The Raw Milk Controversy: Both Sides of the Argument

Is it beneficial to drink raw milk? Do the benefits outweigh the risks? Why has raw milk become a point of political contention?

California halted raw milk production earlier this month after finding a virus in milk samples, adding fuel to a resurgent national raw milk controversy. Many Americans believe they should have the right to consume unpasteurized dairy products while others claim it’s dangerous.

Keep reading to learn about both sides of the raw milk debate.

The Debate Around Raw Milk

Recently, a raw milk controversy has arisen in the US. Raw milk is milk that hasn’t undergone pasteurization, a process that involves heating milk to a specific temperature for a set period to kill harmful bacteria. Pasteurized milk, in contrast with raw milk, has been treated to eliminate potential pathogens, making it safer for consumption.

Pasteurization was introduced in the US in the early 1900s to combat milk-borne illnesses. The process became widespread by the 1920s with the establishment of the Standard Milk Ordinance in 1924—known today as the national Pasteurized Milk Ordinance.

Despite a surge in interest in raw milk consumption in recent years, it remains a niche product in the US: Just 4.4% of adults (11 million) say they drink it at least once a year, while 1% drink it every week. 

The Argument for Unpasteurized Milk

Raw milk supporters point to a range of advantages they say outweigh the potential risks of raw milk consumption:

• Health benefits. Advocates argue raw milk contains helpful nutrients, enzymes, and bacteria that pasteurization reduces or eliminates, potentially improving digestive function and immune support.  
• Economic opportunity. Small farmers can earn higher profits through direct-to-consumer raw milk sales, as these products typically command premium prices.
• Personal freedom. Supporters frame raw milk access as a fundamental right, arguing government restrictions infringe on Americans’ ability to choose what they want to consume.

The Argument Against Unpasteurized Milk

Major health organizations, including the CDC, Food and Drug Administration, and World Health Organization, warn that raw milk’s risks outweigh any potential benefits. They cite several key concerns:

• Health hazards. Raw milk can harbor dangerous bacteria like E. coli, Listeria, and Salmonella, posing particular risks to children, the elderly, pregnant women, and people with weakened immune systems.
• Documented illnesses. Between 1998 and 2018, raw milk caused 202 outbreaks leading to 2,645 illnesses, 228 hospitalizations, and three deaths, mostly affecting children. During the same period, pasteurized milk caused nine outbreaks resulting in 2,133 illnesses, 33 hospitalizations, and three deaths.
• Detection problems. Research shows that up to a third of raw milk samples contain harmful bacteria and other disease-causing organisms, even from healthy animals and seemingly high-quality milk. Testing can’t reliably detect these dangers since contamination varies daily, bacteria aren’t evenly distributed in milk, and some pathogens can cause illness even in very small amounts.

Is Cow Milk Even Good for You?

Despite what many of us were told growing up, milk might not be as good for us as we initially thought. In the book The China Study, Dr. T. Colin Campbell and Thomas M. Campbell explain why cow milk is actually harmful to your health:

• Milk increases acid in the body, increasing your risk of osteoporosis.
• Drinking milk increases the growth hormone IGF-1 and blocks your production of vitamin D, increasing your risk for prostate cancer.
• Multiple studies have found that infants weaned early and fed formula with cow’s milk have a 50-60% higher risk of developing Type 1 diabetes.
• Casein, the primary protein in milk, has been shown to increase carcinogen levels in cells.

Looking Ahead 

Raw milk’s political future may be at a turning point. While only a small fraction of Americans currently consume raw milk, recent data shows dramatic growth, with weekly sales jumping between 21% and 65% compared to last year. This surge in demand, combined with the incoming Trump administration’s stance on minimizing regulation, signals major changes may lie ahead.

Want to fast-track your learning? With Shortform, you’ll gain insights you won't find anywhere else .

Here's what you’ll get when you sign up for Shortform :

• Complicated ideas explained in simple and concise ways
• Smart analysis that connects what you’re reading to other key concepts
• Writing with zero fluff because we know how important your time is

Start your free trial today!