Is It a Good Time to Refinance? How to Weigh the Pros & Cons

A man with grey hair and beard thinking in front of a house illustrates the question, "Is it a good time to refinance?"

This is a free excerpt from one of Shortform’s Articles. We give you all the important information you need to know about current events and more.

Don't miss out on the whole story. Sign up for a free trial here .

Is it a good time to refinance? What’s the real cost of refinancing your home in today’s market? How can you tell if refinancing is the right move for your financial future?

Mortgage rates are expected to shift in 2025, creating potential opportunities for homeowners to refinance. While some recent home buyers could benefit from current rates, the decision to refinance involves weighing multiple factors, including closing costs, break-even points, and long-term financial impact.

Read on to explore the key considerations and to find practical tips to help you make an informed decision about refinancing your home.

Is It a Good Time to Refinance?

Is it a good time to refinance? Forecasters projected 30-year fixed mortgage rates to reach around 6% by the end of 2024, potentially dipping to the mid-5% range in 2025, depending on Fed actions and economic factors such as labor market performance. As rates drop, more homeowners may decide to sell or refinance, which could boost both refinancing activity and home sales. However, the potential for further growth may be limited, as over 76% of homeowners currently have mortgage rates below 5%—so many might not benefit from refinancing unless rates fall significantly further.

Despite this limitation, certain groups of homeowners stand to gain from the current market conditions. People who recently bought homes are particularly well-positioned to benefit from the current rate environment: roughly 40% of those who took out mortgages in 2023 or 2024 could save at least 0.75% through refinancing at current rates.

Still, experts caution that homeowners considering refinancing should carefully weigh potential savings against various costs and risks:

Closing costs. Refinancing involves appraisal fees, recording charges, title insurance, and bank fees, which can add up to thousands of dollars.
Hidden expenses. Be wary of “no-cost” refinancing options, which often hide fees by rolling them into the loan principal or charging a higher interest rate, potentially increasing the overall loan cost.
Long-term impact. Refinancing to a new 30-year mortgage when you’re already several years into your current mortgage could result in paying more interest over time, even if the monthly payments are lower. Consider the total cost over the life of the loan, not just the monthly payment.
Break-even point. To determine if refinancing makes financial sense, calculate your break-even point by dividing your total refinancing costs by monthly savings. For example, if refinancing costs $5,000 and saves $300 monthly, your break-even point would be roughly 17 months. If you plan to move before reaching this point, refinancing might not be beneficial.

Refinancing Tips From an Industry Insider

In Mortgage Rip-offs and Money Savers, Carolyn Warren writes that many homeowners are attracted to the idea of restructuring their mortgage, especially when presented as a chance to lower their monthly outlays or access extra capital. Choosing to refinance might not always be a wise decision, as it could reduce the equity of the property owner or lead to a more precarious financial situation.

According to Warren, consolidating high-interest credit card debts through refinancing can be advantageous for financial management when approached with meticulous planning and discipline. Warren provides these recommendations:

• When considering refinancing, make sure it results in a significant decrease in your loan’s interest rate.
• Make certain that the length of your mortgage is either maintained or reduced to take advantage of lower interest rates, ensuring that this benefit isn’t offset by a longer repayment period.
• Consolidate your debt through refinancing only as a one-time action to regain financial equilibrium, not as a repeated tactic for dealing with ongoing spending issues.

Warren contends that frequently opting to modify your home loan terms, even when interest rates decline, can lead to a risky cycle of increasing debt and decreasing home equity. Whenever a mortgage undergoes refinancing, the process establishes fresh loan conditions, thereby resetting the period for the principal repayment and leading to the accumulation of more interest throughout the duration of the mortgage.

This tactic, often referred to as “equity stripping,” endangers those nearing retirement by reducing the worth of their home equity, an essential fiscal asset intended to support them during their years of retirement. Dishonest lending agents use a range of deceptive strategies to lure homeowners into refinancing plans that are expensive and deplete their equity. Warren offers this advice:

• Seeking to lower your monthly financial obligations through refinancing might not be as beneficial as it seems if it extends the loan’s term significantly or leads to higher interest rates.
• Be wary if loan officers suggest adding other debts to your mortgage, as it might be more prudent to manage them through careful budgeting, even though consolidating high-interest debt can have its benefits.
• Don’t treat the equity in your home as though it is a readily available source of funds. Tapping into your home’s accumulated value for purchases that aren’t necessary or for high-risk investments can erode the equity you’ve built and may put your financial security at risk.

When you’re thinking about refinancing your mortgage, Warren recommends that you base your decision on a careful assessment of your financial goals and current circumstances, not just on the attractiveness of advertisements or enticing promises. Don’t opt for refinancing just because you’ve been approached with an offer or if the interest rates have decreased slightly.

Is It a Good Time to Refinance? How to Weigh the Pros & Cons