Tackling The Tom Brady Roast w/ Jimmy Carr | 2 Bears, 1 Cave
The hosts of 2 Bears, 1 Cave, Tom Segura and Bert Kreischer, share their experiences from the recent Netflix Is a Joke roast event. They shed light on the electric atmosphere, standout performances like Nikki Glaser's, and Kevin Hart's adept hosting skills. The episode also features insights from guest Jimmy Carr, a comedian who transitioned from corporate marketing and achieved international acclaim through his sharp wit and dedication to evolving his craft.
Segura, Kreischer, and Carr delve into the nature of comedy, emphasizing the importance of authenticity and the collaborative yet competitive dynamic within the industry. They also navigate the complexities of handling controversy and criticism, offering perspectives on finding a balance between artistic expression and societal norms.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the May 13, 2024 episode of the 2 Bears, 1 Cave with Tom Segura & Bert Kreischer
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
The Netflix is a Joke Roast Event
Bert Kreischer and Tom Segura's Unique Presentation
Kreischer and Segura proposed a multimedia-based roast presentation acting as a palate cleanser, despite initial hesitation about roasting due to inexperience. Collaborating with writers, they crafted a well-received segment combining commentary and images.
The Electric Atmosphere and Standout Performances
The roast featured an enthusiastic audience, especially receptive to standout sets like Nikki Glaser's. Glaser received praise from Kreischer, Segura, Carr, and others for her brilliant delivery and flawless execution of the roast format.
Kevin Hart's Hosting Prowess
Kevin Hart's energetic hosting and deft improvisational skills were commended by Segura and Kreischer for seamlessly blending scripted and off-the-cuff moments while keeping the show's momentum high.
Impressions and Observations
Shane Gillis Overcoming "Cancellation"
Carr and Kreischer reflect on how the comedy community rallied behind Shane Gillis after his "cancellation" early in his career, before widespread fame. Carr suggests cancellation can paradoxically boost a comedian's profile.
Jimmy Carr's Background and Career
From Corporate Marketing to Acclaimed Comedian
Originally working in marketing, Carr transitioned to comedy by honing a talent for punchy one-liners and wordplay. He's transcended perceptions of his "posh" persona through his uniquely sharp comedic voice.
Dedication to Continual Growth and International Success
Despite acclaim, Carr maintains passion for live performance and evolving his craft. He's currently touring extensively, including upcoming North American dates after a recent Netflix special release.
The Nature of Comedy and the Comedic Process
Finding One's Authentic Voice
Carr, Kreischer, and Segura emphasize the importance of comedians discovering their own unique style rather than imitating others to achieve true comedic success.
Collaborative Yet Competitive Community
While the comedy scene fosters camaraderie and shared experiences, comedians must also set themselves apart through ongoing personal growth. This balance of collaboration and competition propels the field forward.
Navigating Controversy and Critics
Comedians display understanding toward navigating controversies, with Carr having faced "cancellation." They view comedy as a space for context-specific performance not necessarily reflective of personal beliefs.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- The Netflix is a Joke Roast Event is a comedy special where comedians roast each other in a humorous and often edgy manner. It is a popular format in the comedy world where comedians take turns making fun of each other in front of a live audience. These events are known for their sharp wit, playful insults, and camaraderie among comedians. The Netflix is a Joke Roast Event showcases the comedic talents of various well-known comedians and provides a platform for them to showcase their skills in a lighthearted and entertaining way.
- The roast format in comedy involves comedians humorously insulting or making fun of a specific individual or group in a lighthearted and often exaggerated manner. It typically takes place in a live event where comedians take turns delivering their roast jokes. Roasts are known for their sharp wit, clever wordplay, and the balance between humor and respect for the roastee. The audience plays a crucial role in the energy of the event, reacting to the jokes and creating a lively atmosphere.
- Shane Gillis faced "cancellation" early in his career when controversial remarks he made came to light, leading to public backlash and his removal from a prominent comedy show. "Cancellation" in this context typically involves widespread criticism, social media condemnation, and professional repercussions due to offensive or inappropriate behavior. Despite this setback, Gillis received support from some in the comedy community and has continued his career in comedy. The term "cancellation" has become associated with public figures facing consequences for their actions or statements, often in the form of public shaming and career setbacks.
- Jimmy Carr transitioned from a career in corporate marketing to comedy by developing a knack for delivering sharp one-liners and clever wordplay. His shift was driven by a passion for humor and a desire to explore his comedic talents beyond the confines of the corporate world. This transition allowed Carr to establish himself as a successful comedian known for his distinct comedic style and quick wit. Through dedication and honing his craft, Carr evolved from his marketing background to become an acclaimed figure in the comedy industry.
- In the comedy scene, camaraderie exists among comedians who share experiences, offer support, and collaborate on projects. However, there is also an inherent sense of competition as comedians strive to distinguish themselves and stand out in a crowded field. This balance of camaraderie and competition motivates comedians to improve their craft while fostering a sense of community within the industry.
Counterarguments
- While Kreischer and Segura's multimedia-based roast presentation was well-received, some purists might argue that traditional stand-up roasting is more authentic and challenging for comedians.
- Praise for Nikki Glaser's performance, though well-deserved, could overshadow other comedians' efforts, who might have also delivered strong but less recognized sets.
- Kevin Hart's hosting style, while energetic and improvisational, might not appeal to everyone, with some preferring a more subdued or different style of comedy.
- The notion that "cancellation" can boost a comedian's profile might not hold true for all; some comedians may suffer long-term damage to their careers.
- Jimmy Carr's transition from corporate marketing to comedy is impressive, but it might also suggest that a background in other fields is necessary for success in comedy, which could be discouraging to those solely dedicated to the craft from the start.
- Emphasizing the importance of finding one's unique style could inadvertently pressure comedians to differentiate themselves prematurely before they've had a chance to naturally develop their voice.
- The balance of camaraderie and competition in comedy is complex, and some might argue that the competitive aspect can create undue stress and hinder the collaborative spirit that fosters creativity.
- Viewing comedy as a context-specific performance might not always hold up, as some critics believe comedians should be held accountable for their words, regardless of the comedic context.
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
The Netflix is a Joke roast event
Bert Kreischer and Tom Segura share their experience participating in the Netflix is a Joke event, a roast that featured various comedians and garnered an enthusiastic audience response.
Bert and Tom's involvement in the roast
Kreischer and Segura, initially hesitant due to their lack of roasting experience, created a unique and successful presentation for the event.
They were initially hesitant to participate due to lack of roasting experience
Bert and Tom were apprehensive about participating in the roast of Tom Brady. About a month before the event, they received a call inviting them to roast, and Tom Segura expressed concern that they wouldn't gain anything given their inexperience with roasting.
They proposed a unique, multimedia-based presentation format that was well-received
Despite their concerns about roasting, Bert and Tom decided to propose a different approach. Segura likened their presentation to a "weekend update" using commentary paired with images. This multimedia-based presentation acted as a palate cleanser during the long roast and was a refreshing change for the audience.
They collaborated with the writers to craft an engaging and memorable set
The duo met with Netflix and writers to discuss various ideas for their roast segment. Segura crafted a script that was polished with input from Kreischer and Mike, followed by further refinement from professional writers. Kreischer praised the writers, including Ray, Pat, Sarah Tiana, Mike Lawrence, Mike Gibbons, and Jeff Ross, for their excellent contributions which elevated some of the best moments in their set.
The energy and atmosphere of the roast event
The atmosphere of the roast was electric, punctuated by standout performances and the challenge of keeping the audience engaged.
...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The Netflix is a Joke roast event
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- A roast event is a comedic performance where a guest of honor is subjected to jokes, teasing, and humorous insults by a series of comedians or speakers. The structure typically involves each comedian taking turns to deliver their roast, often focusing on the guest of honor's quirks, achievements, or public persona. Roasts are known for their sharp humor, playful jabs, and the balance between wit and good-natured ribbing. The event usually culminates in a final roast by a designated "roast master" or a special guest, bringing the comedic evening to a close.
- Nikki Glaser is a well-known comedian known for her stand-up comedy and appearances on various TV shows. Jimmy Carr is a British comedian famous for his dark humor and quick wit, particularly in the realm of roasting. Jeff Ross is a seasoned comedian and "Roastmaster General" known for his work in comedy roasts, including the Comedy Central Roasts.
- In a roast event, the audience expects humor that pushes boundaries and often involves making fun of the roastee and other parti ...
Counterarguments
- While Kreischer and Segura's multimedia-based presentation was well-received, it could be argued that traditional roasting skills are essential and their approach might not be as impactful in a typical roast setting.
- The collaboration with writers, while successful, might overshadow the comedians' own voices and comedic style, potentially making the set less personal or authentic.
- The enthusiastic audience response to standout performances could be influenced by factors other than the comedians' skills, such as audience expectations or the novelty of the event.
- The challenge of keeping the audience engaged throughout a long show might indicate a ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Impressions and observations of other comedians
The comedy landscape is ever-changing and vibrant. Comedians Tom Segura, Bert Kreischer, Jimmy Carr, and others share their observations on their peers' performances and the challenges faced within their profession.
Kevin Hart's strong hosting and comedic delivery
Kevin Hart's role as a host has garnered admiration from his contemporaries for his energetic presence and comedic prowess.
Praised for his ability to keep the energy high and the jokes flowing
Tom Segura admires Kevin Hart's excellent hosting abilities. Similarly, Bert Kreischer lauds Hart for his exceptional improvisational skills and his seamless integration of off-script moments with prepared material, demonstrating his agility in navigating both the prompter and the live audience effectively.
Nikki Glaser's masterful roasting set
Nikki Glaser's ability to deliver a roasting set with finesse and impact has not gone unnoticed, with her peers considering her performance exemplary.
Her set was structurally and stylistically brilliant, perfectly executing the roast format
Tom Segura calls Nikki Glaser's roast set a masterclass, praising its structure, lines, and cadence. Kreischer mentions a moment involving Kim Kardashian that elevated the impact of Glaser's performance despite an initial potential for bombing. Both Jimmy Carr and Segura remark on her ability to perform confidently within the roast's script, successfully eliciting laughter regardless of initial booing from the audience.
Beyond the immediate audience, Georgia discusses the buzz that Glaser's performance generated, with her friends eagerly anticipating her set. Kreischer affirms that her performance was notably effective, as evidenced by him sharing Glaser's jokes with his daughter, and uses the colloquial “destroyed” to describe Glaser's exceptional performance.
Shane Gillis' experience of being "canceled" before gaining fame
Shane Gillis's journey through adversity and toward acceptance within the comedy community underscores the complexities of contemporary comedic careers.
Overcoming adversity and gaining support from the comedy community
The comedy community has shown solidarity in the face of controversy. Carr and Kre ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Impressions and observations of other comedians
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- In the comedy community, being "canceled" typically means facing public backlash or condemnation for controversial remarks or actions. This can lead to a comedian losing opportunities, fans, or industry support. However, some comedians have experienced a resurgence in popularity after being "canceled," as their defiance or handling of the situation can resonate positively with audiences and peers. The term "cancellation" in comedy often sparks discussions about free speech, artistic integrity, and the boundaries of humor in today's society.
- Shane Gillis faced backlash and was dropped from a prominent comedy show shortly after being hired due to controversial remarks he made in the past. Despite this setback, some comedians like Jimmy Carr and Bert Kreischer supported Gillis publicly, highlighting the solidarity within the comedy community. Gillis's situation sparked discussions about cancel culture, the impact of controversial material on comedians' careers, and the importance of standing by one's work in the face of societal criticism. The incident shed light on the complexities and challenges faced by comedians in navigating public scrutiny and industry acceptance.
- In the comedy industry, comedians often form a tight-knit community where they support each other through challenges and controversies. This support can manifest in various ways, such as rallying around a fellow comedian facing backlash or sharing insights and experiences to navigate difficult situations. The dynamics of support and camaraderie among comedians play a significant role in shaping individual careers and the overall landscape of comedy. This solidarity can help comedians like Shane Gillis navigate setbacks and ...
Counterarguments
...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Jimmy Carr's background and career
Jimmy Carr is known for his distinctive, sharp appearance, always being very well dressed, and his remarkable wit. His journey to becoming an acclaimed comedian spans a surprising career transition and an unyielding dedication to his craft.
Carr's early corporate career and transition to stand-up comedy
Before embarking on his journey as a stand-up comedian, Jimmy Carr had a decidedly different professional life.
His initial focus on one-liners and wordplay
Originally working in marketing for a big oil company, Carr decided to leave his corporate job to pursue a career in comedy. His early comedy style gravitated towards one-liners, demonstrating a quick, punchy approach reminiscent of his distinct comedic style today. When he started, Carr could write and think in one-liners, a talent that he maintained throughout his evolving career. His first Edinburgh show was alongside Ricky Gervais and Steve Merchant back in either 2000 or 2001, marking his early days in stand-up comedy.
Navigating the class system and perceptions of his background in the UK
Carr delves into the UK's class system and acknowledges that he is perceived as quite posh. However, he notes that he actually comes from a family of Irish immigrants who moved to the UK in the early '70s for work. The contrast between his actual background and his public persona is something Carr finds helpful in navigating the entertainment industry.
Carr's current standing as an acclaimed and respected comedian
Carr has not only established himself in the world of comedy but has also successfully adapted and grown through time.
His dedication to continually improving and evolving his craft
Bert Kreischer and Tom Segura share their memory of meeting Carr in Montreal about seven or eight years prior, recounting that even though he had achieved much by then, Carr was still passionate about getting on stage out of sheer love for stand-up comedy. This dedication is reflected in Carr's recent activities. He mentions that his ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Jimmy Carr's background and career
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- Jimmy Carr's early comedy style was centered around one-liners, which are short, punchy jokes that deliver humor quickly. He had a talent for crafting witty wordplay that often involved clever twists on language or unexpected punchlines. This style of comedy is characterized by its brevity and sharpness, aiming to elicit quick laughs from the audience. Carr's ability to deliver these concise and clever jokes helped establish his comedic identity and set him apart in the world of stand-up comedy.
- Jimmy Carr's family background as Irish immigrants contrasts with his perceived posh image in the UK. Despite his posh public persona, Carr's family roots lie in Irish immigrants who moved to the UK in the early '70s for work. This contrast between his actual background and public image adds complexity to his identity and influences how he navigates the entertainment industry.
- Jimmy Carr's humorous comparison of his appearance on The Tonight Show to its impact in the 90s highlights the historical significance of the show in launching comedians' careers. In the 90s, a successful appearance on The Tonight Show could significantly boost a comedian's visibility and success. Carr's jest about this impact reflects his understanding of the evolving landscape of comedy and the changing dynamics ...
Counterarguments
...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
The nature of comedy and the comedic process
Discussing the intricacies of comedy, Jimmy Carr and other comedians reflect on the importance of personal growth, the joy of the craft, and the interconnectedness of the comedy community.
The importance of finding one's authentic comedic voice
Carr articulates the evolution of his comedic style, starting with shorter jokes and gravitating towards longer bits, revealing a journey toward authenticity. The avoidance of merely imitating others is crucial, as success in comedy arises from being true to oneself. Authenticity differentiates comedians, despite crossover among fan bases. The tragedy lies in those who never find their authentic voice, as Carr emphasizes the significance of speaking in one's unique style. Bert Kreischer further illustrates this point through an observation that kids often mimic popular characters like Borat or Ace Ventura, highlighting the importance of finding their own voice rather than impersonating others. Tom Segura concurs, adding that while mimicry can be a starting point, the real draw should be the joy of comedy itself.
The collaborative and competitive aspects of the comedy scene
The comedians showcase camaraderie within their circle, with Kreischer describing the surprise and admiration he felt when encountering a unique and skilled comedian, which links to the process of discovering one’s own voice. Kreischer shares an anecdote showcasing the supportive teasing among comedians, and he and Segura reminisce about Carr's dedication to stand-up. The Comedy Store in London is mentioned as a hub of community for comedians, indicating the importance of physical spaces where comedians can congregate and share experiences.
Carr discusses the possibility of teaching comedy and working on a book and maybe a course, suggesting collaborative efforts to demystify comedy for aspiring comedians. The respect for individual styles becomes apparent once comedians reach a certain proficiency, with Segura suggesting that preference for a comedian becomes a matter of taste. The scene is described as "out for ourselves, but in it together," emphasizing both individuality and community.
While comedi ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The nature of comedy and the comedic process
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- The comedic process involves comedians developing their unique comedic style, which evolves over time. It emphasizes the importance of authenticity and finding one's own voice rather than imitating others. Comedians navigate a balance between collaboration and competition within the comedy community, supporting each other while continually refining their individual acts. This dynamic interaction between comedians keeps the comedy scene vibrant and evolving.
- The interconnectedness of the comedy community highlights the close relationships and support networks that exist among comedians. This interconnectedness is evident in the camaraderie, shared experiences, and mutual respect within the comedy scene. Comedians often collaborate, share insights, and provide feedback to help each other grow and succeed in their craft. Physical spaces like comedy clubs serve as hubs where comedians come together to perform, socialize, and build a sense of community.
- The tragedy of not finding one's authentic voice in comedy signifies the loss of individuality and originality in a comedian's work. It can lead to a lack of connection with the audience and hinder the comedian's growth and success in the industry. Without authenticity, comedians may struggle to stand out and create a lasting impact in the competitive world of comedy. Finding one's authentic voice is crucial for personal fulfillment and establishing a unique identity in the comedy scene.
- The significance of speaking in one's unique style in comedy emphasizes the importance of authenticity and originality. Developing a distinct comedic voice sets a comedian apart from others and helps them connect with their audience on a deeper level. It involves finding a way to express humor that is true to one's personality and experiences, creating a more genuine and engaging performance. By avoiding imitation and embracing their individuality, comedians can stand out in a crowded field and leave a lasting impact on their audience.
- In the comedy scene, collaboration involves comedians supporting each other, sharing experiences, and showcasing camaraderie. Competition exists as comedians strive to refine their individual acts and stand out in a crowded field. This balance between collaboration and competition drives comedians to improve while fostering a sense of community within the comedy world. The dynamic interplay between working together and vying for success is a fundamental aspect of the comedic process.
- Comedians often engage in playful banter or teasing with each other as a form of support and camaraderie. This teasing can involve making jokes or humorous remarks about each other's performances or personalities. It is a way for comedians to bond, show affection, and create a lighthearted atmosphere within the comedy community. This dynamic helps build relationships and fosters a sense of unity among comedians.
- "Canceled" in comedy typically refers to a situation where a comedian faces public backlash, often on social media, for a joke or behavior deemed offensive or inappropriate. This backlash can lead to consequences such as shows being canceled, loss of opportunities, or damage to the comedian's reputation. Comedians sometimes address being "canceled" by making jokes about the situation or issuing apologies to manage ...
Counterarguments
- Authenticity is important, but some comedians have found success through personas or characters that are not necessarily authentic to their off-stage selves.
- While personal growth is highlighted, some comedians may argue that consistency in comedic style can also be a key to success, as audiences appreciate knowing what to expect.
- The joy of the craft is subjective, and not all comedians may find the process joyful; for some, it may be a means to an end or a struggle for relevance.
- The idea that kids should develop their own comedic style may overlook the natural learning process that involves imitation as a foundational step.
- The camaraderie in the comedy community might not be universal; some comedians experience isolation or rivalry.
- The Comedy Store's role as a community hub may not be as central in the digital age where online platforms can serve similar functions.
- Collaborative efforts to demystify comedy could be seen as reducing the art form to a set of teachable techniques, potentially undermining the mystery and spontaneity that some believe are essential to comedy.
- The notion that preference for a comedian is a matter of taste might oversimplify the complex factors that contribute to a comedian's success or failure.
- The description of the comedy scene as "out for ourselves, but in it together" may not capture the full spectrum of exp ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
