This is a free excerpt from one of Shortform’s Articles. We give you all the important information you need to know about current events and more.
Don't miss out on the whole story. Sign up for a free trial here .
What does it mean to be gender-fluid in today’s world? How have different cultures throughout history viewed and accepted diverse gender identities?
Gender expression and identity have evolved significantly across time and cultures. From ancient Mesopotamian deities to modern social movements, the concept of gender fluidity has shaped societies in fascinating ways.
Keep reading to explore gender fluidity in history and discover how past perspectives continue to influence our modern understanding of gender identity and expression.
Gender Fluidity in History
The umbrella term “gender fluidity” is often used to describe people who identify as transgender (people whose gender identity doesn’t align with the sex they were assigned at birth) or nonbinary (people who don’t identify as exclusively male or female). It might also apply to those who are otherwise gender nonconforming—for example, women who don’t wear makeup and men who wear nail polish.
We’ll explore gender fluidity in history, in both ancient and modern times.
Gender Fluidity in Ancient Times
Throughout history, many societies have operated within rigid gender binaries where roles and expectations were strictly defined. For example, both ancient Greeks and ancient Chinese adhered to strict gender roles, where men were expected to engage in public life and women were expected to manage the home and family. People who deviated from these norms were either marginalized or mythologized to explain their exceptionality.
However, some societies throughout history—such as Mesopotamia and some Native American cultures—allowed for a greater degree of gender fluidity. In Mesopotamia, for instance, the deity Ishtar was linked with gender fluidity and embodied both masculine and feminine traits. Ancient texts describe Ishtar’s fluid gender identity and note that their priests practiced transvestitism.
In his book The Return of the Gods, Jonathan Cahn offers a different perspective on these cultural shifts. He contends that current societal trends regarding gender, sexuality, and religious values stem from a resurgence of pagan deities such as Ishtar and Molech. Cahn connects modern phenomena, such as the celebration of Pride Month and the push for transgender acceptance, to the historical veneration of gods associated with sexual freedom and gender fluidity. He draws parallels between ancient practices and modern discussions about gender, particularly noting the increasing prevalence of gender transitions among young people and evolving views of human identity.
(Shortform note: Ishtar, also known as Ashtoreth or Astarte, was a prominent deity associated with sensuality, gender fluidity, and fertility in ancient Mesopotamian cultures. Her worship involved rituals that celebrated diverse gender expressions, and she was often depicted with attributes symbolizing power, sensuality, and the mysteries of life and death.)
Gender Fluidity in Modern Times
The 1990s brought significant advances, especially after philosopher Judith Butler published Gender Trouble. Butler proposed that gender identity is not something one is, but something one does—an ongoing act shaped by social and cultural contexts. Butler’s perspective emphasized the fluidity of gender and the idea that identity could not be neatly categorized into binary roles. This contributed to a greater cultural understanding of gender theory and helped amplify the voices of those advocating for expanded gender rights.
Despite the growing prominence of gender theory, much of mainstream Western culture initially resisted gender fluidity, as evidenced by hate crimes against LGBT people and the widespread use of the word “gay” as an insult at the turn of the 21st century. However, the advent of social media created new platforms for marginalized voices. This allowed more people to explore their gender identities, challenge traditional norms, and advocate for greater acceptance and equality. As a result, the visibility of diverse gender identities increased significantly, and many nations have expanded legal protections for gender nonconforming people.
Gender fluidity has become more common in the 2020s, due in large part to Generation Z, who are more likely than any other generation to identify as transgender or nonbinary. According to research, among young adults born in the 2000s, transgender identities shot up by 48% from late 2021 to late 2022, while nonbinary identities increased by 60% in the same year. Still, however, the proportion of people identifying as transgender, nonbinary, or otherwise gender-fluid is relatively small: Only around 5% of young adults fell into this category as of 2022.
Reflection & Discussion Questions
- How might our understanding of gender fluidity be different if we had grown up in ancient Mesopotamia or in a Native American culture that recognized multiple gender identities? What can we learn from these historical perspectives?
- The text mentions that social media has created new platforms for marginalized voices. In what ways has social media been both helpful and potentially challenging for discussions about gender identity? What are the benefits and drawbacks of having these conversations online?
- Judith Butler suggests that gender is something one “does” rather than something one “is.” What are your thoughts on this perspective? How might this view change how we think about gender roles in society?
- The statistics show a significant increase in young adults identifying as transgender or nonbinary, yet the overall percentage remains relatively small. What factors might contribute to both the recent increase and the still-limited overall numbers?
- Jonathan Cahn draws parallels between ancient religious practices and modern gender discussions. How do you think religious and cultural beliefs throughout history have shaped our current understanding of gender? How do they continue to influence these discussions today?
Want to fast-track your learning? With Shortform, you’ll gain insights you won't find anywhere else .
Here's what you’ll get when you sign up for Shortform :
- Complicated ideas explained in simple and concise ways
- Smart analysis that connects what you’re reading to other key concepts
- Writing with zero fluff because we know how important your time is
