bias. For example, if you find yourself resisting the idea that Jews are Indigenous, explore the roots of that resistance in your journal.
  • Start a book club focused on Indigenous and Jewish authors to gain a broader perspective on their histories and struggles. This can be as simple as inviting friends or colleagues to read and discuss one book every two months, ensuring the chosen literature covers a range of experiences and viewpoints within these communities.
  • Engage in active listening by seeking out conversatio ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Lani Anpo: The Erasure of Native American & Jewish Identity, and the Indijewnous Response

Preserving and Reviving Indigenous Cultures and Rights

Indigenous peoples continue to combat challenges related to their existence, identity, and the bond with their ancestral lands and cultures, with the intention to protect and revive their heritage for future generations.

Indigenous Peoples Fight to Protect Lands, Languages, Spirituality, and Self-Governance

Indigenous communities strive to ensure that their descendants inherit more than the legacy of past trauma. Anpo emphasizes the battle to safeguard land, languages, and stories as a testament to the enduring connection Indigenous peoples have with their heritage. The idea is to demonstrate to descendants that their ancestors never capitulated and were persistently linked to their Indigenous identity.

Goal: Ensure Descendants Inherit More Than Trauma; Embrace Indigenous Identities and Land Connections

Anpo voices the hope that future generations will inherit a legacy that includes a robust connection to their Indigenous identities and lands. This goal underlies the efforts of Indigenous communities to remain actively engaged in the preservation and recognition of their traditional knowledge, spiritual practices, and the right to govern themselves.

Indigenous Passengers: Key to Sovereignty and Self-Determination Recognition

The concept of Indigenous passports emerges as a symbol of sovereignty and self-determination. Anpo expresses a desire for Indigenous passports that would represent the unique status of Indigenous nations. Such passports would mark a significant reclaiming of Indigenous cultures, stories, and languages aimed at ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Preserving and Reviving Indigenous Cultures and Rights

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • You can support Indigenous artisans by purchasing their crafts and artwork directly. By doing so, you contribute to the economic sustainability of their communities and help maintain the vitality of their cultural expressions. For example, look for online marketplaces that certify the authenticity of Indigenous-made products or visit local Indigenous-run stores.
  • Engage with Indigenous-authored literature to deepen your understanding of their perspectives and histories. Reading books, poems, and essays by Indigenous writers allows you to appreciate their narratives on a personal level. Start with a visit to your local library or bookstore and ask for recommendations on Indigenous authors.
  • Incorporate the acknowle ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA