The 99% Invisible episode explores the relentless ambition and unapologetic tactics of Robert Moses in expanding public infrastructure and green spaces in New York. It details how Moses wielded his growing power, appropriating land from farmers and landowners, often resorting to coercion, illegal methods, and ethical breaches to achieve his vision.
While his projects were hugely popular with the public and provided recreational spaces, this episode also examines the criticism Moses faced for his authoritarianism and lack of compromise, as well as the questionable legal practices he deployed to overcome obstacles. His controversial tenure as Secretary of State and his struggles with reforming the corrupt boxing industry provide insight into the depths he would go to control government operations for his grand plans.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Robert Moses expands park spaces in Long Island aggressively, managing to grow state parks to 9,700 acres across 14 parks. He employs strategies such as using connections to obtain lands in unethical manners, coercing local governments through threats, and appropriating land illegally. His tactics illustrate a relentless pursuit to complete his public infrastructure projects.
Moses encounters resistance from Long Island farmers and landowners regarding the routes of his parkways. He typically refuses concessions to landholders but makes exceptions for affluent individuals like Otto Kahn. Small farmers, unable to fight back against his influence, often suffer devastating losses, such as James Roth, whose farm is irreparably divided by parkway construction.
Moses’ approach becomes increasingly dismissive and authoritarian as his power escalates. He belittles advisory boards, ignores dissent, and orchestrates the systematic erasure of Ansley Wilcox from Niagara park history. Moses' arrogance is illustrated by his reluctance to acknowledge any ethical deviations, including issues relating to the AutoCon incident.
Al Smith safeguards Moses against criticism and provides political and financial support for his projects. Smith diffuses Republican opposition to Moses and delays legislative action strategically to increase public support for parks. These tactics, along with rallying public support, emphasizing the class struggle aspect, and personally intervening to resolve Moses' financial issues, culminate in Smith's crucial role in empowering Moses.
Moses becomes Secretary of State for New York, gaining control over licensing and state construction. He encounters challenges in regulating the corrupt boxing industry and after attempting reforms, ultimately withdraws from the field. His tenure as Secretary demonstrates his command over jobs and patronage but also exposes the complexity of corralling all facets of government operations.
Moses finds combating corruption in boxing formidable and after initial reform attempts, he backs down. His reluctance to press on reveals the limitations of his political determination when faced with a resistant industry.
Moses maintains a grueling work environment, with extensive hours, exemplified by the hardships endured during projects such as Jones Beach. The stress results in significant health consequences for staff, including alcoholism, breakdowns, and marital strife. Moses fosters a culture of relentless productivity, illustrating the personal toll of his ambitious developments.
The section on how Moses engages with the wealthy is not elaborated upon due to missing content.
Moses’ development of parks and beaches garners public adoration even as he frequently operates outside legal and ethical boundaries. The end goal – the creation of popular recreational areas – often justifies his means, from redirecting funds to flouting legal injunctions. Public support and the sunk cost fallacy allow for continued funding, casting a shadow on the legacy of Moses’ developments as they come at the cost of legal and ethical integrity.
1-Page Summary
As the end of Al Smith's governorship approaches, Robert Moses rapidly acquires land for parkways and state parks, leveraging his connections and bending rules to amass more property than ever before for his projects.
Robert Moses resorts to utilizing government-owned land and trading deals to acquire land at a fraction of its market value. He expands Long Island's state park space from 200 acres to 9,700 acres across 14 parks in less than three years.
In one instance, Moses turns to a Yale classmate, who happens to work for Herbert Hoover, the Secretary of Commerce, to acquire 600 acres on Fire Island Beach that is critical for his parkway projects. These lands are secured not through typical means but through connections and favors, employing strategies from early in his career, such as making agreements with adversaries to achieve his objectives.
Moses's use of political connections further manifests when a politically connected lawyer forms a corporation specifically to purchase 265 acres of land necessary for the Meadowbrook Causeway. Additionally, with the support of Nassau County GOP boss G. Wilbur Dowdy, Moses secures building contracts for Dowdy's brother-in-law's contractor.
Despite an initial referendum loss, Moses gains control of Jones Beach after a successful reversal vote. He also acquires miles of land from the Nassau County Board of Supervisors to proceed with the Southern State Parkway, combining this land with New York City-owned property.
Moses learns that Babylon Township has been leasing out "Bay Bottom" without legal ownership, a revelation he uses to blackmail the town council. He pressures them into a referendum to give him the Jones Beach land, threate ...
Robert Moses continues to expand his power and influence, pursues land for his parkways ruthlessly
The attempts by urban planner Robert Moses to build parkways across Long Island sparked contention, particularly with regards to which land would be used for these new routes.
Moses often visited Long Island farmers in the evenings, aiming to charm them into selling their land for his parkway projects. If these farmers showed resistance to selling their property, Moses did not hesitate to employ hardball tactics by threatening to condemn the property. Despite these aggressive strategies, wealthy landowners mounted significant resistance to Moses’ parkway plans, fearing that the public parks and roads would bring the "wrong kind of people" near their opulent estates.
Moses, known for his inflexibility, did make concessions for the wealthy and politically influential. For instance, he altered the Northern State Parkway route to avoid cutting through Otto Kahn's esteemed golf course after Kahn contributed $10,000 towards funding land surveys. The parkway's trajectory was also moved south multiple times to accommodate objections from other affluent landholders.
In stark contrast, small farmers like Ja ...
Moses clashes with Long Island farmers and land barons over parkway routes
As Robert Moses's authority expands, his attitude towards collaborators and critics becomes more dismissive and uncompromising.
Moses begins to show his indifference to the opinions and authority of other key figures in governance. After securing the support he needs and acquiring power, Moses shows little respect for the budget requests from the State Parks Council and treats its members poorly, indicating his disregard for their differing methods and approaches.
Moses targets anyone who opposes his swift and uncompromising development tactics, including spreading unfounded rumors. One notable example is his aggressive defamation of Ansley Wilcox and Judge Clearwater, whom he accuses of corruption, damaging their reputations.
Despite Wilcox's persistence in trying to clear his name, Moses disregards his efforts. Wilcox's detailed letter is ignored and put away, leaving his work and contribution to Niagara park history virtually forgotten. Moses takes this erasure a step further by removing plaques with Wilcox's name and replacing them with his own. Places like the Robert Moses Parkway and the proposed Robert Moses Dam replace Wilcox's legacy in the park.
Roman Mars recount ...
Moses shows increasing arrogance and refusal to compromise as his power grows
Governor Al Smith, described as a populist figure, continues to support Robert Moses despite various controversies. Smith uses his political leverage to provide Moses with the protection and resources needed to carry on with his ambitious projects.
Al Smith displays a staunch willingness to protect Robert Moses amidst rising legislative opposition and public controversy. When Hutchinson and Hewitt, Republican Committee Chairmen, attempted to impede Moses' progress, Governor Smith diffused their protest by engaging them in a night of drinking and distraction, effectively neutralizing their complaints and allowing Moses to carry on with his work. Moreover, Smith even steps in to shield Moses from calls for his resignation, refusing to dismiss Moses over his contentious plans for Jones Beach, which demonstrated contempt for his budget allowance.
Smith's support for Moses extends beyond mere protection. Despite reservations about the legality of Moses' appropriation of the Taylor estate, Al Smith chooses to sign the documents after being incensed by wealthy landowners' scorn for the city's working class. He later delays legislative action to coincide with peak public demand for parks, which secures the necessary approval of funds for Moses' projects.
Smith further fortifies Moses' position by delivering a radio speech rallying public support behind Moses' parks, framing it as a battle between the rich and the need of common people for public spaces. This maneuver culminates in both Al Smith and the Republican-led legislature agreeing to provide Moses with the funding needed in 1926, enabling the commencement of Moses' park projects.
When Moses faced a $22,000 fine and personal financial scrutiny, Smith interve ...
Al Smith continues to protect and enable Moses despite controversies
Robert Moses, appointed by Al Smith, becomes Secretary of State for New York, a position encompassing a wide range of duties, control over jobs, and a short-lived influence in the boxing industry.
As Secretary of State, Moses controls a significant amount of patronage, due to the high number of people seeking licenses from the department he oversees. His responsibilities include various miscellaneous functions such as filing incorporation papers, compiling election results, and licensing auctioneers and private detectives. In addition to these duties, Moses is expected to coordinate state construction and collaborate with the state's cabinet.
Despite opposition from Albany, Moses secures the appointment, thanks in part to Al Smith's popularity and the media portraying Moses as the "parks man" opposite the "fat cats," casting his appointment in a favorable light.
Moses also has oversight of New York's athletic commission, which includes the regulation of the boxing industry. He confronts endemic corruption, particularly around boxing ticket sales. Moses tries to ensure fairness in ticket distribution, hoping to allow average citizens to purchase tickets. However, h ...
Moses becomes Secretary of State for New York, gains more power and responsibilities
The podcast delves into Robert Moses' challenges and reluctances in regulating the boxing industry in New York, highlighting his struggles against systemic corruption and his eventual retreat.
Initially, the podcast suggests that Moses did not exhibit much enthusiasm for purging corruption from the boxing industry and contrasts this with his interest in reforming parks, which were a significant source of his influence and power. His tentative approach towards tackling the boxing corruption is implied to be a calculated move, stemming from an understanding that the public interest in addressing boxing controversies was limited in comparison to other areas under his control.
Furthermore, the podcast indicates that Moses may have felt intimidated by the daunting prospe ...
Moses takes on regulation of boxing in New York, struggles with corruption there
The work ethic and expectations set by Moses for his employees are intense and often lead to significant physical and emotional strain.
Moses' staff, known as "Moses' men," experience extreme pressure due to the demanding work environment he creates. They often work from 9 a.m. to midnight on many days. His expectations are high, and he's known to react with anger or coldness when he doesn't get what he wants. Despite the long hours, employees note that Moses never seems to tire and keeps them busy late into the night.
The intense work pace set by Moses has serious consequences for the health and well-being of his employees. Caro mentions that more than one becomes an alcoholic, some suffer nervous breakdowns, and marital problems are not uncommon. In a tragic case, at least one person who worked for Moses committed suicide, though Caro does not reveal the individual's identity out of respect for the person's family.
The crew's dedication to their work is further exemplified by their efforts on Jones Beach during the challenging winter of 1927 to 1928. Workers endure freezing conditions as they live on ships, work all day dredging and spreading sand over 17 miles, and kneel in freezing sand to plant beach grass by hand during windy, cold weather. The hardship of the job is illustrated by an incident where surveyors, trapped on the beach for 10 days due to freezing conditions, sur ...
Moses pushes his employees extremely hard, some crack under the strain
It appears that there is missing content to elaborate on the topic outlined. Without additional information, an in-depth analysis or description cannot be provided. If there is specific content or context relating to Moses making deals and compromises with the wealthy w ...
Moses makes deals and comprises with the wealthy but refuses to bend for regular citizens
Robert Moses, notorious for developing popular parks and beaches on Long Island, frequently chose expedients that skirted or outright broke ethical and legal standards, though the public largely embraced the resultant recreational spaces.
The public's enthusiasm for new recreational areas developed by Moses is evident. For example, the demand at Long Island state parks, with attendance exceeding half a million by summer’s end, and the consistent need to add more lockers at the Valley Stream State Park bathhouse to accommodate an influx of visitors, illustrate this popularity. Moses’s work is well-received by the public, particularly highlighted by the "crown jewel" Jones Beach, an enduringly popular location acknowledged for its appeal even by critics.
Moses conceived of Jones Beach as a grand recreational complex and moved ahead with his plans despite legal injunctions. He strategically redirected funds earmarked for other purposes, such as tree nursery programs and oyster culturing, to his park and road building projects. When Moses faced a lawsuit and did not show up for a deposition, it suggested his disregard for the legal proceedings.
He forcefully attempted to acquire land in Babylon Township for his developments and violated the agreed sequence for starting the Northern State Parkway. He also disregarded a court ruling against his use of non-union labor for building bathhouses, reinforcing the belief that the end result—a public good like parks—could justify these means.
Despite the breaking of laws and bypassing of rules, Moses faced minimal consequences, evidenced by a trivial six-cent fine, and even retained land from the Taylor estate despite a court ruling deeming his acquisition illegal. The building was already in place, people were using the park, and judges were loath to dismantle established parks, suggesting an implicit acceptance that the ends justify the means.
Moses had significant financial leverage, demonstrated by having immediate access to $1 million from a $15 million budget, which he used fo ...
Moses builds popular parks and beaches on Long Island but often breaks laws and rules
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser